106150

- This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. ~ - 413 Ontari 0 Charles Barnes House Park Ci ty - UTAH STATE HISTORY 11 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 3 9222 50017 2700 HISTORIC SITE FORM (10-91) UTAH STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE 1 IDENTIFICATION Name of Property: Charles Barnes House Address: 413 Ontario Avenue Twnshp City, County: Park City, Summit, Utah UTM: Current Owner Name: USGS Map Name & Date: Park City East Everson Exemption Trust Current Owner Address: 2001 Lucky John Drive Range Section: Quad/2011 Park City, UT 84060 Tax Number: PC-468 Legal Description (include acreage): S 20112 FT LOT 29 & LOT 30 BLK 55 PARKCITY SURVEY NWD-241 XWD234 WWD-26 M22-528 M40-507 571-291 272-5371570-1177; 0.09 AC 2 ST ATUS/USE Property Category ..lbuilding(s) _structure _site _object Evaluation ..leligible!contributing • _ineligible/non-contributing _out-o.f-period Use Original Use: single dwelling Current Use: single dwelling 3 DOCUMENTATION Photos: Dates ..ldigital: Nov. 2013 .J..Prints: 2006 (2),1995,1983, 1940s _historic: Drawings and Plans _measuredfloor plans _site sketch map _Historic American Bldg. Survey _original plans available at: _other: Research Sources (check all sources consulted, whether useful or not) ..labstract of title ..lcity!county histories ..ltax card & photo ---personal interviews _building permit _USHS History Research Center _sewer permit ..l USHS Preservation Files ..lSanborn Maps USHS Architects File _obituary index _LDS Family History Library _city directories/gazetteers ..llocallibrary: Park City Museum ..lcensus records _university library(ies): _biographical encyclopedias ..lnewspapers Bibliographical References (books, articles, interviews, etc.) Attach copies of all research notes, title searches, obituaries, and so forth. Boutwell, John Mason and Lester Hood Woolsey. Geology and Ore Deposits of the Park City District, Utah. White Paper, Department of the Interior, United States Geological Survey. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1912. Carter, Thomas and Peter Goss. Utah's Historic Architecture, 1847-1940. Salt Lake City: Center for Architectural Studies, Graduate School of Architecture, University of Utah and Utah State Historical Society, 1988. Hampshire, David, Martha Sonntag Bradley and Allen Roberts. A History of Summit County. Coalville, UT: Summit County Commission, I 998. National Register of Historic Places. Park City Main Street Historic District. Park City, Utah, National Register #79002511. Peterson, Marie Ross and Mary M. Pearson. Echoes of Yesterday: Summit County Centennial History. Salt Lake City: Daughters of Utah Pioneers, 1947. Pieros, Rick. Park City: Past & Present. Park City: self-published, 2011. Randall, Deborah Lyn. Park City, Utah: An Architectural History of Mining Town Housing, 1869 to 1907. Master of Arts thesis, University of Utah, 1985. Ringholz, Raye Carleson. Diggings and Doings in Park City: Revised and Enlarged. Salt Lake City: Western Epics, 1972. Ringholz, Raye Carleson and Bea Kummer. Walking Through Historic Park City. Self-published,1984. Thompson, George A., and Fraser Buck. Treasure Mountain Home: Park City Revisited. Salt Lake City: Dream Garden Press, 1993. • NHRP listed in 1984 as part of Mining Boom Era Residences Thematic District Researcher/Organization: Daniel Carmen I CRSA Architecture Task 5-lntensive Level Surveys, Historic Sites Outside of Main Street Historic District Date: November 2015 581 4 ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION Building Style/ Type: shotgun type / Victorian Eclectic style Foundation Material: not verified Additions: _none ..x.minor _major (describe below) No. Stories_:_1_,_5_ _ __ Wall Material(s): drop-novelty wood siding Alterations: _none ..x.minor _major (describe below) Number of associated outbuildings _0__ and/or structures _0_. Briefly describe the principal building, additions or alterations and their dates, and associated outbuildings and structures. Use continuation sheets as necessary. The house at 413 Ontario was described in a 1984 National Register nomination as follows: "This house is a one and one half story frame shotgun building with a gable roof. Having been built deep onto the lot with the gable end to the street, it is possible that the plan is one room wide with rooms aligned one directly behind the other, typical of a shotgun house. There is a door with a single two over two double hung sash window centered directly above it on the fa9ade. A porch, which is probably not original, spans the facade. It was designed to complement