OCR Text |
Show CONCLUSIONS 1.) The refinery database that has been generated shows that refinery fuel gas (RFG) varies widely in inorganic, organic and sulfur content. 2.) The existing refinery analytical techniques are not capable of accurately measuring all of the sulfur compounds in RFG at the low levels that are now of interest in the field. 3.) Newly developed analytical methods are indicating that significant levels of sulfur species other than HzS, such as Carbonyl Sulfide (COS), Carbon Disulfide (CSz), Dimethyl Disulfide (DMDS) and Mercaptans (RSH's) are present in RFG streams. 4.) Existing refinery amine systems typically remove 99.5 + % of the inlet HzS. The average sulfur content in the existing RFG database is 180-250 ppmv, based on the updated measurement techniques. 5.) The different sulfur removal processes that were investigated vary considerably in their abilities to remove specific sulfur compounds. 6.) No praYeD single technology was identified that can reduoo typical RFG's to 40 ppmv average total sulfur. Based on combining a number of the technologies a refiner may be able to acheive a 40 ppmv level. Only plant tests can confirm this hypothesis. 7.) At this time, the most promising and cost effective technological areas appear to be : enhanced chemical and physical solvent absorption, regenerative caustic scrubbing, and hydrogenation / hydrolysis reaction beds. Higher pressures can increase the efficiencies of most of these; therefore compression can also be of benefit. 8.) Due to the variability of RFG's among and within refineries, a case by case analysis will be required for each refinery to determine the most cost effective scheme(s) to supplement its existing systems. 9.) Five processes or combinations thereof appear to be theoretically capable of achieving the new SCAQMD 40 ppmv total limit on an "average" RFG. The generic costs generated for these process schemes appear to fall close to the SCAQMD "cost effectiveness" expenditure guidelines. The processes evaluated are by no means to be considered an exclusive list of potential processes. -13- |