| OCR Text |
Show PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL OF HIS EXPEDITION TO UTAH, 1825 EDITED BY DAVID E. MILLER* INTRODUCTION JL ETER SKENE OGDEN was one of the most widely traveled trapper- explorers to enter the Far West in the first half of the nineteenth century. During the six-year period from 1824-1830 he headed five Snake Country brigades on extensive expeditions into the territory that now comprises the states of Washington, Oregon, California, Nevada, Utah, Idaho, and Montana. It is probably accurate to say that no other man led larger expeditions farther over more unexplored territory or brought in more furs than he did during these active years. He may well have out-traveled Jedediah Smith. Although a Canadian by birth, Peter Skene Ogden was a descendant of early American ancestors. At the time of the American Revolution the Ogden family was divided in its loyalty, part supporting the American struggle for independence, part remaining loyal to Great Britain. At the end of the war British loyalists of the family moved to Canada where Peter was born at Quebec in 1794. Although it was the desire of his family that he follow the profession of law, as his father and grandfather had done, Peter chose a more adventurous life. At the age of seventeen he joined the Northwest Fur Company, a British concern, and remained in its employ until 1821 when that company was merged with Hudson's Bay Company. While employed by the Northwest Company, Ogden rose rapidly, being advanced to "partnership" after only nine years service. During that time he proved his ability as a leader in the rough competition between his firm and the Hudson's Bay Company. Evidently because of his energetic hostility to the rival company, Ogden found himself without a job at the time of the merger *Dr. Miller is associate professor of history at the University of Utah, and is recognized as an authority on the Great Salt Lake and other phases of Utah history. He wishes to express appreciation to the University of Utah Research Committee for a grant of funds for research incident to the preparation of this article. 160 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY and would likely not have been employed by Hudson's Bay Company had not George Simpson, newly appointed governor of the northern district, interceded in his behalf.1 By 1824 Hudson's Bay Company experience in the Snake River Country had proved almost totally unsatisfactory-expensive and dangerous with heavy loss of life. So unpopular had the region become that no volunteer could be found to take over the difficult assignment of leadership of the expeditions. Yet Governor Simpson thought the country could be made profitable under proper management. He was sure that the "empty headed"2 Alexander Ross who had led the previous Snake expedition was not the one for the job. But there was one man who had proved his ability and Simpson knew "no one in the country better qualified to do it justice than Mr. Ogden."3 So Peter Skene Ogden, age 30, "short, dark, and exceedingly tough,"4 was given his command, which he accepted with "the utmost readiness." In order to begin to understand the nature of Ogden's Snake River expedition that brought him into Utah in the spring of 1825, one must realize how large a party it actually was. Ogden lists the names of his men at the beginning of his journal,5 indicating how many guns, horses, and traps each had. His compilation shows 58 men, 61 guns, 268 horses, and 352 traps. He does not list himself. Kittson, while not listing the men, adds other details of interest. Says he: "The party is now together consisting of 22 lodges which contain besides Mr. Ogden and myself, Charles McKay an interpreter of the Piegan Language 10 Engages 53 fremen and lads, 30 Women and 35 Children, all well furnished in arms ammunition Horses and Traps, able in all 'Ample biographical material concerning Ogden is found in T. C. Elliott, "Peter Skene Ogden, Fur Trader," Oregon Historical Quarterly, XI (1910), 229-78, and in his notes and introductions to the Ogden journals in the same volume. Dr. Burt Brown Barker, in his Introduction to Pefer Skene Ogden's Snake Country Journals. 1824-25 and 1825-26. E. E. Rich, ed. (77ie Publications of the Hudson's Bay Record Society, XIII [London, 1950]), xi-lxxix also gives interesting biographical material. 'Frederick Merk, ed., Fur Trade and Empire. George Simpson's Journal (Cambridge, 1931), 46. 'Ibid. 'Robert Glass Cleland, This Reckless Breed of Men (New York, 1950), 315. 'Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit. 2, 3. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 161 appearances to face any War party brought into the plains."6 This party of 131 people was supplemented from time to time by the addition of others7 and by births-at least three babies were born during the first weeks of the expedition, during the severest cold winter. To supply food for such a formidable group was a major task, especially since Simpson's policy was for expeditions to live "off the land" rather than rely on European goods. Hence the constant interest in elk, deer, buffalo, and other game as well as beaver. The latter animal was a major item on the menu; if trapping was good the expedition was well fed even though no other game could be found. If both sources of supply failed, horses must be slaughtered for food, a practice resorted to only in the face of starvation. To find forage for the large herd of horses was also a major task. One of Ogden's chief responsibilities, then, was to steer a course that would produce the necessities of life. It is interesting to note that at least 30 of the men took their wives8 and families along and although the women and children sometimes caused friction and delay, the women, at least, were an important part of the expedition. They had such duties as preparing the camp, skinning the catch, and preparing the pelts. Journal references to the women are very few; they are mentioned only when some special circumstances warrant it- the birth of a child, sickness that would delay the advance, etc. Whether or not Ogden's Indian wife accompanied him is not known. His journal is entirely silent on the subject. It is obvious from the above list that freemen and their families made up the bulk of the personnel. George Simpson describes the freemen as a "worthless and motley crew . . . the very scum of the country and generally outcasts from the Service for misconduct are the most unruly and troublesome gang to deal with in this or perhaps any other part of the World, are under no control & feel their own independence they therefore require "Ibid., 209, 210. This list of personnel differs somewhat from that given by Alexander Ross, the source of information about it before the publication of diese journals. See Oregon Historical Quarterly. XI, 248. 'Jedediah Smitii and six companions joined the party on December 29, 1824, according to Kittson. One man returned to Flathead Post and came back with his wife and family. Indians later joined die expedition. "All Indians. 162 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY very superior management to make any thing of them . . . ."• Ogden had numerous occasions to verify Simpson's judgment. It was one of his major tasks to keep* the camp in order and moving harmoniously forward. Both Ogden and William Kittson (Ogden's "right hand man" of the 1824-25 expedition) kept detailed daily journals of their movements, and Kittson drafted a remarkably accurate map showing the route and camp sites, principal streams and mountains. Until the publication of these journals practically all that was known of Ogden's activities during that season was obtained from his two letters to company officials. The first of these was written from "East Fork Missouri" (probably in the Horse Prairie-Beaverhead region of western Montana), July 10, 1825.10 This letter contains considerable detail concerning Ogden's contact with and desertion of many of his men to American trappers during that expedition. The second letter was written July 1, 1826, and contains very little definite information about his 1825 visit to Utah,11 Ogden's reference to Great Salt Lake being the major item of significance in it. Lack of definite and complete information about Ogden's activities has resulted in the accumulation of much inaccurate information (as well as a great deal of historical fact) to form what may logically be called the "Ogden Tradition." With the publication of the 1824-25 journals, however, most of the mystery is removed and Ogden's activities during his first expedition are clarified. One of the most significant facts to remember about these journals is that they compose the earliest contemporary written account of an expedition into northern Utah yet to come to light. Herein are the earliest descriptions of the region-flora, fauna, weather conditions, geography, Indians-as well as the day-by-day record of a large fur brigade. In view of these facts it is difficult to overestimate the value of these documents. The extent of Ogden's penetration into Utah was the subject of a field trip conducted during November, 1951, by Dr. •Merk, op cit. 45. "Oregon Historical Quarterly, XXXV, 107-15. This letter will be cited as "Ogden's letter of July 10, 1825," in notes on the following pages. "Merk, op. cit. 274-77. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 163 C. G. Crampton, Jesse H. Jameson, and the writer.12 During this field trip, Ogden's route from Alexander, Idaho, where he first struck Bear River, to Mountain Green, Utah (the southernmost point of his penetration), was carefully followed, camp sites located, and the area mapped to show the relationship of Ogden's route to present rivers, mountains, and cities. Since only that part of the Ogden journal that describes his movements along Bear River, into Utah, and back out again is to be reproduced here, a brief summary of his four-month trek before he reached Bear River will be of interest. After leaving Flathead Post, located north and west of Missoula, Montana, December 20, 1824, Ogden trapped up the Bitterroot River, through Gibbon Pass (January 13, 1825) to Big Hole River, continuing in the same general direction to the present Armstead region (January 30). Early in February the brigade crossed the continental divide via Lemhi Pass and spent almost two months trapping tributaries of Salmon River, primarily the Lemhi River. From this region Ogden directed his course toward the south in an effort to reach Snake River. Passing by the "three buttes" he struck Snake River, April 6, near the present site of Blackfoot, Idaho. After trapping up Black-foot River some distance, Ogden turned south to the upper waters of Portneuf River (April 20-25), probably in the northwest corner of Caribou County. He was striking as rapidly as possible for Bear River. "For use on this expedition copies of Ogden's and Kittson's journals and Kittson's map were used plus more recent maps, including the following: Maps made in connection with the United States Geographical Surveys West of die lOOtii Meridian, under the direction of Lt. George M. Wheeler, Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army, expeditions of 1877 (diese are among the earliest complete maps of the area); appropriate quadrangles of die United States Department of Interior, Geological Survey; and United States Forest Service maps. Our objective was to trace Ogden's daily movements into Utah and back out again. In this we succeeded very well and were able to locate the route and camp sites with a relatively high degree of accuracy. Of course, no trace of Ogden's camps are still remaining and no attempt was made to pick the exact spot where he pitched his tent. The accompanying map (page 164) is die result of this field work. I wish to express appreciation to Professor Elbert D. Miller, of the University of Utah, Department of Geography, and to Jesse H. Jameson for advice and aid in the drafting of it. McCommon 0 ***• MAY 31 •JUNE I I t ' '*" i ->^e\ tSs*- ' -^>LovaV%!- APRIL 26 f^e o Soda Springs «'7V*\ IGrace I <o •*^$£%*- \ S ^ - ^ ^ o / ^ i ^ X ^ S A P R I L 28-29 -£*S" MAY 30 « ^ - 0 DowneyV^APttL 2 7 * * > ^*C^O!fc-;/£>• = ' - < ^ * - - ,^>-Qv. j^iK> MAY 29 '*w»; " " . ^ V > -SS^SN. ^w>J * Ws' £>*»' *J.DAH0' _ L.UTAH~V \ MAY i/-t->7;- IS* /MAY 3-4 " jFranklin nRichmond ( - * ^ - x mithfield M A Y I 3 - I 4 ^ - O J S ^ 4 ^ ' ^ . \ . < ^ V - c-55* •?&<K I Hjrun kMA^J.-^ <&v 0 7' Brigham • r l;S~ '&Kx&#: v ^ - « S . A>W^ j?>;v ' ^ I Ogde ^ - ^ « l ^ l o u n < a i n Gr.« y % » ^ -V?^- ^ v U 4 ^ / * < * ' " ?* 5 SCALE 10 20 Ml. Peter Skene Ogden's Route to Utah, 1825 A Section of William Kittson's Map of the 1824-25 Journey to the Snake Country 166 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY OGDEN'S JOURNAL13 April 26-June 1, 1825 Tuesday 26th.-Raise Camp & proceeded over a fine plain for 15 miles when we reached Bear River14 a fine large Stream of Water about the 1/8 of a mile in width this River was discovered in 1819 by Michel Bourdon15 & the upper part has been trapped twice but the lower part never has been16 it takes its rise due east & was supposed to be the Rio Colorado & even now Said to be a Fork of the same as our route is to follow it we shall be enabled to ascertain this point17 some traps were set but no appearance of Beaver here our Course this day South east-vegetation is far advanced here.18 "The journal is reproduced by special permission of the Hudson's Bay Record Society and is presented here exactly as it appears in Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit, 40-56. No attempt has been made to correct spelling, punctuation, capitalization, etc. "From his camp site of April 25, Ogden continued in a southeast direction through Portneuf Valley (as shown on the Wheeler map), following approximately the route of the Old Oregon Trail between die big bend of Bear River and the upper waters of die Portneuf. Ogden and his party got their first glimpse of the Bear just below the present town of Alexander, Idaho, and after traversing two miles of rough lava beds, which form the precipitous banks of the stream through this region, they found an approach down to the river and a fairly level area on its west bank where camp was probably made. This is the first point below Alexander where the stream could be reached owing to the lava banks about 150 to 200 feet in height. Gently sloping lands on the east side, immediately across from the camp, would make a ford easily possible. On the east side today is a small cultivated area; the river may be approached by roads from either side. "Ogden's letter of July 10, 1825, states that Bourdon was at Bear River in 1818. See Oregon Historical Quarterly, XXXV, 112. Bourdon had evidently been quite active in the employ of the company. See Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit, 40, note 2. Kittson's entry for this day states that Bourdon gave Bear River its name "from die great number of those animals on its borders." The Ogden expedition would see plenty of bears farther down stream. "Ogden was mistaken in this. He would soon find that aldiough no British expedition had trapped on lower Bear River, a large group of Americans had beaten him to it by one season. "See Ogden's entry for May 22. "Kittson adds die important information that the Americans (Jedediah Smitii and six companions), who had been with the Ogden party much of the time since December 29, 1824, now headed upstream. Compare with Ogden's letter of July 10, 1825, op. cit, 108. Kittson devotes considerable journal space to die Americans. On April 19 he described Jedediah Smith as a "sly, cunning Yankey" which was probably not far from the truth. Kittson's record shows that the Americans were in and out of the Ogden camp several times before they reached Bear River. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 167 Wednesday 27th.-The traps produced but one beaver we crossed the river with our horses19 the waters appear very low we had for three miles a road of rocks & Stones when we came on a fine level plain & proceeded eighteen miles & again Crossed the River20 & found the men who I had Sent to the Sources of Black Foot River21 their Success not great it appears that quarter had been trapped by the Americans last Year we also found Some of the Trappers who had Started from our Camp on the 23rd Inst, they report in the most favourable terms of the River so far as they had been & from what I can See it looks well & I trust will repay us for our trouble in discovering it many traps in the water 6 the success of both parties amount to 134 Beavers & this Completes our first thousand indeed we only wanted 6 to complete it so we have a Commencement for our Second, our Course this day South. Thursday 28th.-There being fine feeding for our Horses about a mile22 in advance we raised Camp & here I purpose to remain two days not only on account of our Horses & trapping but also in expectation of Seven men who remained behind will overtake us here if not I shall feel anxious for their Safety for it "According to Kittson the crossing was made just above the camp site. They would have found a better ford about two miles downstream near the present highway bridge north of Grace, Idaho. However, all evidence (description of terrain, etc.) points to the upper crossing. Kittson says that the brigade struck the Bear, April 26, at a point where it was flowing due south; two miles downstream they camped, just below the ford. The lower ford (at Grace) would have brought them out immediately on the fine level plain at Grace, yet Ogden says that tiiey had three miles of rocky road before coming to theplain. "Traveling in a southerly direction to avoid a large bend in the river the party passed through Grace and Niter, struck the stream again, crossed, and camped on the west side. This crossing was probably at Burton's Ford as shown on the Wheeler map. It is about five miles below the Grace power plant. A bridge spans die river at this point today; a cheese factory is located on the west side. Kittson's map shows a small stream at this camp site, probably Alder Creek. There is a discrepancy in the distance for this day's travel as recorded by Ogden and Kittson. Ogden says they covered 18 miles; Kittson indicates 9 miles. It would seem that Ogden's mileage is in error since 18 miles would have brought the party too far downstream to agree with later movements in which both journals and Kittson's map agree. nA reading of the journal shows that Ogden often sent men out in front to scout the country and trap tributaries. The reports of their success very largely directed his course. Ogden tried to keep his camp in a position that would be accessible to his men who were doing the actual trapping. ^Kittson says a half mile. There are numerous fine green plains suitable for camp sites along tiiis stretch of the river. 