the building, and to resemble the type of porch that might have been built. It has appropriately scaled lathe-turned porch piers, balusters and spindles. There are also spindles in the fan-like stickwork of the gable. That decorative element is also an addition. Windows on the sides of the house are irregularly spaced, most being the two over two double hung sash type. Several new windows were added to the north wall. They, however, are unobtrusive additions. There are two one story shed roof extensions on the north and south sides which may not be original. The north extension has a door in the west facade, and is stuccoed. The south extension is made of the same drop siding as the rest of the house, which may indicate that it was built as part of the original structure. In-period rear extensions are part of Park City's architectural vocabulary. Although in many cases an extension represents a major alteration of the original house, it usually contributes to the significance of a house because it documents the most common and acceptable method of expansion of the small Park City house. The effect of the extension and the new windows on the integrity of the building is minor. The house is in excellent condition, and maintains its original integrity." The house has been largely unchanged since the 1984 nomination. The roof is now sheathed with a standing seam metal rather than the shingle material shown in earlier photos. The hipped porch roof and small shed roofed addition are still sheathed with wood shingles. One of the brick chimneys was moved from the center of the house to the south side and the other removed. The overall form and materiality of the building remains intact and the building retains its hi~toric value. 5 HISTORY Architect/Builder: unknown Date of Construction: c, 1900 Historic Themes: Mark themes related to this property with "s" or "C" (S = significant, C = contributing). (see instructions for details) _Agriculture _Economics _Politics/ h..lndustry _Invention h..Architecture _Education Government _Archeology _Engineering _Landscape _Religion _Art _Entertainment/ Architecture _Science _Law _Commerce _Social History Recreation _Communications _Ethnic Heritage _Literature _Transportation _Community Planning _Exploration/ _Maritime History ...£..Other: Mining & Development _Military Settlement _Conservation _Health/Medicine _Performing Arts Write a chronological history of the property, focusing primarily on the original or principal owners & significant events. Explain andjustifY any significant themes marked above. Use continuation sheets as necessary. The history of this house was described in the 1984 National Register nomination form as follows: "Built c. 1900, the Charles Barnes House at 413 Ontario is architecturally significant as one of three well preserved, extant examples in Park City of a house that has the exterior configuration of a shotgun. The shotgun was a common house type in other mining towns across the country. It, however, was never one of the preferred house types in Park City. Less than ten examples of this type are extant in Park City, and the three included in the nomination are especially significant because they 582 Park City Preservation Consulting, CRSAArchitecture document the existence ofthe shotgun type among Park City houses, and because they are the only examples which have maintained their integrity to the present. Sanborn Insurance Maps indicate that this house was built between 1900 and 1907, although the 1907 map was the first to fully cover this area of town. It was probably constructed after the fire of 1898 which destroyed many of the houses in this area and throughout the town. The first recorded transaction involving this property was in 1903, when Charles Barnes sold it to Mettie Hubbard for $600. According to the census records in 1900, Barnes was living in a house which he and his brother owned on Daly Avenue, so it is likely that he had this house built between 1900 and 1903. It is unclear whether or not he ever lived here. Charles Barnes was born in Rhode Island in 1855 and came to Park City in 1890. He worked at various occupations including mining, blacksmithing, and jigging. The latter proved to be fairly profitable for him and his brother/partner, Marcus. Charles, who never married, died in Park City in 1936. Other owners of this house include J.R. and Metta Hubbard Conway (1903-14), Mr. and Mrs. D.H. Bertie (1914-17), Ida Hansen (1917-20), and Emma Johnson (1920-40)." Further research has uncovered more information regarding the other owners of this house. No information could be found on