PERRLA is Not Adequate

Update Item Information
Identifier perrla_is_not_adequate
Title PERRLA is Not Adequate
Creator Andrew G. Lee, MD; Jae Eun Lee
Affiliation (AGL) Chairman, Department of Ophthalmology, The Methodist Hospital, Houston, Texas; Professor of Ophthalmology, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York City, New York; (JEL) Class of 2023, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas
Subject Pupils; Examination
Description .Summary: • PERRLA is an abbreviation that is going to appear in many charts o But it has no assessment of the three pieces that we need o We must check in the light and in the dark • Why PERRLA is not enough o We're not testing their accommodation when we're testing their pupil o We're testing their response to light and near o When we're looking at pupils, we need to test both in the light and in the dark o We have to swing the flashlight for a Relative afferent pupillary defect • Normal Pupil o If we shine the light into the right pupil, both pupils will constrict o But also, that will be felt by the contralateral pupil because the innervation to the nucleus is bilateral o Both pupils are dilating because they're connected and so both pupils will dilate • What should we do? o When we have a RAPD on the left eye, we need to do the swinging flashlight test o Likewise, if we have a poorly reactive pupil to light, we need to check both the near reaction and the light reaction o We need to test all three pathways: the sympathetic and the parasympathetic pathway, light and dark, and we need to record the pupil size in the light and the dark o We need to swing the flashlight from the right to the left and from the left to the right to detect if there's a defect in the pupil pathway
Transcript So, one of the things that I don't like is PERRLA. Pupil equal round and reactive to light and accommodation. PERRLA: it's an abbreviation that is going to appear in many charts in hospitals in the city and across the country and perhaps even across the globe. The reason I don't like it is PERRLA has no assessment of the three pieces that we need. We need to measure the pupil response, and check for anisocoria, that is true. But we have to check in the light and in the dark. So, it should be PERRLDA. Duh. And, we need to be looking at the near reaction, and even though it's called PERRLA, accommodation is the change in the shape of the lens that occurs when we accommodate from the distance to the near. And really what we're trying to test is the same kinetic response to a target that's at near. It's not really testing their accommodation when we're testing their pupil. We're testing their response to light and near. And that is called, light near disassociation, when there is a difference between the light and the near response. And finally, we need to have some assessment of the Relative afferent pupillary defect. So literally you can have a patient who is PERRLA and have an anisocoria in the dark and the thing we're looking for there is a Horner's Syndrome. So, you could be PERRLA and have a Horner's Syndrome. You could also be PERRL and have a light near disassociation and we need to be able to test in the ER. And you can have PERRLA, a pupil that's equal round reactive to light and accommodation, and has an RAPD, a Relative afferent pupillary defect. And so, when we're looking at pupils, we need to test both in the light and in the dark and then we have to swing the flashlight for a Relative afferent pupillary defect. So, when we have a normal pupil, if we shine the light into this right pupil, both pupils will constrict, and that's because there is both a direct response to the light and a consensual response in the fellow light. So, when we have a direct response, pupils constrict, but also, that will be felt by the contralateral pupil because the innervation to the nucleus is bilateral. Likewise if we swing the light from the right pupil to the left pupil the constriction will be maintained there might be a little bit of difference while you're swinging but basically we're going to be swinging from the right to the left and then back to the right and if we see that the pupil dilates when we swing to the left eye that means the direct response in this left pupil is less than the consensual response from the right pupil. And that we call a relative afferent pupillary defect. Because relative to the fellow eye the afferent system in the pupil pathway has been damaged and what's interesting is both pupils are actually dilating when you swing the light from the right to the left in a patient who has a left RAPD. So if we're asked the question which pupil dilates in a left RAPD when we swing the light from the normal right pupil to the abnormal left pupil most residents will say the left pupil dilates which is true but the correct answer is both pupils are dilating because they're connected and so both pupils will dilate. And so, when we have a RAPD on the left, we need to do the swinging flashlight test. Likewise if you have a poorly reactive pupil to light we need to check both the near reaction and the light reaction because you cannot tell whether that's an efferent problem, there's something wrong with the iris, or an afferent problem, there's something wrong with the light sensing of the optic nerve on that site. And so, we have bilateral pupils that are both dilated and poor to reactive to light we want to test both the light and the near reaction the near reaction determining light near dissociation. And so, the point of this talk is basically to try and convince you not to use PERRLA. We need to test all three pathways: the sympathetic and the parasympathetic pathway, light and dark, and we're going to record the pupil size in the light and the dark, we're going to test the near reaction especially if the light reaction is impaired looking for light near dissociation of the pupils. And we're going to swing the flashlight from the right to the left and from the left to the right to detect if there's a defect in the pupil pathway on the afferent side relative to the fellow eye and you should remember that both pupils dilate when we swing from the normal pupil to the abnormal pupil in a patient who is has a RAPD. And that's because both the direct and the consensual response are connected and bilateral.
Date 2019-10
Language eng
Format video/mp4
Type Image/MovingImage
Collection Neuro-Ophthalmology Virtual Education Library: Andrew G. Lee Collection: https://novel.utah.edu/Lee/
Publisher North American Neuro-Ophthalmology Society
Holding Institution Spencer S. Eccles Health Sciences Library, University of Utah
Rights Management Copyright 2019. For further information regarding the rights to this collection, please visit: https://NOVEL.utah.edu/about/copyright
ARK ark:/87278/s6fz220s
Setname ehsl_novel_lee
ID 1469319
Reference URL https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s6fz220s