168 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY is I verily believe almost impossible to avoid the War tribes.23 We have upwards of 100 traps in the water this day with most Sanguine hopes of Success. 20 Beavers this day. Friday 29th.-We did not raise Camp so as to secure all we can 6 recruit our Horses we had heavy thunder & rain part of the day our Success in beaver has not been great many of the Traps having snapped & again 2 Traps lost.24 16 Beavers Tracks of Black Feet seen also two Strange Dogs.25 Saturday 30th.-We took our route down the Stream, we had an indifferent road & were obliged to leave the River owing to the high rocks but by Crossing a Small mountain we shall again fall on it tomorrow we encamped on the banks of a Small River26 a most dangerous Spot for Should we happen'd to be attacked here we would Stand a poor chance of escaping but there was no alternative our Horses were too much fatigued to proceed. The non-arrival of the seven men causes many dreary in the Camp & nearly all agree that they are no more I really apprehend Some Serious accident has happened them they were to have been with us three days past-we must Still hope all is well. 76 Beaver which closes the month of April. Course S. Dis. 10 miles. Sunday 1st May.-We raised Camp early all safe so far well we had not proceeded more than three miles when we were ""Ogden would repeatedly express anxiety for the safety of diose men before they finally caught up with the main party on May 5. "Losing traps was a serious matter. Ogden often expressed regret that the chains were of such poor construction that such losses were frequent. Note Ogden's weather report for this day. These reports were a regular feature of die journals. ^Kittson noted that these were loaded Blackfeet dogs. Strict watch was kept that night. T h e company moved soutii along the river, through the present community of Thatcher. Just below the Thatcher school, Bear River has cut a very narrow opening through a lava flow. Although a bridge spans the stream at this point today, Ogden found no possibility of continuing along its banks so he turned to the right, leaving the river bottoms near the present site of the Thatcher school. He then struck southwest over hilly country to the north bank of Cottonwood Creek where he camped, probably not far from the present highway bridge. Mr. M. V. Anderson, who lives at that point, informed us that a ford, long used by wagons, lies about a half mile below the bridge. It is not at all unlikely that Ogden used that ford and that his camp was in the immediate vicinity. However, crossing Cottonwood Creek would not be much of an undertaking for Ogden's party which had crossed Bear River twice within a week; his camp might well have been some distance above the ford. Kittson noted excellent beaver signs on this stream. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 169 obliged to encamp27 the rain falling in torrents until the evening we have however a far Superior encampment than last night. Elk & Buffalo28 are most numerous in this quarter & the farther we proceed we find the leaves already large. Flowers in blossom & every appearance of Summer. 40 Beavers this day. Monday 2nd.-Early this day we Started our route was over a hilly Country & our progress very Slow for it was late ere we reached the river it certainly makes a great bend here for had the rocks permitted our following it we should have been two days in Coming round we Crossed over the River & encamped. 29 Dis. 10 miles. Course South & South west. Our hunt this day amounts to 74 Beavers & a Pelican30 also taken in the traps it was rather a Strange Sight to us all to see one of the latter in these remote quarters for in fact with the exception of T h e party was now passing around the Oneida Narrows of Bear River. A steep climb took them out of Cottonwood Canyon. The old trail left the stream bed somewhat below the present bridge but followed close to present state highway 34, the two becoming identical near the summit. Just over the divide Ogden struck the headwaters of Battle Creek, which would lead him to Bear River again, and after having crossed several small tributaries (according to Kittson), camped on one of them. "'Both Kittson and Ogden mention the large number of buffalo in the region. Since the party was forced to "live off the country" this source of food was always welcome. Without buffalo, elk, deer, and antelope, the expedition had to rely on beaver and horseflesh for food. This was very satisfactory as long as large numbers of beaver were being taken, but Ogden was very reluctant to slaughter horses for food. ""Striking for Bear River in the easiest possible way, the brigade continued, following the natural route down Battle Creek in a southwesterly direction past Treasureton, and entered the valley (Poverty Flats) three or four miles east and south of Banida. Rather than follow the creek to die valley floor, the party evidently turned south across rolling hills and valleys, near the edge of the plain and struck Bear River just upstream from the mouth of Battle Creek near the present highway bridge. The river was forded and camp established, no doubt in one of the meadows just below the crossing. It is possible, but very unlikely, that the crossing was made upstream at die present site of Riverdale. To reach this point would have necessitated a very difficult climb out of Battle Creek followed by a very rough route over hills and gullies following the route of highway 34. There would have been no good reason for such a course. Subsequent journal entries seem to rule out the probability of this upper crossing. For example, the following day's journey over flat level plains could not have been made from Riverdale. A further and more convincing proof of the lower crossing is the record of Ogden's return from Utah later in the month. May 28 he camped at the same camp of May 2, crossed the river and struck northwest along the route of present U S Highway 91. Kittson's map and entries from both journals bear out this contention. T h i s is the earliest known reference to pelicans in this area. (William H„ Behle, Professor of Biology, University of Utah.) 170 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY a few Bustards,31 we have so far not seen Birds or Fowls32 of any kind Save & except Ravens & crows in abundance & as for insects we have no Cause to Complain, Fleas Wood lice Spiders 6 crickets by millions.33 Tuesday 3rd.-As we were on the eve of Starting two of the Freemen who had been absent last night arrived & informed us they had Seen a war Party of Black Feet who called to them to Stop & Smoke a pipe a polite way of taking their Scalps but the former in lieu of advancing retreated & hid themselves for the night, they were on a Small River about ten Miles from this, as they left their traps obliged us to proceed there which we reached early our course this day East over a fine level plain covered with Buffalo & many were killed34 I now almost begin to despair of seeing the seven men who have been so long absent indeed from the number of villians35 who are on all Sides of us their chance of escaping is not great 13 Beavers only we may thank the Black Feet if our Traps were not in the Water & our not having taken more Beaver. Wednesday 4th.-Last evening about Sun Set 7 Indians came in Sight on the opposite Side of the River they were hailed in the Snake Language but made no answer they appeared very doubtful of us & we so equally in regard to them, two of our party however Crossed over & joined them they then all Came to the Camp36 being plain Snakes their Camp at a Short distance "Probably various species of broad tailed hawks, or the turkey vulture. (William H. Behle.) KKittson mentions large numbers of geese and ducks as well as trout in die stream. This is also the first record of such wild life in the region. T h i s is the earliest known reference to crickets in the region. It is probably safe to assume that they were the large black crickets of the same variety that occasionally infest regions of the West today. MOgden's course was southeast over a level plain for ten miles to Cub River. Both journals and Kittson's map indicate an "east" course. However, a course due east would have run the party into mountainous country and not over level plains covered with buffalo as described in the journals. Cloudy weadier might help explain this error in direction. Recorded mileage and description of the route check if one follows a southeasterly direction from the crossing through Preston and Whitney to the Cub River. Camp was probably made above and across the stream north and east of present Franklin. The party had crossed Worm Creek, passed northwest of Smart Mountain, and probably camped near its base. ""A favorite expression used by Ogden to describe those who opposed him-Indians, deserters, etc. In this case he was referring to Indians. T h e s e Indians numbered about 40 according to Ogden's letter of July 10, op. cit, 109. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 171 from this only 4 Leagues they inform us that Pe-i-em with all the Snakes are now absent on a trading excursion for Shells with another nation Some distance from this & are expected back this month they also inform us that a party of 25 Americans37 wintered near this & are gone in the same direction we had intended going if this be true which I have no reason to doubt it will be a fatal blow to our expectations & the non arrival of our Seven men will Complete it these Indians had 4 Guns (Barnets) 6 altho' one had 1802 marked on the lock & another 1817 Still they were in good order & appeared as if they were taken out of the Store only a few days Since nor were they wanting in ammunition having procured it from the Americans. What a Sudden change in the Weather for the Violence of the Snow Storm has prevented us from raising Camp yesterday the heat was great & today the Cold is Severe we had only 7 Beaver this day. Thursday 5th.-Weather cloudy & altho it appears we shall have rain Still we raised Camp as this Small river have been Well trapped by the Americans this Spring we shall now return to Bear River our Course this day was west over a fine Plain38 "This was no doubt the Sublette party known to have been in the region at that time. This sets for the first time the approximate location of the American winter camp and the approximate number in the party. In his letter of July 10, Ogden says that the Americans numbered 50 "and had returned home early in the Spring, and had not taken many Beaver." This report varies somewhat from Kittson's account of good catches made by the Americans. He states that "25 Americans had wintered on this river . . . had made many skins but left them en Cache in the mountains." This is the first use of the word Cache in connection with the region that has since taken the name Cache Valley. In later journal entries the word is used quite often. On May 5, Kittson referred to this stream (Cub River) as the "American Branche." It was probably from this region tiiat Jim Bridger made his bullboat voyage down Bear River to discover Great Salt Lake. Interesting as the information about Americans is to us today, it was certainly disheartening to Ogden who would have repeated occasion to regret that they were ahead and had taken the cream of the beaver crop. Kittson further reported that one man, Depot, had a narrow escape from a grizzly bear, being attacked while setting his traps. Depot made his escape by swimming the stream. "Ogden's route probably took him down Cub River a short distance, between Smart Mountain and the present location of Franklin, then southwest to the Bear. Although both journals say the course was "west" for this day, die Kittson map shows southwest, and a description of the terrain Indicates a probable south of west course. If we take the journal directions literally, we find some contradictions. According to these directions, the May 3 route had been "east" for ten miles; now the route was "west" four miles to the river. Ogden was certainly not backtracking. There would be no logical reason for striking a due west course; the whole line of march was southward. This day's travel probably took the party below die 42nd parallel into 172 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY Covered with Buffaloes & thousands of Small Gulls39 the latter was a Strange Sight to us I presume some large body of Water near at hand at present unknown to us all,40 we had not been long encamped when to the joy & surprise of many our party of Seven men who had been absent 11 days made their appearance all Safe41 their long detentions was owing to their having been 6 days in Search of us & almost dispaired of ever seeing us again they set their traps but four nights & took 170 Beavers in Portneufs River on our way here we trapp'd a Small Fork of that River & on our return we shall finish what they have Commenced they report well of it so far well all safe we have Still two men absent but we receive daily tidings of them our Success this day including the above 189 Beaver we are Coming on slowly in collecting Beaver.*42 The remaining two absent men arrived but have left their furs en cache43 41 Beavers this day. Friday 6th.-We remained in Camp to give our Traps a Chance*-look above-we had rain the greatest part of this day. Saturday 7th.-Rain all night the weather Still unsettled Still we raised Camp but did not proceed more than 5 miles when the rain again obliged us to encamp Course N. E. 4' South I44 -three traps lost last night by the Chains. 31 Beavers. Utah; camp was established on the Bear River probably just south of the present Utah-Idaho line. The intervening area is level and open and die Bear River may be easily approached almost anywhere. There is very litde swampy ground which would have deflected the course anywhere in the area traversed. A south of west course would have brought them to an eastward projection of the river just below the Idaho line. Mileage, logic, and Kittson's map indicate a course that would have taken them along the route here described. However, it is possible that the party did not cross the line on that day. The route and camp site for this day was one of the most difficult to determine; we devoted more time examining this area than any other along the whole route. T h e California Gull, common in the Great Salt Lake region, is smaller than some other species found farther east. This is the first known reference to gulls in this region. (William H. Behle.) T h i s is Ogden's first mention of Great Salt Lake, although he was only speculating about the existence of such a body of water. It had certainly been discovered by Americans before May 5. Ogden's letter of July 10, op. cit., 108, states that the party first reached Bear River on May 5, whereas the journal definitely establishes April 26 as the day. •"Ogden's concern for the safety of these men before their return is one of the interesting features of the journal. T h e asterisk is in the original; same for entry of May 6. This indicates diat Ogden did not make journal entries every day. He may well have gotten two or three days behind in his bookwork. "On May 9 this cache yielded 110 beaver skins. "The brigade raised camp and steered a southeast course back to the Cub River or "American Branche.' The stream was forded and camp pitched about a mile below the crossing. The Cub could have been crossed almost anywhere PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 173 Sunday 8th.-Rain all night, the weather fine this day we raised Camp early our Course South over a level plain for 9 miles when we reached a Small creek & encamped45 shortly after the Snake Camp Consisting of A Lodges46 joined & for their own Safety intend following us we found one of our horses that was Stolen from our party last year which they returned, one of the freemen purchased a horse from them which Cost him nearly 60 Skins in goods these poor Snakes understand trade the Freemen have been too long with them not to have profited by their instruction, but few traps in the Water the Americans have taken nearly all the Beaver they are a Selfish Set they leave nothing for their Friends we act differently.47 22 Beavers this day. Monday 9th.-We raised Camp early the Snakes in Company our Course this day South, the main river here takes a great bend to the West we reached the large Fork Commonly Called Bear River tho' large in Size is not to be compared to the other48 the Americans must have taken a number of Beaver in this region, west and north of Richmond, Utah. The stream follows a meandering course through a broad valley affording unlimited sites. Kittson says die river takes a north-south direction here. His map shows a stream, possibly High Creek, which helps identify the movements and camp site for this day. It seems that Ogden's "N. E. 4" should read "S. E.," yet Kittson also says 'N. E." while his map shows a soutiieast course. T h e course this day was soutii through the level plains west of Richmond to Smithfield Creek where camp was established on the south bank. The route doubtless followed a course somewhat west of the present highway in order to avoid some rather deep gullies near the base of the Wasatch Range. "Probably about twenty persons. (Jesse D. Jennings, Professor of Antiiro-pology, University of Utah.) "Very interesting in view of the scorched earth program outlined by Simpson. T h e party continued south and camped on the north bank of Logan River, probably within the present Logan City limits. Journal descriptions of the route at this point are confusing. Ogden says the Bear River makes a big bend to the west and that they struck "the large Fork." Two days later he says that they left "the main branch of Bears River and ascended die largest of three forks." Kittson's map indicates that they did not actually camp at the junction of Little Bear River and Bear River but rather well upstream on Logan River, which he called "Little Bear River." Ogden was actually following a route directed by the success of his trappers who were well out in front trapping and exploring. They indicated that beaver seemed more plentiful on the upper waters of tributaries; the Americans had evidently not trapped very far upstream because of heavy snow during the previous winter. There would have been no logical reason for taking his party out of its normal line of march to camp several miles west at the junction. In stating tiiat his party had left the main stream, he probably intended to emphasize the fact that diey were trapping tributaries rather than Bear River itself. Kittson says that the 174 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY here as there are Still many left but no doubt very wild nearly all the Traps in the Camp were set. 9 Beaver this day & the two men who left their furs en Cache brought them in amounting to 110 so this day forms a total of 119 Beavers. Dis. 11 miles. Tuesday 10th.