J.R. and Metta Hubbard or Mr. and Mrs. D.H. Bertie. Ida Hansen appears on the 1920 census, living in this house with her husband Bertel and their three children. Bertel worked in a mine as a repairman, and there is some evidence to suggest that he was also involved in prospecting. They sold the house in 1920 to Emma Johnson . Emma Johnson appears on the 1930 census for Park City, living on Marsac Avenue with her husband Ancil. It seems they used the house as an income property, and it was being rented at the time of that census by two separate families, Benjamin and Edna Ryan, and George and Geneva Wathan. Both Benjamin Ryan and George Wathan worked as miners. The house was still being rented out during the 1940 census, and was occupied at that time by William and Lorna Searle, as well as William ' s brother and sister in law, Clifton and Lela Cook, and their son. Both William and Clifton worked as miners at that time. Emma Johnson sold the house in 1940 to John and Lula Collins. The house is currently owned by Everson Exemption Trust. 413 Ontario Avenue. Southwest oblique. November 2013. Task 5-lntensive Level Surveys, Historic Sites Outside of Main Street Historic District 583 584 Park City Preservation Consulting , CRSAArchitecture Utah State Historical Society Property Type: Site No. _ _ __ _ _ __ Historic Preservation Research Office Structure/Site Information Form 1 Street Address: UTM : 12 458330 4499130 i= 413 Ontario Park City, Summit County, Utah Name of Structure: Charles Barnes House u: Present Owner: Lula Collins Owner Address: c/o K. W. Everson 314 Narcissus Street, Corona Del Mar, CA z 0 « 0 i= z w 0 South 20~ feet Lot 29 and Lot 30 B10ck 55 Less than one acre. Original Use: Present Use: C Site ~cellent = o Good o Deteriorated 3z o i= « IZ w :IE ::::I o oo pes Construction Date: c. 1900 Building Condition: Ru ins Photography: Research Sources: o-P;bstract oITiUe = I2-Slgnificant Unaltered = Major Alterations C--'rax Card & Photo 1983 [:::; Not of the - Contributory - Not Contributory Historic Period Sl ide No.: =Front =Side =Rear =Ot her Demolition Date: Final Register Status: o National Landmark = C National Regist er - Mu lti·Resourc e o State Register - Thematic Date of Photographs: 1983 o Personal Interviews c,....obiturary Index o LOS Church Archives ~ounty & City Histories LJ LOS Genealogical Society ;VOther =City Directories = Biographical EnCYClopedias District Photo No.: Views: 0 Front 0 Side 0 Rear C Other o U of U Library o BYU Library o USU Library ::I-Se.nborn Maps ~Iat Records/Map o Sewer Permit Preliminary Evaluation: Date o f Sli des: Views: o Building Permit Integrity: YMi nor Alterations PC 468 Tax#: Original Owner: probably Charles Barnes Residence S. R. 92625 Effective Age: Kind of Building: Year Built ITax Record): Legal Description 2 T. ~ewspapers C Utah State Historical Society o }'LC Library Census Records Bibliographical References (books. articles, records, interviews, old photographs and maps, etc.): 1900 Census Records. Surmrit County, Park City Precinct, p. l89-B. Salt lake Tribune. March 14, 1936, p. 27. Charles Barnes obituary. Researcher: Roger Roper Date4/84 Street Address: 4 W IX ~ I- o w !:: x o a:: <t 413 Ontario Site No: Architect! Builder: Building Materials: t-1ood Building Type/Style: Shotgun Description of physical appearance & significant architectural features: (Include additions, alterations, ancillary structures, and landscaping if applicable) This house is a one and one half story frame shotgun ruilding with a gable roof. Having been built deep onto the lot with the gable end to the street, it is possible that the plan is one room wide with rooms aligned one directly behind the other, typical of a shotgun house. There is a door with a single two over two double hung sash window centered directly above it on the facade. A porch, which is probably not original, spans the facade. It was designed to complement the bJilding, and to resemble the type of porch that might have been built. It has appropriately scaled lathe-turned porch piers, balusters and spindles. There are also spindles in the fan-like stickwork of the gable. That decorative element is also an addition. Windows on the sides of the house are irregularly spaced, most being the two over two double hung sash type. Several new windows were added to the north wall. They, however, are unobtrusive additions. There are two one story shed roof extensions on the north and south sides which may not be original. The north extension has a door in the west facade, and is stuccoed. The south extension is made of the same drop siding as the rest of the house, which may indicate that it was Pi;· ruilt as part of the original structure. In-period rear extensions are part of Park City's architectural vocabulary. Although in many cases an extension represents a major alteration of the original house, it ususally contributes (See cont 1m at i on sheet) . 