Aristotle on sameness and oneness

Update item information
Publication Type Journal Article
School or College College of Humanities
Department Philosophy
Creator White, Nicholas P.
Title Aristotle on sameness and oneness
Date 1971-04
Description Before I begin, let me get one substantial issue out of the way. Recently certain views which are in many ways similar to Aristotle's have been expounded in connection with the idea that there is something wrong with the words "same" and "identical" used by themselves, and that we should instead make use of expressions of the form "same F," where "F" represents a general term. Aristotle, so far as I can find, never says any such thing, and although he does say a number of things which would seem to suggest, even perhaps to imply, such a view, and although he maintains that the word "same" carries many senses, he does not offer to resolve its ambiguity by coupling it with general terms. Indeed, he almost never uses "same" in this way, and only rarely thus uses his word for "one," ev3. I shall accordingly be doing without such couplings in what is to follow.
Type Text
Publisher Duke University Press
First Page 177
Last Page 197
Subject Leibniz' Law; Metaphysics; Greek philosophers
Subject LCSH Identity; Philosophy;, Ancient
Language eng
Bibliographic Citation White, N. (1971). Aristotle on sameness and oneness. Philosophical Review, 80, 177-97.
Rights Management (c) Duke University Press
Format Medium application/pdf
Format Extent 1,956,951 bytes
Identifier ir-main,1902
ARK ark:/87278/s6pn9q7h
Setname ir_uspace
Date Created 2012-06-13
Date Modified 2012-06-13
ID 706468
Reference URL https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s6pn9q7h
Back to Search Results