-Rain greater part of the night but fair this morning from all the traps being Set induced me not to raise Camp but our Success has not been great only 25 Beavers.49 Wednesday 11th.-Heavy rain during the night but again fair this morning we raised Camp our Course S. E. we left the main branch of Bears River & ascended the largest of three forks which from the appearances take their rise from nearly the same quarter, the trappers inform me that they have Some hopes of finding a few Beaver if not I shall Soon change my Course. Dis. 6 miles.60 Buffalo scarce but grizzily Bears in abundance one of the men had a narrow escape three of them were killed. 70 Beavers this is a Convincing proof that there are Some remaining, it would appear the Americans trapped only the lower part of these Forks from the quantity of Snow at the time it was impossible for them to proceed to their sources & if we are so fortunate as to find Beaver it will be So much in our favour. Thursday 12th.-It froze hard last night, fine & warm during the day all the Trappers off I sent two men51 to the branch they reached came in from the east. This must have been Logan River. Kittson's entry for this day also contains interesting information to the effect that Michel Bourdon had called this stream the Little Bear, which would indicate tiiat Northwest Fur Company trappers had penetrated this far south in 1819. "Trappers were out, and, no doubt, trapped Logan River some distance upstream as well as Blacksmith Fork. This day the brigade moved five or six miles southeast along Blacksmitii Fork and camped probably about a mile from the mouth of the canyon in the meadows on the north side of the stream. They likely did not camp nearer the canyon mouth because the next move would be toward the south and the only way out would have necessitated a rather steep climb out of the Blacksmith Fork bottoms. Camp was probably pitched just upstream from the old railroad bridge. That would leave them in a favorable position to move toward the south. B1One of these was probably Charles McKay, for Kittson tells us that on May 12, McKay climbed a high mountain and got a view of a large lake lying off to the southwest. He probably found himself in position to make such a discovery while on that reconnaissance. There is no indication that would lead to the identification of the mountain from which McKay made his discovery; it was probably on the north side of Blacksmith Fork Canyon. In order to see the lake, McKay would be looking southwest over die mountains that lie east of Brigham City. It seems rather peculiar that Ogden did not mention McKay's report, for this was an important event, the first recorded view of Great Salt Lake by any of the Ogden party or any white man. It is not impossible that others of the party had seen the lake from points on lower Bear PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 175 Sources of the middle Fork to See if the Country is worthy of our attention, we did not move this day so as to give the Traps every chance & at the same time not waste Beaver indeed they are by far too Scarce, altho' from the different [accounts]62 we have received of the Snake Country I was as well as many others almost led to believe they were very numerous; but I am now of a Contrary opinion, indeed there is nothing like Seeing then a man Can believe. 52 Beavers I had expected more from the accounts the Freemen gave me but they Complain that the Beaver are very shy. Friday 13th.-Raised Camp & took the middle Fork in ascending as nearly all the Traps are a head of us we had fine plains Covered with Buffalo63 we proceeded near a lofty range of Mountains & encamped if we Can judge from appearances it Cannot be far distant from the three Forks that discharge into Bear River take their rise our Course this day South west.54 Dis. 11 miles some of the Trappers have Crossed the Mountains55 6 many others intend following their example tomorrow as not one of the Trappers have ever been beyond these mountains I shall be anxious to hear of their Success for if they find nothing I shall be at a loss what Course to Steer. 79 Beaver today which Completes our Second thousand56 & leaves us two Beaver to Commence our third with our party of last year did not Complete their first thousand before the 16th from thus so far we ought not nor should we complain. Saturday 14th.-We did not raise Camp as three of the Trappers are in the rear. 15 men Started this morning with their Traps in quest of Beaver we are to meet again in four days River where they had probably trapped; they certainly furnished accurate information for Kittson's map. '"Brackets in the printed journal. "Ogden mentions no buffalo south of tiiis part of Cache Valley-none at all in Ogden Valley. "After raising camp, the brigade turned soutiiwest through the present location of Hyrum to the Little Bear River, which they ascended past Paradise to a point just below Avon where camp was made. Kittson gives an excellent description of the country and states that the stream forks into three branches near this point. The east fork and south fork are die main branches, while die third is probably Paradise Dry Canyon. KSouth into Ogden Valley. This meant that 1,000 beaver had been taken since April 27, which sounds like a favorable catch. Ogden was not too dissatisfied with the results, but couldn't help speculating on the catch he would have made had the Americans not been there ahead of his party. 176 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY as they are gone a head a head of us we Cannot expect great many beaver untill we overtake them I only hope they may meet with Success, the Country is not sufficiently rich in Beaver for So large a party together, but for Safety we require all however we Shall soon be obliged to divide if we don't find more beaver than we have So far.67 31 Beavers this day. Sunday 15th.-We raised Camp for about A miles merely on account of grass for our Horses as I must wait for the men in the rear. Our route this day was hilly & I should Suppose we are not far distant from the height of land as we are Surrounded on all sides by lofty mountains well Covered with Snow.58 Course North 2' & S. E. 2 Miles. 16 Beavers. The Snakes lost four fine fat Horses Since yesterday it is Supposed they have eat Some poisonous weed59 one of the Company's also died this day I think we shall be fortunate if the remainder escape. We have none to spare. Monday 16th.-We raised Camp to Come up with our trappers & commenced ascending a high mountain & reached the sources of Bear River Forks when we began to descend which was far greater than the ascent, the road rocky & Soil gravel which Surprised me, as we found on descending the mountain Covered with white Oak60 & maple trees rather a Strange Sight as we have Seen no Wood of any kind except Willows for these two months past,81 after travelling eight miles we reached a fine valley Covered with Small Streams which appear to discharge themselves in to a river flowing from the N.W.62-this Country T h e party was now approaching the divide between Cache Valley and Ogden Valley. More of Ogden's trappers crossed over into Ogden Valley this day. "Gamp was moved soutiiward up the south branch south of Avon for about four miles where a suitable camp site was located in one of the numerous meadows along the stream. Numerous beaver dams are located along this stream today. Probably either deatii camas or loco weed. (Walter P. Cottam, Professor of Botany, University of Utah.) One more horse was lost on May 17, and although Ogden performed an autopsy die cause of death could not be determined. "Kittson mentions white oak on the other side of the divide, just above Avon. These references are very interesting to botanists in their study of the migration of plants. These oaks are found today right where Ogden and Kittson reported them a century and a quarter ago. (Walter P. Cottam.) "Ogden is forgetful. Poplar and pine had been noted on Bear River just below Alexander, and poplar and aspen on Little Bear River below Paradise, according to Kittson. "Ogdpn continued up toward the divide and over into Ogden Valley, PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 177 looks well & by all accounts promises equally So, it does not appear the Americans have Come this Way, so much in our favour, the three Trappers who were in the rear overtook us as we encamped63 & brought 27 Beaver, we advanced two miles in the plains & encamped but without grass. Course South our Success this day including the above, 52 Beavers many of the Trappers who are near us did not come in. Tuesday 17th.