5 >a:: o I- !a x Statement of Historical Significance: Construction Date: c. Built c. 1900, the Charles Barnes House at 413 Ontario is architecturally significant as one of three well preserved, extant examples in Park City of a house that has the exterior configuration of a shotgun. The shotgun was a common house type in other mining towns across the country. It, however, was never one of the preferred house types in Park City. Less than ten examples of this type are extant in Park City, and the three included in the nomination are especially significant because they document the existence of the shotgun type among Park City hooses, and because they are the only examples which have maintained their integrity to the present. Sanborn Insurance Maps indicate that this hoose was built between 1900 and 1907, althoogh the 1907 map was the first to fully cover this area of town. It was probably constructed after the fire of 1898 which destroyed many of the houses in this area and throughout the town. The first recorded transaction involving this property was in 1903, when Charles Barnes sold it to Mettie Hubbard for $600. According to the census records in 1900, Barnes was living in a house which he and his brother owned on Daly Averue, so it is likely that he had this house built between 1900 and 1903. It is unclear whether or not he ever lived here. Charles Barnes was born in Rhode Island in 1855 and came to Park City in 1890. He worked at various occupations including mining, blacksmithing, and jigging. The latter proved to be fairly profitable for him and his brother/partner, Marcus. Charles, who never married, died in Park City in 1936. Other owners of this hoose include J.R. and Metta fubbard Conway (1903-14), Mr. and Mrs. D.H. Bertle (1914-17), Ida Hansen (1917-20), and Enma Johnson (1920-40) • 1900 413 Ontario Descript ioncont i ru ed: to the significance of a hoose because it documents the most common and acceptable method of expansion of the small Park City house. The effect of the extension and the new windows on the integrity of the bJilding is minor. The house is in excellent condition, and maintains its original integrity. ENG 0 D iI N, G FOR H U H C' S To be Corrpleted -for All Sites 'Sent to the Naticnal P.egister or as a Follow-up to the Block Survey - , UPDATED 10/17/84 I , , , 14. m. CI. ST. P. SMI'I'Ik,CU'UAN NUMBER S. SITE BLOCK 6. II] WNE M. ,k ~ 0f\. ._ 7. f'0""LC 1/4 9. 1/<1 1/4 SEC. i<P4>,L/. I ;3 r:;d 10,N.T ,H rs I _Q .A, V,E ,N , U,t: , I /' - ,-T' '( ,L . .L , I • • , I It, STREET NAME S'IREET NO. t , NORTHING ' El~TING , ~, ·A , SJ . ,7 .· .5 ,1 , Is. 1\ 9 ,55 1 DKrn MAP REIERENCE RANGE WWNSHIP 8 I ~I : NOImI/SOurn I I .' 1 I , , , , : ~ /, « I I I 1 EPBT/WEST , ] l1.iEJ 12. [EJIl 1'1 @,<1 13.m 35. ~ ~ 'I-,-I~:~:~I : : : : : 0/ . f:.' V? ~ CULTURE 'il-liME .' 37. [ I I , COMMENTS Tr:r T El71WG I ! t , I I I I , I , • \ \ , , , , . , ASSOCIA'llD INDIVIDUAlS BUILDERS I , , I I 1\ n r: n E F G H I .J K L M N 0 P q R STU V W X Y Z t A I .- 3'8 ~ " [iQJ s.onG. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 89 m ASSOC. ORGAN, This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. r-. ·~ ' \.... -. . 40°37'30" 111'·030' ~ 5~ed bv :~e Geological Survey Mapped. eo * GNi \! I -: o. OC -:' .: : c: t' ::: ::: . r-,.; rih c . . : cei :"~ cOJ'"cina:e .system, I 7 I 1&1/, ~f.:;; ~I 2ci3M:LS· :~--=:-~ :i / \I lODO.meter u ~ .e· ; ~ zone 12, shc:,~· ~.~, s,'srse f'-1erc31Or gild ticks. To place on the prec ictea North American Datum 1983 'JE:~ ~.AT',_~, · • . • C Et'~' £;'; FOfi Sf, ' TEX AS, Hill County, HilLsboro, HilLsboro Residential Historic District (Hillsboro M R A), Roughly bounded by Country Club Rd., Thompson, Corsicana, Pleasant, Franlli'1, and Elm Sts. (07109/84) TEXAS, Oldham County, Chavez City Ruins (410L253)(New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle T R), (07/12/84) TEX AS, Oldham County, Chavez Suburbs East and West (41 OL254) (New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle 'f R), (07/12/84) TEXAS, Oldham CountYI Green No.5 (410L257) (New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle TR), (07/12/84) TEXAS, Oldham County, Gliffin Site (41 OL246) (New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle TR), (07/1 2/84) TEX AS, Oldham County, Mansfield 1(410 L50) (N