Unmasking Descartes's case for the bete machine doctrine

Download item | Update item information
Publication Type Journal Article
School or College College of Humanities
Department Philosophy
Creator Newman, Lex
Title Unmasking Descartes's case for the bete machine doctrine
Date 2001
Description Among the more notorious of Cartesian doctrines is the bete machine doctrine -- the view that brute animals lack not only reason, but any form of consciousness (having no mind or soul). Recent English commentaries have served to obscure, rather than to clarify, the historical Descartes's views, Standard interpretations have it that insofar as Descartes intends to establish the bete machine doctrine his arguments are palpably flawed. One camp of interpreters thus disputes that he even holds the doctrine. As I shall attempt to show, not only does Descartes affirm the doctrine, his supporting arguments are not palpably flawed -- even if they ultimately come up short. It will indeed emerge that, in making his case, Descartes employs interesting argumentative strategies that have not been duly appreciated.
Type Text
Publisher University of Calgary Press
First Page 389
Last Page 326
Subject Animals; Intelligence; Soul; Mechanical causation
Subject LCSH Animal intelligence; Instinct; Animal behavior
Language eng
Bibliographic Citation Newman, L. (2001). Unmasking Descartes's case for the bete machine doctrine. Canadian Journal of Philosophy;, 31,(3), 389-26.
Rights Management (c) University of Calgary Press
Format Medium application/pdf
Format Extent 1,209,764 Bytes
Identifier ir-main,2493
ARK ark:/87278/s6qf9b59
Setname ir_uspace
Date Created 2012-06-13
Date Modified 2012-06-13
ID 703992
Reference URL https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s6qf9b59