| OCR Text |
Show - _____ . .... _ .. _ ... _ ...... • I .............. t.ra.'IIhM .....iIIIiIIa&_.. _..... " J. ftome % p.rente .eem'to tUlcrltloe themoelvt,s' tor tht' aoJ\p. of thtflr ohl.lc1ren the r0pl.y 1" mde thFt t thl8 seeming saorlfio f: 1 tne:r-el:Y Th·P,t orcllntary me ,nloi' ,t ,the·.terfl' .elfish 1m thu lx.tend@d· to lnelutl e ,n,:! t\,ct,1on.;:, by 1)\'terpret1ns ,nl action n terUl! of $ lf In th1 wsy the proponent of the view lnttl'est. dtlnltlon'a eAse by Uproot agalnnt disproof" h10h 1e In itself althoub 1t 1 pre.ented _8 1t it oorUll truots wre a C8_a built upon verlfl abl$ t'a,otf. An inter.est'tng exmple of this ,kind or argull'lpnt ap pears in Newman' s suoon·d. speeoh in the Prt4 t t-NeNm.n Deba. t e. Al thoui;h a varl,t1on 1n r.Vtr!8 m"m tloned form or th$ prooedure 1 t 9PfJ-ea,ra to 'tht 'W'ri ter to be 1m11r in Just },)I'incip 1 e. In an,alyt1ng th term,s 1n the Qu!stlon for dbate' 'r$ no'ti' c()m ,to .notb.$r 1nrportRnt ro:rd--nr.unly, 'oes the Bible sanot1on' I.DotlQD! By th. term ,a,not1on we mefl.n OllHfA$.nd, consoqtle ntly thG ,uthorl ty Qf pOF.Jlt1.vp._ rltt0n. divine 1. or ,h9.t(lVH' mey be It reanonmbly held .a qu1v1nt to ueh law. followe t thetor, th t tolert1on 11ll not 0l:'HlC t ion. Suttereno8 is not anotlon. Nunln1p1 leg111tlon is not a,not1.on. An hltorlQ£fl stqtemn t of 'r.:rev,111ng , to,ithful nt).X-rSttlve o.f the euetoms 1 not $;netltjf,}1t 'l.tfe nd.· xp.Httpl$ of srm1nent nnUl is M,t smet1on. The A rovldntll remllflon Qf penalty 1.: not ennotlon. 01 tHlH:tln.g bee towd upon gener$1 prlncipleA. for an ulterior purno. 1 not 0anotlon. The only 8,qute 1de or I!!tf.il.n tlon 1" the d:1 'line nIl nos 1 tlve f.p't'::rob. tlon, plainly @presl.d. lthr 1n definite statute of. by sucb t'o,rmm· of onform. t ton ,9J co ns t t tu t e ,f.'I, full and clar equivalent. It 18 in this eene that w t,.k;e th.f t'l'm .n<':tlon. in the Qtlosti.on before us ;" . . to m:8,n in the debtt 1s pl"Act1e,11y , , point by point enumer-a t Lo n |