ew Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle TH), (07/12/8~TEXAS, Oldha m County, MastonI(410L256) (New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle TR), (07/12/84) TEXAS, Oldham County, Maston No. 52 (410L235) (New Hexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle TR), (07/12/84) TEX AS, Oldham Cour~.9:, Stone Corrals No. 1-6 (41 OL250) (New Mexican Pastor Sites in Texas Panhandle T R), (07112/84) UTA H, Grand County> Moab vicinity, Dewey Bridge, N E of Moab on U T 128 (07112/84) UTAH, Salt Lake C·:i1iU9.:J Salt Lake City, Gibbs-Thomas House, 137 N.W. Temple St. (07/12/84) UT A H, Sum mit Countz., Park City, Austin, William, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 247 Ontario Ave. (01111/84) UTAH, Summit County:, Par k City, Barnes, Charles, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 413 Ontario Ave. (07/12/84) UTA H, Su m mit CountYJ Park City, Barr'€tt, Richard, House (Mining Boo m Era Houses T R), 36 Prospect Ave. (07/11/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Ba.r'ry: George J., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 250 Grant Ave. (07112/84) , UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Beggs, Ellsw orth J., House (Mini.'1g Boom Era Houses TR), 703 Park Ave. (07/11/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City , Brown, Otis L., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 713 Woodside Ave. (07111/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Buck, John W., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1110 Woodslde Ave. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park Cit.y, Campbell, William, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 164 Norfolk St. (07111/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park Cit.y, CarJing, Benedictus, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 660 Rossie Hill Dr. (07/12/84) . UTAH, Sur;n:nit County, Park City, Cassidy, James, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 33 King Rd. (07111/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Cavanaugh, James, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 564 Woodslde Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Clark, Peter, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1135 Park Ave. (07/11/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Condon, David F. and Elizabeth, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1304 Park Ave. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Cunningham, John F., House (Mi.:1ing Boom Era Houses TR), 606 Park Ave. (07/11/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, Cunni'1gham, Thomas, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 139 Main St. (07112/84) UTAH, SUI1l:nit County, Park City, Durkin Boarding House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 176 Main St. (07/12/84) scon M. MATHESON GOVERNOR February 9, 1984 Division of State History (UTAH STATE HISTOR ICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T . SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANOE SALT lAI<E CITY. UTAH 641 01-1182 TELEPHONE [phone] lu1a Collins c/o K. W. Everson 314 Narcissus Street Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 Dear Ms. Collins: We are pleased to report that your property at 413 Ontario, has been approved by the State Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee at its February 1, 1984 meeting for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. We have received comment from you regarding the eligibility of your property and will therefore submit the nomination to Washington as soon as possible. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the Preservation Office, Utah State Historical Society, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake City, Utah 84 101, 533-6017. Sincerely, A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer AKP:br Sta te History Board : Milton C. Abrams. Chairman • Theron H. Luke • Ted J . Warner • E llza:.-e:~ Mcr:z ;~-e • Thcn'iasG. Alexander Delio G Dayton • Wayne K. Hinton • Helen Z. Papanikolas • Da\lid S. Monson • E-Iza:)-e,n G-. ~ "", • ";':Iiam D. Owens This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. f-l 7'lS ll/ J OAt1a!lJ1; /900 ~j(j_!) 1~2-A -If" . . " '> J'4{I~/fV( _/ ,----",-- m1~6 - 1e:, \~-Uj 1hJJXJr:d. 1i~1M b. IY:)(~ ~ -(v~hJ fO% -f tis ;f$lI-it~.t-l" Al,jf, ~ o~ c,~~ " I u 0a!(;1(J!;) ~ b. 1~5? ~ Wat1f. .1JJdt4 !