Contributor |
Basquez, D., Pappe, M., McGuire, J., Johnson, B., Weimer, B., Luginbill, R. |
Abstract |
John Zink Hamworthy Combustion field personnel inspect thousands of burners at customer sites each year. Too often those flames are not only bad but sometimes potentially dangerous. There are a number of conditions needed for good flames. Burners should be operating at or near their design conditions which includes the excess air and draft levels, and the design firing rate (fuel pressure) and fuel composition. The combustion air must be properly distributed, the fuel to the burners must be clean, and both the air and fuel must be properly controlled. The burner and its associated equipment (e.g., tile and pilot) must also be properly installed and maintained. There are some visual indicators that should be checked for proper burner operation. These include uniformity (all flames in a given heater should normally look about the same), proper flame color, no leaning between flames or into process tubes, no pronounced hot spots or dark spots on the burner tiles, no irregular flame movement (e.g., no pulsing), and no unusual sounds (e.g., flashback).; Bad flames can lead to increased pollution emissions, reduced thermal efficiency, and unplanned shutdowns. Common reasons for bad flames include improper burner installation, maintenance, and operation. Dirty fuel is particularly problematic as it can cause fuel injectors to plug which can create multiple problems. Ugly flames can be dangerous and need to be corrected as soon as possible as they could lead to significant incidents and unplanned shutdowns. Examples of these irregular flames include flame impingement, huffing or pulsing, and severely lifted flames.; The purpose of this presentation is to discuss proper burner operation and what good flames look like and then to contrast that with lots of examples of improper burner operation including the causes and corrections. This information can be used in the risk-based inspection and performance monitoring processes. Typically, equipment has a function statement (primary/secondary) and performance objectives and ranges. The consequences when the function of the equipment has failed is documented in the earlier processes. |
OCR Text |
Show Process Burner Flames: Good, Bad, & Ugly C. Baukal1, D. Basquez2, M. Pappe1, J. McGuire1, B. Johnson1, B. Weimer1, R. Luginbill1 1John Zink Hamworthy Combustion (Tulsa, OK) 2HollyFronter (El Dorado, KS) American Flame Research Committee Salt Lake City, Utah September 17-19, 2018 Important Notice The information contained in these materials is for informational purposes only and is provided "AS IS", without warranties of any kind. Your use of the information contained herein is at your sole risk. We expressly disclaim any express or implied representations, warranties or guaranties, including without limitation, the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose. We will have absolutely no liability (whether direct, indirect or consequential) in connection with these materials (and/or the information contained therein) including without limitation, any liability for damage to person or property. We also reserve the right to make subsequent changes to the materials without prior notice. For purposes of this notification, "We" includes John Zink Company LLC and its affiliates and their respective employees, partners, principles, agents and representatives, and any third-party providers or sources of information or data. This presentation is subject to copyright and the information presented is confidential and/or proprietary to John Zink Company, LLC. Accessing, using, copying, and/or changing the presentation or any part hereof is strictly prohibited For information on patents and trademarks, see johnzinkhamworthy.com/legal-notices ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 2 Outline • Introduction • • • • Good Flames Bad Flames Ugly Flames Summary & Recommendations ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 3 Introduction • JZHC field personnel inspect thousands of burners each year & find a wide range of flame conditions: • • • Good - no changes needed Bad - changes needed but likely not dangerous Ugly - immediate changes needed, potentially dangerous ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 4 Outline • Introduction • Good Flames • Bad Flames • Ugly Flames • Summary & Recommendations ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 5 Good Flames - no changes needed • Principles of good burner operation: • • • • • Uniform flames Proper flame color No significant hot spots or dark spots on burner tiles Flames not leaning into each other or into process tubes Flames are stable • It's not a beauty contest - not looking for perfection! ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 6 Photos of Good Flames ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 7 Videos of Good Flames ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 8 Outline • Introduction • Good Flames • Bad Flames • Ugly Flames • Conclusions & Recommendations ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 9 Bad Flames - changes needed, but likely not dangerous • Examples of bad flames: • • • • • • • Non-uniform flames Poor flame patterns Improper flame colors High or low draft Significant hot spots or dark spots on burner tiles Flames leaning into each other (flame-flame interaction) Flames are stable ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 10 Non-Uniform Flames 2 air registers were closed ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 11 Flame Pattern Problems ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 12 Plugged Tips ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 13 Plugged Tips Before cleaning ©2018 John Zink Company LLC After cleaning **Proprietary & Confidential** 14 1 4 Plugged Staged Tip ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 15 Plugged Burners Irregular Flame Patterns ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 16 Fuel Injector ("tip") Problems Old burner tips ©2018 John Zink Company LLC New burner tips **Proprietary & Confidential** 17 Draft & O2 Problems Before adjustment After adjustment flat flame burners fired horizontally ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 18 Fuel Rich vs. Clean Firebox Heater flooded, fuel rich firebox ©2018 John Zink Company LLC Clear firebox, burners adjusted **Proprietary & Confidential** 19 Fuel Rich vs. Clean Firebox Hazy firebox ©2018 John Zink Company LLC After adjustment **Proprietary & Confidential** 20 Fuel Rich vs. Clean Firebox Long tailing cloudy flames, haze visible in the firebox ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** Clear firebox, no haze 21 Improper Air Adjustments Burners short of air, hazy tailing flames ©2018 John Zink Company LLC Same burners with proper air adjustments **Proprietary & Confidential** 22 Air Unbalanced Primary air door was closed ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 23 Not Enough Air to 1 Burner Irregular Flame Patterns ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 24 Leaning Flames 25 ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 25 Leaning Flames ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 26 Leaning Flames Baking soda used to visualize flame ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 27 Flame-Flame Interaction ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 28 Outline • Introduction • Good Flames • Bad Flames • Ugly Flames • Conclusions & Recommendations ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 29 Ugly Flames - immediate changes needed, potentially dangerous • Possible characteristics of ugly flames • • • Unstable flames Flame impingement (could lead to tube leak/rupture) Flames lifting off or flashing back ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 30 Unstable Flames 31 ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 31 Burner Going Unstable ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 32 3 2 Pulsating Flame ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 33 Pulsating Flame ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 34 Huffing Burner ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 35 Unstable Heater 0 -0.3 +0.3 0 Draft ©2018 John Zink Company LLC 3 %O2 **Proprietary & Confidential** 36 Flame Impingement ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 37 Flame Impingement Flames into roof tubes Deposits on tubes ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 38 Flame Impingement through Process Tubes Platformer (flame coming through tubes) ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 39 Flame Impingement ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 40 Flame Impingement on Roof Tubes 41 ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 41 Flame Rollover/Impingement ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 42 42 Tube Failure due to Impingement Note polished look of tubes, indicating flame impingement in wide area due to over-firing ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** Most failures caused by flame impingement 43 Tube Rupture Example Before rupture After rupture Photo courtesy of Associated Press ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 44 Flame Lift-Off ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 45 Flame Lift-Off ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 46 Flame Lift-Off ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 47 Flashback Some burner tips flashing back ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 48 Flashback Mixer flashing back ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 49 Flashback ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 50 Outline • • • • Introduction Good Flames Bad Flames Ugly Flames • Summary & Recommendations ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 51 Summary Process burner flames can be: • Good - no changes needed • Bad - changes needed but likely not dangerous • Ugly - immediate changes needed, potentially dangerous ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 52 Recommendations for Sites/Users: • • • • Properly install burners Operate burners within their design range Properly maintain burners Inspect burners/heaters regularly ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 53 Frequently Inspect Flames • Uniform flames • Proper flame color • Appropriate flame pattern • • No impingement Not too long or leaning • No pronounced hot spots or dark spots on burner tiles • No irregular flame movement (e.g., pulsing) • No unusual sounds (e.g., flashback) ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 54 Questions? ©2018 John Zink Company LLC **Proprietary & Confidential** 55 Thank You! |