Bingham Canyon hydrologic/geotechnical study phase II project report: interim study report

Page 83

TABLE 4. 1-4 - 20 YEAR PRESENT VALUE, WET YEAR= 20, I = BZ (ALL COSTS x Sl,0001 ======================================= * =========== 1 D1VERSiON OF RUNOFF COST i TREATMENT COST t STORAGE COST * =========== * (1) 1 =========== * (2l * =========== * MATR[X COMBINATION t RESERVOIR ± ======================================= 1 =================== f ============================= 1 SUBTOTAL t ========= t SUBTOTAL 1 ==========• TOTAL t (ITEMS CONSIDERED) * REQUIREMENTS* DIVERSION DRY FORK DRY FORK DRY FORK t CARR FORK LEACH * NEW ALTERNATE EXISTING* (x Sl,000) t 6. 25K GPM t {x Sl,0001 1 12.5K 6PM t COSTS * 1 (ACRE-FEET) 1 DAM PUMPING TUNNEL * &PIT WATER I RESERVOIR RESERVOIR RESERVOIR 1 1 TREATMENT* *TREATMENT* (x Sl,0001 * ======== ··=============================I =========== f =============:::::::::::::::::::::::::: f ::::::::::::::::::: f ::::::::::=================== f =========== f :::: ::::: r ::::::::::: I========-=*----------- f f f * I f I f f i A. BASE CASE FOR TREATMENT ¾ 1 I f * (11 NOS~ CARR FORK UNDERGROUND 1 I i l * 12) BINGHAM & BUTTERFIELD TUNNELS,1 t l f ¼ I f * AND B[NGHAM CANYON CUTOFF J.I I I 1 I I * 1A. NO DIVERSION, NC, ND $0 f $0 $0 t $83,919 * 13,058 f. $0 I $66,751 I Hi, 169 :+ $0 $0 $26,329 $51,458 I $15,292 I $25,129 1B. NG DIVE~SrGN, C7, ND $0 1 $0 t 13,058 1 $0 $96,889 * $0 I $0 $0 $73,991 * $22,897 * $51,458 I $22 1 533 I $26,329 $25,129 * 1C. NO DIVERSION, NJ, ND $0 $0 1 $0 I $67, 055 I $19,978 * $87,033 * 13,058 t $0 I $0 $0 $51,458 :t $15,597 * $26,329 $25,129 t 10. NO DIVERSION, NJ, ND, EP 1 $0 $0 13,058 I $64,615 1 $16,582 * $0 I $51 1 458 I $13,157 I $81, 197 * $0 $26,329 so $25, 129 t so* 1E. rm DIVERSION, NC, AD $86,970 t $0 13,058 t * $69,801 I $17,169¼ $0 $0 I $0 I $0 $0 $3,220 I $51,289 $54,509 * 'HS,292 * 1F. NO DIVERSION, C7, AD $99,940 I 1 $0 $77,042 I $22,897 * $0 13,058 I $3 1 220 I $0 ¼ $0 ¼ $54,509 I $22,533 I $0 $0 $51,289 18. rm DIVERSION, NJ, AD $90,084 1 $19,978 I i $70,106 $0 13,058 t $0 $0 1 $0 $54,509 !t $15,597 * $0 $51,2B9 $3,220 I $0 * 1H. NO DIVERSION, NJ, AD, EP $84,248 I 1 13,058 I $67,666 I $16 532, $0 $0 $0 $0 t $0 $54,509 I $13, 157 * 53,220 I $0 I $51,289 $0 2A. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, P, NC ND 1 $78. 793 l $61,625 I $17,169 1 10 343 1 $46,332 I $15 292 I !4 802 $1,690 $0 H 791 $0 $3,220 * $0 * $28 829 23. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, P, C7 1 ND 1 $91,763 t $68,865, $22,897 * $3 1 220 I $0. $0 I $28,829 $22,533 I $46,332 I $7,791 $4,802 10,343 * $1,690 $0 $0 2C. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, P NJ. ND 1 $81,907 I 10,343 I ·$ 1, 690 $7,791 $0 t $46,332 I $15,597 * $0 SO I $28,829 $61,929 * $19,'778 * $3,220 * 2D. DIV COPPERTON L DRY FORK, T NC ND 1 $1 690 $7,791 10,343 ! $63, 155 1 $17 169 t $0 $80,324 * $47 863 I $0 I $0 $6,332 l $0 $3 220 t $28,829 2E. DIV COPPERTGN & DRY FORK, T, C7, ND 1 $'13,293 f. 10,343 f $0 J $1,690 $0 $7,791 $0 $70,396 * $22,897 f. $6,332 t $3,220 t$28,829 $47,863 * $22,533 * $0 2F. DIV COPPERTON DRY FORK, T, NJ, ND i 10:343 + $0 $83,438 * $0 H,690 $47,863 1 $1~ 1 597 * $7,791 $0 f $28,829 $63,459 * $19,978 t $6,332 1 $0 $3,220 * 26. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, P, NC, AD 1 10,343 f $0. H2, 385 1 H7, 169 t $89,553 * $0 f$ l, 690 $0 $i,791 $3 1 220 I H,802 $39,589 $0 $57,092 * H~,292 1 2H. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, P, C7, AD 1 10 1 343 I $79,625 f $22,897 * $102 1 523 I $1,690 $57,092 i $22 1 533 I $7,791 $0 I H,802 $0 $0 $39,589 $3,220 * $0 * 2I. DIV COPPERTON DRY FORK, P, NJ, AD 1 $92,667 t $72,689 I $19,978 * l0,343 1 $0 1 $0 f. $1,690 $57,092 1 HS, 597 t $0 $0 $7,791 $4,802 $39,589 $3,220 • 2J. DIV COPPERTGN DRY FORK, T, HC, AD 1 $91,084 I $1,690 $0 $73,915 1 $17,169 t 10,343 * $58,623 I $15,292 * H, 791 $3,220 t $0 $0 $39,589 $6,332 * $0 * 2K. DIV COPPERTON &DRY FORK, T, C7, AD 1 $104,053 t $81,156¼ $22 1 897 I 10 1 343 I $0 f $ l, 690 $0 $0 $0 $7,791 $39,589 '56,332 f. $58,623 * $22,533 1 $3,220 * 2L. DIV COPPERTON DRY FORK, T, NJ, AD t $94,198 t $1,690 $0 $7,791 l0,343 * $19,978 * $0 I $74,219 $0 $0 $39,589 $58,623 * $15,597 n, 220 t * * S6,332 * I . 3A. 2. +FREEMAN\ MARKHAM, P, NC, ND 1 91 122 I $83,359 :+ $17,169:+ $66,191 l $6,956 $0 I $27,029 $0 $8,891 $4,802 $0 $3,220 + $50,898 * $15,292 t io • 38. 2. + FREEMAN &MARKHAM, P, C7 1 ND * $96,329 i 9I 122 f $6,956 $50,898 I $22,533 f $8,891 $0. $27,029 $4,802 $73,431 * $22,897 * $0 $0 $3,220 * $0 * 3C. 2. + FREEMAN &MARKHAM, P, NJ, ND 1 9,122 I $66,495 t $19,978 I $6,956 $66,473 * $0 t $0 $8,891 $3,220 + $4,802 $0 $50,898 * $15,597 1 $27,029 $0 * 3D. 2. +FREEMAN~ MARKHAM, T, NC, NO 1 9, 122 1 $84,890 I $6,956 $0 $8,891 $0 1 $0 $67,721 * $17,169 * $0 $3,220 t $6,332 * $27,029 :52,429 * $15,292 * 3E. 2. + FREEMAN &MARKHAM, T, C7, ND 1 $97,859 1 9, 122 1$6, '?56 $0 t $27,029 $0 $8,891 $74,962 • $22,897 * $6,332 1 $0 $0 $52,429 * $22,533 * $3,220 * 3F. 2. + FREEMAN L MARKHAM, T, NJ, ND * $88,004 t 9, 122 1 $6,956 $52,429 t $15,597 * $0 $8,89! $0 t $27,029 $6,332 $0 $0 $68,025 * $19,978 f. $3,220 * 36. 2. + FREEMAN & MARKHAM, P, NC, AD 1 $91,119 I 9,122 I $73,951 i $6,956 $17,169 * $0 $4,202 $0 $8,891 $0 I $58,658 * $15,292 * $3,220 * $34,789 $0 * 3H. 2. +FREEMAN~ MARKHAM, P, C7, AD t $81,191¼ $22,897 t 9I 122 l $6,956 $104,089 • $0 $3,220 f $0 t $0 $34,789 $8,891 $4,802 $58,658 * $2~,533 t $0 * 3I. 2. + FREEMAN &MARKHAM, P, NJ, AD $94,233 1 $74,255 t $19,978 * 9! 122 I $6,956 $0 $58,658 t $15,597 t $8,891 fl, 220 I $0 I $0 $4,802 $34,789 $0" 3J. 2. + FREENAN &MARKHAM, T, NC, AD t $75 1 481 I $17,169 * $92,650 I $60,189 t $1C',292 I $0 $0 $8,891 $3,220 f 9, 122 * $6,956 $0 $34,789 $6,332 • $0 * 3K. 2. + FREE~AN MARKHAM, T, C7, AD 1 $82,722 i $22,897 * il05,619 * $3 1 220 I 9, 122 * $6, ·156 $0 SB,891 $60,189 * $22,533 * $0 $0 $34,789 $6,332 * $0 * 3L. 2. + FREEMAN &MARKHAM, T, NJ, AD $95,764 * 9 I 122 f $75,785 * $19,978 I $0 $6,956 $0 $34,789 $3 1 220 I $60 1 l89 * $15,597 * $8,891 !O $6,332 * $0 * 4A. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, NC, ND 1 $86, '?10 * 8,533 I Hl,007 $0 I $69,741 • $17,169 * $9,291 $54,449 * $15,292 * $0 $0 H,802 $3,220 * $0 * $26, 129 48. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, C?, ND $0 I $76,982 * $22,897 * $99,280 * $0 $54,449 I $22,533 * $0 $9,291 8,533 * H 1,007 $4,802 $3,220 * $0 * $26,129 4C. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, NJ, ND * 8,533 1 $11,007 $0, $26,129 $0 f H0,024 * $9,291 $70,046 • $19,978 I $54,449 * $15,597 * $0 $3 1 220 I $0 $4,802 4D. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, NC, ND 1 $71,272 l $17,169 I $88,441 * $55,980 I $15,292 l $0 $0 $3,220 I 8,533 * H 11 007 $0 $6 1 332 I $9,291 $0 * $26,129 4E. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, C7, ND 1 8,533 1 $11,007 $101,410 * $78,513 * $22,897" $0 $0 $0 I $26, 129 13,220 I $55,980 * $22,533 * $0 $9 I 291 S6,332 * 4F. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, NJ, ND 1 $71,576 it $l9,978 * $55 1 980 I $15,597 I $91,554 * $0 $0 $0 l $0 $3,220 l 8,533 * H 1,007 $9,291 $26,129 $6,332 * 4G. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, NC, AD 1 8,533 I $11,007 $75,901 * $17,169. . ii • $93,070 t $0 $0 i ~3,220 1$4,802 ~60,609 * $15,292 * $0 $32,289 H,2'?1 $0 * 4H. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, C7, AD 1 $106,040 1 $83, 142 I $22,897 * 8,533 I H 1,007 $0 $60,609 * $22,533 * $0 $9,291 $4,802 !32,289 $3,220 * $0 * $0 * 4I. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, P, NJ, AD * $76,206 * $19,978 I $0 S96, 184 * $3,220 I8,533 * Hl,007 $60,609 * $15,597 * $0 $32,289 H,291 ·$0 * H,S02 $0 * 4J. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, NC, AD 1 $94,601 t 8,533 I $11,0{)7 $77,432 * $!7, 169 * $0 $32,289 $0 $62,140 * $15,292 1 $9,291 $0 ib,332 t n, 220 • $0 * 4K. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, C7, AD 1 $84,673 I ·s22, s91 * ¾107,570 I 8,533 t $1 l, 007 $62,140 I $22,533 * $0 $9,Z'?i $3,220 I $0 I ~o !6,332 * $0 $32,289 4L. 3. + UPPER CARR FORK, T, NJ, AD * 177 1 736 I $i9 1 978 I 8,533 I Hl,007 $62, 1·i0 tc $15,597 * $97,714 * $0 t $0 $0 $0 $32,289 $9,291 $3,220 f i6,332 I 5A. 4. +MUDDY~ GALENA, P, NC , UD 1 8,362 i $ I 1,995 $70,529 * $17,169¼ $55,236 * $15,292 * $9,191 $0 I $0 *87, 697 * $0 I $4, 80 2 $3,220 ! $0 $25,729 58. 4. + MUDDY &GALENA, P, C7, MD + $77,769 + $22,897 * 8,362 * Sll, 995 $100,667 * $0 $0 l $0 I $9,491 $0 $55,236 * $22 1 533 I $4,802 n, 220 * ,25,729 5C. 4. + ~UDDY ; GALEi1A, P, t!J, ND 1 8,362 f Si 1, 195 $90,811 t ;9, 49 i H0,833 * $19, 978 * ~o t4, 802 155 , 236 * $15,597 * $0 $0 * $25,729 ;o * 5D. 4. + '.1UDDY ; Gr;LDA, i , i~C, HD 8,362 t :ll : ·:;95 $72, (i59 J H7, t69 f ~:.) rn9,2:a * ~o i so ;56,767 * H5,292 + $25,729 3a 3