/ CMUI1 #;{;f4eu k1 l -1J *MiurtJ w/ .j(jH'l I JJjj This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. .' (' f:' C/ " PARK CITY SURVEY I-lORKSHEET NO. PC 466 / Name of site _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Subdivision -----------------Lot (s) Block 55 Presen~ Zoning 26=;4+;-2"t3 zt 70 .HR-l ------------- PRH1ARY Vie~'l west facade ---------~~~~----- Da teo i' pho t 0_-'2=..1<-8=2____.,-' . Negative File 13/23 / Phisical description: bargeboard; Two-storv frame; rectatHJular wi t .n gable:. yoGf· attached one-story porch with spindle frieze and balustrade' additions on both sides; Features of interest: decorat jve ] bay: small exterior chimney. Porch deta; Is and bargeboard Bui 1 ding rna terial s : _--"'w""o""o""d'--_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _BUi Idi ng typel sty Ie -gah....l ....e-...l;je~n"-ld........_ _ __ Modificati.ons: None to mi'nor'______x.. ____t-loderate _________ -M-aJ. or _________ ;" Explain: ____________________. ______________________________ __ Condition: Excellent _____Go oo_. __x<>--____F . ai r --------- ' i Deteriorated ----~ Corr.ment : _ - - - - - - - - -. resiq~niia~l______________ Or i gi na 1 us e : _.--'r::.,;e""'s""'... ·l d""e"",!l"""t=..l",,·a....l,.._______......,-____ Present use: SIGnFICANCE OF PRIVtJ..RY STRUCTURE ( Individual landm2.rk _____Typical example COlTU1'.ent: l~ctually Contributes to district X ------ not S1.:!re of date of build..;;:.i_n..J.g..:..;_m:;;.;."-'a... y.....;;;..b~e_n;:..;;.;:..ew_"_'_.______- - -.- - - - - - - '2 .- 5"r ....) .. 21./ ~ .' /(0 X 1\ .____ !lr~\ December 8, 1983 scon M. MATHESON GOVERNOR Division of State History Lula Collins c/o K. W. Everson 314 Narcissus Street Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 (UTAH STATE HISTOR ICAL SOCIETY) STA TE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMU"lITY AND ECONOMlC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T . SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANDE SALT l.Al<E CITY. UTAH 64101·1182 TELEPHONE [phone] Dear Ms. Collins: We are pleased to inform you that your property, 413 Ontario, will be considered by the State Revie\y Committee for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. The National Register is the Federal Government's official list of historic properties worthy of preservation. Listing in the National Register provides recognition and assists in preserving our Nation's heritage. Enclosed is a copy of the criteria under which properties are evaluated. Your property is being included in a thematic nomination of approximately one htmdred houses entitled: Park City Mining Boom Era Residences. All of the houses included in the nomination were presented in a public hearing sponsored by Park City's Community Development/Engineering Building and Planning , Departments, and conducted by staff members from our office on November 2, 1983. You are invited to attend the Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee Meeting, February 1, 1984 at 2:00 p.m. in the Marsac School in Park City. If the weather is inclement the meeting will be held at the same time at the Utah State Historical Society, Denver & Rio Grande Depot, Salt Lake City. At that time the Park City thematic nomination will be presented to the State Review Committee for approval before being sent to Washington for final approval and listing. Listing in the National Register provides the follO\¥ing benefits to historic properties: --Consideration in the planning for federally assisted projects. Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 provides that the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation be given an opportunity to comment on projects affecting such properties. --Eligibility for Federal tax benefits. If a property is listed in the National Register, certain tax provisions may apply. The Tax Reform Act of 1976, as a'1lended by the Revenue Act of 1978 and the Tax Treatmeant Extension Act of 1980, and the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981, contain provisions intended to encourage the preservation of depreciable historic structures by a11m..'ing favorable tax treatments for rehabili tati on, and to discourage destruction of historic buildings by eliminating certau1 Federal tax provisions for demolition of histor ic structures. Beginning January 1, 1982, the Economic Recovery Tax Act replaces the rehabilitation tax incentives available lH1der prior law with a 25% investment tax credit for rehabilitations of certain historic commercial, industrial and residential rental buildings. This can be comhined with a IS-year cost Sl ate H;SlOry 80ard: Mii!01 C . A~:,""'S Ch3 .',,",2" J . E!con Dorman '. ....J;;y;'e K f-!' ~:C '1 . • '~ he r()n H. Luke ' ,·l Z Papanikoias • • Anand A. Yang • EliZdbeltl Mor.