-For want of grass I was obliged to raise Camp this day & proceeded in a South east direction 6 miles and finding grass we encamped64 in our route this day we Crossed over three Forks that looked rich in Beaver all the Trappers Came in & our Success this day amounts to 244 Beavers and as they have only Set their traps three nights their Success has been great, but we have to regret the loss of 7 Traps owing to the Chains the Iron I grant is bad but the workmanship is equally probably along the present road which follows diat course today. From die summit he could have followed down the steep draw on the left hand (where the road is now), or he might have gone down a right-hand draw. In either case he would have come to the North Fork of Ogden River within a half mile of the same spot. He camped that night east of the river across, and probably slightly upstream, from the town of Liberty. Kittson's description of the valley just reached is very interesting. Says he: "We are now in a hole as I may say; as die place is surrounded by lofty mountains and hills. . . This place Mr. Ogden named new hole and the river bears the same name." It takes little imagination to figure out how Ogden's Hole (Ogden Valley) got its name. ""Ogden's whole force, plus the four lodges of Snakes, were now in Ogden Valley. T h e brigade probably camped on the south side of Middle Fork just south of Eden through which tiiey had passed during the day. This camp was probably located in the flat bottoms now covered by the upper end of Pine-view Reservoir. One is led to accept the Middle Fork as the camp site because Kittson says that near that spot the river makes a bend to the southwest and empties into the lake. It was also the largest fork crossed and afforded an excellent camp site. Mileage also checks as does Kittson's map. Kittson's reference to the fact that the river empties into the lake is of especial interest at this point. It indicates that Ogden's men had done extensive exploration of die river and had, no doubt, trapped down through Ogden Canyon to a point from which they had a view of Great Salt Lake. A study of Kittson's map reveals a remarkable amount of accurate detail of the streams and mountains of this vicinity. Weber River, its junction with Ogden River, and the mountains that separate the two streams are remarkably well portrayed. Yet neither Ogden nor Kittson mentions having personally seen the lake or explored down any of the streams. They were both too busy keeping die camp in order, planning strategy, etc. Kittson's description of the valley on this day is worthy of partial quotation: "This hole is but small not being above 50 miles in circumference, of an oblong shape, through the middle of which runs New River coming from the N. W. and taking a S. W. course near this place. It falls into the lake already mentioned." 178 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY So one Horse belonging to the Freemen died this day he was not more than three hours ill his body was opened but we were not sufficiently knowing to discover the cause of his illness,65 I only trust the remainder may escape. Wednesday 18th.-As all the Traps in Camp were Set last night we did not raise Camp & our expectations as usual most Sanguine, but the Water Constantly rising at night & falling in the day is not in our favour we had however nearly 100 Traps snapp'd to take 109 Beaver one nights Setting, three of the Trappers did not Come in it is to be regretted that this Spot is not ten times as large I presume the Americans intended returning this way but they will be as we were on Bear River fa/ten in they ought to keep at home not infringe on their neighbours territories66-one trap again lost by chain. Thursday 19th.-Rain last night. Warm this day our Success of yesterday induced me to remain another night here in hopes of success but the Beaver are already very shy the weather is now becoming very warm Still the Beaver are in their Prime. 68 taken this day. Friday 20th.-We raised Camp merely on account of night guard for our Horses we came two miles S. E. and encamped67 many of the trappers off on discovery but we shall give this place two nights more trapping ere we leave it & certainly we have no cause to regret the time we have Spent here. 67 this day. Three Traps again lost. Saturday 21st.-Remd. in Camp, & our Success this day amounts to 23 from this it must appear this River & Forks which I have named New River68 as no whites have ever been here be- "See Note 59. "This would certainly indicate that Ogden did not consider himself outside the legal bounds of territory claimed by Britain, which, of course, he was not. That he should accuse Americans of infringing on their neighbors' territories is very interesting for any trapping done by Americans west of the continental divide and south of the 42nd parallel was indeed out of bounds as a result of the Adams-Onis Treaty of 1819 between the United States and Spain. T h e party now continued its journey through Ogden Valley, turned left up South Fork (which joins North and Middle Forks just a short distance below the camp site of May 17) two miles and camped again-this time in the river bottoms immediately south of present-day Huntsville. T h i s is Ogden's first reference to the fact that he had named the stream "New River" although Kittson mentioned the fact in his entry of May 16. See Note 62 above. Needless to say, this name has not been retained, but Ogden's own name has been given it, as well as die valley which he discovered at this time. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 179 fore is now nearly exhausted of its riches & for So Small a Space it not being more than 6 miles in length & 3 in breadth has certainly well repaid us for the time we have spent.69 I only wish we could find a dozen Spots equal to it. Sunday 22nd.-As we were on the eve of Starting this Morning one of our Trappers arrived in Company with two of our Freemen70 who deserted from the Flat Head Post 182271 they belong to a party of 30 men who were fitted out by the Spainards & Traders on the Missouri & have Spent the winter in this quarter & have met with little Success72 of the 14 who deserted73 6 are dead & the remainder with the Spaniards, at St. Louis & Missouri from the information obtained from them we are now 15 days march from the Spainish Village,74 the whole Country overrun with Americans & Canadians all in the pursuit of the Same object of this we had Convincing proofs this Spring on Bears River & now here for this party know nothing of the others,75 it appears we are now on the Utas Lands who they represent as being most friendly to the Whites, they have about 2076 with them, the Americans had a battle last fall with the Snakes & 7 of the former & one of our deserters Patrick O'Connor were killed & only one Snake fell77-there is no water Com- "°A reading of the journal will disclose that Ogden took 563 beaver pelts from Ogden Valley. Kittson makes note of the fact that several trappers had gone ahead. This would mean that they had gone over to the Weber River. '"Ogden's freemen had been over in the Weber River Valley, where uiey found these former company freemen. "See Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit, xlvi, concerning these deserters. "This was obviously the party headed by Etienne Provost who came into Ogden's camp the following day. '"Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit., 49, note 2, lists the names of die 1822 deserters. "In his letter of July 10, 1825, op. cit, 109, Ogden says: "This place is called Taas [obviously Taos] distant about 100 Miles from St Fe and is now supplied with goods from St Louis overland in wagons by the Americans." T h i s would indicate that Provost's party had no knowledge of the Sublette party or the Americans under Jedediah Smith. Yet Ogden later claimed that one of the Indians of Provost's party had been responsible for bringing Americans to the British camp. See note 86 below. T w e n t y "Uta" Indians. Kittson adds that these Indians had accepted Christianity as evidenced by the silver and brass crosses worn about the neck. T h i s must surely have been the well-known treacherous attack made on Etienne Provost. The fight is depicted as having occurred "last fall" (1824), and obviously not far away, no doubt on the Weber. This is significant because it not only dates and locates that event but places Provost on the Weber in the fall of 1824, early enough to make him a very likely discoverer of Great Salt Lake. Of course, this does not prove that Provost saw die lake 180 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY munication between this & the Spainish River78 which is now about three days march from this very mountain, this I can credit for as far as the eye can reach we appear to be Surrounded on all Sides by very high ones Still well Covered with Snow. From two of our trappers who Came in inform me they had Seen a large lake79 equal in Size Winipeg & that Bear River & New River discharge their Waters in the Lake so the point is now ascertained that Bear River has nothing to do with the Spanish River80 from what they Could observe the Lake runs due west, if so & as the Natives inform there is a large river at the west end81 this must be the Umqua Seen by Mr. Thomas McKay G agrees so far with the natives of that quarter of their being a very large Lake in the Vicinity of their Lands & that there was no beaver this So far as it has been examined I am inclined to believe is the Case.82 Our Course this day South over a hilly Country for ten miles when we again reached