~ague • T:-'omas G. Alexander DaVIS S. Monso" • E;il'aoettl Griffith • William D. Owens recovery period for the adjusted basis of the historic building. Historic buildings with certified rehabilitations receive additional tax savings because they are exempt from any requirement to reduce the basis of the building by the amount of credit. The Tax Treatment Extension Act of 1980 includes provisions regarding charitable contributions for conservation purposes of partial interests in historically important land areas or structures. --Consideration of historic values in the decision to issue a. surface coal mining permit where coal is located, in accord with the Surf8;ce M.inlng a.nd Control Act of 1977. . --Quali fication for Federal grants for historic preservat ion when funds ' are available. Owners of private properties nominated to the National Regist ~r ' of Historic Places must be given an opportunity to concur in or object to 11sti Hg :in accord with the National Historic Preservation Act Amendments df .:.11980 and Federal regulations 36 CFR Part 60. Any owner or partial owner 'o ('ptlvat e property "mo chooses to object to listing is required to submi t , t o".t:he state. Historic Preservation Officer a notarized statement certifying .that ~ \t.he party is the sole owner of the private property, as appropriate, and' ()bjocts to the listing. For a single privately owned property with one owner ~th~.property will not be listed if the owner objects. In nominations wi th tI1I.I~~ ~'Ple ownership of a single property, the property will not by list·?...d'i.,j.f ,; 3. majority of the owners objects. Each owner or partial owner of privat~ p~'op~rty has one vote regardless of what part of the property that party own-s<. If the property cannot be listed because the owner or a majority of owne r s objects prior to the submission of a nomination by the State, the State Jlistorlc Preservation Officer shall submit the nomination to the Keeper of ',the National Register for a . determination of the eligibility of the property f:Qt -incl u s~(}.ri in the National Register. If the property is then determined eligible for! .; listing, although not fonnally listed, Federal agencies will be r equired th ," allow the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation an opportuni ty t.Q, . ~.omm~nt before the agency may fund, license, or assist a project which will aff~t the property. If you choose to object to the listing of your proper ty, the - . - notarized objection must be submitted to Dr. Melvin T. Smith, 1)ire¢tora.nd State Historic Preservation Officer, Utah State Historical Soci¢ty, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake City, Utah 84101. If you wish to comment on whether the property should be nominated to the " National Register, please send your comments to the above address. Comments must be received before the State Review Committee considers this nomiriation on February 1, 1984. A copy of the nomination will be on file at . the Preservation Office after it is completed and will be made available to you upon request. Sincerely yours, +,~.~ A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer DT:br Enclosure Pi\H.K CITY SURVEY \"lORKSHEET NaTTIe 0: site '1i o f ,C- SITE NO. PC 466 Subdi vi s i on _____________ --~ E - - BloCK_5_S__Lot (s) ddress ____~4~l~3~O~n~t~a~r~i~o~______________~___ ===_------------ Owner Nathan & Florence Cossy 26,27,28 Present Zoning .HR-l Owner Address __~P~.O~.~B~o~x~=S~4~~P~a==r~k~C~1~·t~y~,~U~t~a~h~~8~4~O~6~O~____________________________ - n PRI~~Y ---------------- STRUCTURE Vie'tr ~--~~~~~~-----west facade pc L1 hb t -~ =I~ !~;~(~:-!_ 7><. - i :; Date or phot0--1L~8~2_______ Negative File-ldJ-U.._ _ "/ '~"-'",~ ~-'~~':~,~~;r,i. Pbysi4Bil ·.:<.i\';lscri,ts:'1:i(jn: ~ ~ <{:( ,:,; " : ., ~ " ;' '.",'; ..,.... /:'i 'I\oro-sto!:V frame; rectan(]ular with gable roof; decorative bargeboard; " att:.:t:ched: one-story porch with spindle frieze and balUstrade: . ~ .:-. .: small 4 L ~ };".~ :' ... " .~' additions,"on -botn 's islesj Fe a t ur e s': Q£ in exterior chimney. te:tes t : _~P~o~r...:c~hl.L.;d~e...t!:;a5iU.j.r..li;;i.s_ang,ud~_bOJ.alOU..r~gt:.eb.u5.!og.aL.r1J.d____________-.-:.-______ "'s-'C " "" -'\ Build i ngtnateriat~ :_.....Dw~o~o~d'--_____________B . uilding type/style Hodifications~ 1~8ne to minor _ _J;x"'--_ _ _,lvloderate ,~ gable QPd Major __________ ..~ .. :J" ~ ... ~ Explain: ____~--------_---__------------------------------------------Good ____--"x"'--_ _ _ _ Fai r _____---'Deter i or 2. ted ________ Condition: Exc~llent ; Comment: ____________________________________________________________________ ------ Pre s en t us e : _____r....e.. ,S04<lo1..ld.