New River83 but here nothing but Stones & gravel without any appearances of beaver84 but from the non arrival of 20 men I am in hopes they before Bridger did (or that he saw it at all), but it bolsters his case as a serious contender for that honor. Ogden later reported Snake hostility that eventually led to this attack had been brought about as a result of a horse stealing foray against these Indians by some Hudson's Bay Company men under the leadership of Alexander Ross. See Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit., 58. ''Probably Green River, a major tributary of the Colorado. '"This is the only mention in Ogden's journal that any of his men had actually seen Great Salt Lake although it seems incredible that he had not heard of it before, as recorded by Kittson May 12 and 17. He does not mention that it is salty (nor does Kittson), so it may be fairly asserted that none of the party actually visited its shores. "Ogden considered this important and new information, which, of course, it was to him and his party. T h e illusion of a river at the west side of Great Salt Lake would remain until Ogden's 1828-29 exploration which disproved the existence of such a stream. See Oregon Historical Quarterly, XI, 392. fflOgden found few beaver on Weber River; die region had already been trapped by Americans. This statement suggests that Ogden's men might have explored all the way down Weber River to Great Salt Lake, but this is doubtful. Cf. Note 79 above. T o d a y we know Ogden's "New River" as "Ogden River," while the stream he struck May 22 is definitely Weber River. However, both streams join before discharging into Great Salt Lake, and it is only natural that Ogden should consider them two branches of the same river and call them by the same name-New River. MIn order to come up with his men, Ogden had raised camp and struck south, up over the divide into Weber Valley. The course probably followed a small stream (Hawkins Creek) to its source near the summit, tiien crossed over and fell on the headwaters of Dry Creek and down that stream to its PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 181 have met with success two of the 20 men Came but found nothing. 27 Beavers. Monday 23rd.-Remd. in Camp in expectation of the arrival of our absent party, early in the day a party of 15 men Canadians & Spainards headed by one Provost85 & Francois86 one of our deserters, arrived, and also in the afternoon arrived in Company with 14 of our absent men a party of 25 Americans with Colours flying the later party headed by one Gardner87 they encamped within 100 yards of our encampment & lost no time in informing all hands in Camp that they were in the United States Territories & were all free indebted or engaged & to add to this they would pay Cash for their Beaver 3J/2 dollars p. lb.,88 & their goods cheap in proportion our Freemen in lieu of Seeking Beaver have been with the Americans no doubt plotting. Tuesday 24th.-This morning Gardner came to my Tent & after a few words of no import, he questioned me as follows Do you know in whose Country you are? to which I made answer junction with Weber River where camp was established. The route probably paralleled that of die present road most of the way. Had the party crossed the mountain anywhere in the vicinity' of Huntsville, they would have come to one of the small tributaries of Dry Creek, for aldiough not large, this stream drains an extensive area. Journal descriptions and Kittson's map fit die geography of the region very well. This camp, maintained in the same place through May 24, was on die north bank of Weber River probably just west of the present location of Mountain Green. Here the river runs in a westerly direction; extensive flat meadowland with large groves of cotton-woods is found there today-excellent camp sites. Evidences of beaver may be found there now, although Ogden found none. The May 22 camp site marks Ogden's farthest penetration toward the south and settles definitely die long moot question as to die extent of his exploration in 1825. Now that this fact has finally been ascertained, a monument or otiier fitting marker should be placed tiiere. "Etienne Provost. "Ogden's letter of July 10, op. cit, 109, states that Francois was "an Iroquois Chief who deserted from our party two Years since. . ." In the same letter he suggests that this same man was responsible for directing the Americans to his camp. He says: I have already observed it was an unfortunate day Mr. Ross consented to allow the 7 Americans to accompany him to the Flatheads, for it was these fellows that guided and accompanied them to our Camp, and the whole party were on their return to St. Louis and were induced to return by letters they received from the Iroquois Chiefs, otherwise we should not have seen them. "Johnson Gardner. "In his letter of July 10, op. cit, 112, Ogden states that Americans were offering eight times as much for beaver as he could pay. 182 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY that I did not as it was not determined between Great Britain & America to whom it belonged,89 to which he made answer that it was that it had been ceded to the latter90 & as I had no license to trap or trade to return from whence I came to this I made answer when we receive orders from the British Government we Shall obey, then he replied remain at your peril, he then departed & seeing him go into John Grey91 an American & halt Iroquois Tent one of my Freemen I followed him, on entering this Villain Grey said I must now tell you that all the Iroquois as well as myself have long wished for an opportunity to join the Americans & if we did not Sooner it was owing to our bad luck in not meeting with them, but now we go & all you Can Say Cannot prevent us, Gardner was Silent having only made one remark as follows, you have had these men already too long in your Service & have most Shamefully imposed on them selling them goods at high prices & giving them nothing for their Skins on which he retired, Grey then said that is true and alluding to the gentlemen he had been with in the Columbia they are Says he the greatest Villains in the World & if they were here this day I would Shoot them but as for you Sir you have dealt fair with me & with us all,92 but go we will we are now in a free Country & have Friends here to Support us & if every man in the Camp does not leave you they do not Seek their own interest, he then gave orders to his Partners to raise Camp & immediately all the Iroquois were in motion, & made ready to Start this example was Soon followed by others at this time the Americans headed by Gardner & accompanied by two of our Iroquois who had been with them the last two years advanced to Support & assist all who were inclined to desert, Lazard an Iroquois93 now Called out we are Superior in numbers to them T h i s would indicate that Ogden considered himself to be inside the Oregon Country jointly occupied by Great Britain and the United States since the Convention of 1818. "Gardner was certainly bluffing, for joint occupation was to last ten years, after which it was renewed. On the other hand, by the Adams-Onis treaty of 1819, the United States gave up any claim she might have had south of the 42nd parallel. Gardner probably knew this, but was merely using this bluff as an attempt to justify his actions at that.time. "John Grey or Ignace Hatchiorauquasha according to Kittson. T h i s is no doubt true. Ogden's constant concern for his long absent men as expressed in his journal entries April 27 to May 5 should be evidence of his interest in their well being. Deserting men found fault with company policy, but not with the leader of their expedition. "There is a Lazard listed among the deserters of 1822, as well as among Ogden's deserters. It is likely that this Lazard was the deserter of 1822. PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 183 let us fire & pillage them on Saying this he advanced with his Gun Cocked & pointed at me but finding I was determined not to allow him or others to pillage us of our Horses as they had already taken two say Old Pierres94 which had been lent him, they desisted & we Secured the ten Horses but not without enduring the most opprobious terms they could think of from both Americans & Iroquois all this time with the exception of Messrs. Kittson & McKay & two of the engaged men95 & the latter not before they were Called Came to our assistance thus we were overpowered by numbers these Villains 11 in number with Du-ford, Perrault and Kanota96 escaped with their Furs in fact some of them had conveyed theirs in the night to the American Camp. A Carson & Annance paid their debts97 & followed the example of the others, I cannot but Consider it a fortunate Circumstance I did not fire for had / I have not the least doubt all was gone, property & furs indeed this was their plan that I should fire & assuredly they did all they Could to make me but I was fully aware of their plan & by that means Saved what remains-they Started & encamped about half a mile from us. From the above affair I am now Convinced the 6 absent men they have Secured & it would be folly in me to delay my departure for their arrival, indeed I fear many of the Freemen will yet leave us. Wednesday 25th.