· . .,eO&Jn....t~l"'·Ja...l____________Or i gi nal us e : __~r...,e""s...... 1· d,..e""'n~t_ia~J_____________ SIG:H FICJI.NCE OF PRI IvLl\RY STRUCT URE IncE vidual landmark ____Ty pi c::l.l example x COmIne !1t: may be new. Actually not sure of date of building; Contributes to district __~X~__ O ba 0 Q.. -Jd.s (On ! ~9 SCV),;) f'l ... )-a,.,d 7'0 CdL ~ tt!X- ~ . t:j ~S" <>Yo> 11'4~ ~ ~ ~ ~ rn 11M- Sq.//.., seon M. MATHESON August 7, 1984 loIs. Lu1a Collins c/oK. \,. Everson 314 Narcissus Street Corona Del ~~r, CA 92625 GOVERNOR Division of State History (UTAH STATE HISTOR ICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T. SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANOE SALT lAKE CITY. UTAH 84101-1182 TELEPHONE [phone] Dear f.1s. Collins: It is my distinct pleasure to inform you that on July 12 J1984, your property at ~~ Ontario and 413 Ontario, Park City, nominated by the Historic and Cultural Sites Review Corrnnittee and the Utah State Historic Preservation Officer as part of the Park City Thematic Resources Nomination, ~'as officially listed in the National Register of Historic Places by the National Park Service and ?vIs. Carol Shull, Acting Keeper of the National Register. The National Register of Historic Places is the official list of historic properties recognized by the Federal Government as worthy of preservation for their sighificance in American history, arcllitecture, archeology, engineering and cultt.irE~. Located in the National Park Service, Department of the Interior. the program is part of a national policy to coordinate and support public and -private efforts to identify, evaluate, and protect our cultural and natural resources, and is maintained by the Secretary of the Interior under provisions of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966. Listing in the National Register provides the follm.;ing benefits to historic properties: -Consideration in the planning for federally assisted projects. Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation .~t of 1966 provides that the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation be given an opportunity to comment on prc)jects affecting such propert~es. . -Eligibility for Federal tax benefits for rehabilitations of certain historic commercial, industrial and residential rental buildings. -Consideration of historic values in the decis ion to issue a surface coal mining permit where coal is located; in accord with the Sur face ~1ining and Control Ac t of 1977. -Qualification for Federal grants for historic preservation when funds are available. Slate History Board: Milton C. Abrams . Challman • Theron H. Luke • Ted J. Warner • Ehza:,e:,-, Mcr:a;o_"i! • Della G Dayton • Wayne K. Hinton • Helen Z. Papanikolas • David S. Monson • E·lza:>e'" G'~", • 'ihon'as G. Alexander W;:!iam O. Owens Ms. Lula Collins Augus t Page 2 :s) 1984- Listing COeS not mean that the Federal Government wants to acquire the property', place res tricti ve covenants on the land) or dictate the color or materials used on individual buildings. State and local ordinances or lah~ establishing restrictive zoning, special design review committees, or revie\-1 of exterior alterations, are not a part of the National Register program and should be clearly separated from the function of the National Register as a tool in the Federal planning process. Sincerely, ~.'W\U A. Kent Pm..ell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer Mt': jjt,..- December 1, 1983 Dr. Melvin T. Smith, Director and State Historical Preservation Officer Utah State Historical Society 300 Rio Grande .... ~~lt Lake City, Utah 84101-1182 '( " , Dear Dr. Smi th: We received a letter dated October 20, 1983, regarding our property located at 417 Ontario, Park City, Utah being considered for nomination to the National Register of Historical places. This is to inform you that we, as the owners of this private property, object to the listing of our property in the Register at this time. Thank you for your consideration. ~~ r-1~/)/l.{!".e.., eC-1-~ Nathan Cossey Florence Cossey SUBSCRIBED My Commission Expires: /-3--Fs Charles Barnes House 413 Ontario, Park City Charles Barnes House October 1983 Photo by Roger Roper, Negative: Utah State Historyical Society 413 Ontario, Park City, Summit County, Utah Northwest corner Charles Barnes ~H~o~ us_e_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _413 _1Ontario, Park City Kodachrome SLIDE ( ) t.." 'ld ; C'\ r vi ' Kodak Charles Barnes House 413 Ontario, Park City EKTACHROME Charles Barnes House 413 Ontario, Park City Kodachrome SLIDE + PROCESSED BY KODAK