-Late last evening I was informed98 the Iroquois & Americans intended to attack & pillage the Camp on hearing this I conversed with Some of the Freemen & engaged men to know if they would assist in defending the Company's property in Case of attack and they said they would we made all necessary preparations in Case of attack & kept Strict guard "Kittson says: "A scuffle took place between Old Pierre and Mr. Ogden regarding the horses lent by that Gentleman to the old villian . . . ." See also Ogden's letter of July 10, op. cit. 111. Ogden recorded the ultimate death of Pierre, who was ' killed and cut to pieces" by the Blackfeet. See Oregon Historical Quarterly, XI, 374. "Kittson lists the men who came to Ogden's aid and adds that Ogden was busy securing the skins belonging to the men still absent from camp. Dr. John McLoughlin later reported how shamefully the engaged men had acted on this occasion. See Oregon Historical Quarterly, XXXV, 117. "These were evidently not Iroquois but were included in the count of eleven deserters. ""Annance had evidently been a leader among the Freemen and an important member of die expedition. His name appears from time to time in die journals. Kittson lists Annance as having deserted May 25. ""In die evening Alexander Carson came back and warned me to be on my guard as a plot was forming . . . to pillage me in the night as I had refused to sell tiiem Tobacco. . . ." Ogden's letter of July 10, 1825, op. cit.. 111. 184 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY during the Night, at day light I gave the Call to raise Camp, scarcely had we begun loading our Horses, when the Americans & three of our Iroquois Came to our Camp but finding us prepared kept quiet Soon after Mr. Montour, Clement & Prudhomme came forward & told me they intended joining the Americans that they were free & not indebted I endeavored to reason with Mr. Montour but all in vain, the reasons he gave for his villany were the Company turned me out of doors they have £260 of my money in their hands which they intend to defraud me of as they have refused to give me interest for but they may keep it now for my debt Q Prudhoms. which we have Contracted in the Columbia as for Clement he has a Bake, in the Compys. Book; go we will where we shall be paid for our Furs & not be imposed & cheated as we are in the Columbia-they were immediately Surrounded by the Americans who assisted them in loading & like all Villains appeared to exult in their Villany we then Started but on my mounting my Horse Gardner Came forward & Said you will See us shortly not only in the Columbia but at the Flat Heads & Cootanies99 we are determined you Shall no longer remain in our Territory,100 to this I made answer when we Should receive orders from our Government to leave the Columbia we would but Not before to this he replied our Troops will make you this Fall we then parted & proceeded to our encampment of the 19th Inst.101 and encamped. Here I am now with only 20 Trappers102 Surrounded on all Sides by enemies & our expectations and hopes blasted for returns this year, to remain in this quarter any longer it would merely be to trap Beaver for the Americans for I Seriously apprehend there are Still more of the Trappers who would Willingly join them indeed the tempting offers made them independent the low price they Sell their goods are too "A Hudson's Bay Company post north and west of Flathead Post. 100Ogden either did not know of the Adams-Onis Treaty or did not realize tiiat he was south of the 42nd parallel-which seems quite unlikely. "This would be on the middle fork of Ogden River just south of Eden. Kittson says they returned to the camp site of May 16-just across the river from Liberty. ""Including the six absent men, believed by Ogden to be "lost" to the Americans, 22 men had now deserted. Two of the absentees returned late tiiat night, cutting die number to 20, but on May 29, three more men left. This leaves a total of 23 deserters from the Ogden camp before he was able to get out of the region. Kittson lists the deserters of May 24 (12 according to his figures), and indicates which ones paid tiieir debts. Kittson labeled the camp of May 22-24 "Deserter Point." PETER SKENE OGDEN'S JOURNAL 185 great for them to resist & altho' I represented to them all these offers were held out to them as so many baits Still it is without effect I have now no other alternative left but direct my Course towards Salmon River without loss of time, to follow up my Second intentions in proceeding by the Walla Walla route103 is now in a manner rendered impracticable as our numbers are by far too few, as nearly one half of the Trappers are determined to return to Fort des Prairies104 so if we divide again neither party would Stand a chance of ever reaching the Columbia, there is now No alternative I must bend & Submit to the will of the party. Thursday 26th.-Late last evening two of the six absent men joined us105 they had Seen nothing of the remaining four By their accounts as they were on their return to the Camp yesterday they fell in with an American party from 30 to 40 men as they Say Troops, who on Seeing them Called to them to advance which they did, their traps 15 in number 16 Beaver & their two Horses were taken from them they were then told if they would remain with them & not return & Join me their property would be restored to them otherwise not, they were Strictly guarded during the day & while in the act of changing Watches about midnight last night they effected their escape leaving all behind them how far this is Correct I cannot Say it may be probably made to Suit intentions as they have both Women & Horses perhaps they will now Watch an opportunity to return if they do which they Can easily effect without their Furs both day & night we shall however watch them, we raised Camp & encamped at our encampment of the 14th.106 5 Beavers were taken. May-Friday 27th.-Raised Camp & came to our encampment of the 9th107 Cloudy weather rain during the day only 1 Beaver altho' many Traps in the water, it does not appear from our success now that we left many behind as we went along. Our Camp is now dull & gloomy. Saturday 28th.-We strongly suspect this morning that a 103In his letter of July 10, Ogden stated that he had intended to follow instructions and return via the Umpqua. This would have led to extensive exploration of the region west of Great Salt Lake. '"Edmonton House, on the North Saskatchewan River. See Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit., 55, note 1. '"This reduced die losses by two. IWJust below Avon. ,OTAt Logan. 186 UTAH HISTORICAL QUARTERLY party is forming to desert this they Can easily effect at any time but with their Furs not conveniently we raised Camp & came to our Encampment of the 3rd on Bear River108 here we found the Water had risen three feet since we were last here we lost no time in making rafts of rushes & had the greater part of the Freemens furs & Traps Crossed over Strongly guarded. Sunday 29th.-Three men109 deserted leaving all behind them Women, Children, Horses, Traps & Furs so greatly are they prepossessed in favor of the Americans that they sacrificed all to join them. I cannot make too great progress otherwise I apprehend many more will leave us,110 our Numbers are now So few that if any war party Comes across us we shall Stand a poor chance of escaping, we Crossed over the remainder of our property & Horses & proceeded in a north west Course direct to the Snake River. Weather fair. 2 Beavers-we Came 18 miles & encamped on a Small creek111 destitute of Beaver. Monday 30th.-Raised Camp our route over a fine Plain we Came about 20 miles & encamped on the head of River Portneuf. 112 Buffalo in abundance all this day. Weather Warm. Tuesday 31st.-We raised Camp & proceeded down the west Fork of Portneuf's River Country fine & level Dis. 18 miles & encamped,113 a few Traps were Set last night which gave us 7 Beaver. The heat encreases. June 1st-Wednesday.-Raised Camp, Crossed over the West Fork also the main Branch and encamped distance 5 miles114 Cloudy Weather. 25 Beaver this day. '"May 2 the party had camped on Bear River and, of course, were still there on the morning of May 3. They returned to this old camp site May 28. '"Kittson gives their names and some details about their desertion. He says of the third man: ". . . it is not surprising he being an Iroquois by the Name of Fras. Sasanare." This was one of those who had returned May 25. '"No more men deserted in spile of Ogden's fears. "'The route this day was approximately that of U S Highway 91 through Banida and past Swan Lake. Camp was located on Deep Creek not far from Red Rock Pass. ' T h i s camp was on Marsh Creek just west of Downey. ' T h e route was down the west bank of Marsh Creek, which Ogden called the West Branch of Portneuf River. The camp site was just a few miles south of McCammon. '"The party crossed Marsh Creek to the east side then crossed the Portneuf and camped on the north bank just below McCammon. The brigade later continued down Portneuf River to the Snake. During the rest of the season Ogden trapped die upper Snake River, returned again to die headwaters of the Missouri, and eventually returned along the Snake (at least part of the way), and ended his hunt at Fort Nez Perces (Walla Walla), during the first week of November. For a complete account of the remainder of his activities see Ogden's Snake Country Journals, op. cit., 56-93. |
