114486

- This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. ~ - 577 Deer Valley Road Park City - J UTAH STATE HISTORY 1111111111 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 3 9222 50017 2379 L HISTORIC SITE FORM (10-91) UTAH STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE 1 IDENTIFICA nON Name of Property: 577 Deer Valley Drive Address: 555 Deer Valley Drive #10 Twnshp City, County: Park City, Summit, Utah UTM: Current Owner Name: USGS Map Name & Date: Park City East Hunter Ryan Metcalf Current Owner Address: PO Box 680188 Range Section: Quad/20l1 Tax Number: LINE-I0 Park City, UT 84068-0188 Legal Description (include acreage): UNIT 10 THE LINE CONDOMINIUM; ACCORDING TO THE OFFICIAL PLAT ON FILE IN THE SUMMIT COUNTY RECORDERS OFFICE CONT 528 SQ FT TOGETHER WITH AN EQUAL UND INT IN THE COMMON AREA 1834-15352046-970; 0.01 AC 2 STATUSIUSE Property Category --lbuilding(s) _structure _site _object Evaluation _eligible!contributing --lineligible/non-contributing _out-ofperiod Use Original Use: single dwelling Current Use: single dwelling 3 DOCUMENTATION Photos: Dates --ldigital: Nov. 2013 (2) 2flrints: 2006, 1995, 1983 _historic: Drawings and Plans --lmeasuredfloor plans _site sketch map _Historic American Bldg. Survey _original plans available at: --lother: plat survey, 12/13/2005 Research Sources (check all sources consulted, whether useful or not) --labs tract of title --lcity!county histories --ltax card & photo ----personal interviews _building permit _USHS History Research Center _sewer permit --lUSHS Preservation Files --lSanborn Maps USHS Architects File _obituary index _LDS Family History Library _city directories/gazetteers --llocallibrary: Park City Museum --lcensus records _university library(ies): _biographical encyclopedias --lnewspapers Bibliographical References (books, articles, interviews, etc.) Attach copies of all research notes, title searches, obituaries, and so forth. Boutwell, John Mason and Lester Hood Woolsey_ Geology and Ore Deposits of the Park City District, Utah. White Paper, Department of the Interior, United States Geological Survey. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1912. Carter, Thomas and Peter Goss. Utah's Historic Architecture, 1847-1940. Salt Lake City: Center for Architectural Studies, Graduate School of Architecture, University of Utah and Utah State Historical Society, 1988. Hampshire, David, Martha Sonntag Bradley and Allen Roberts. A History of Summit County. Coalville, UT: Summit County Commission, 1998. National Register of Historic Places. Park City Main Street Historic District. Park City, Utah, National Register #79002511. Peterson, Marie Ross and Mary M. Pearson. Echoes of Yesterday: Summit County Centennial History. Salt Lake City: Daughters of Utah Pioneers, 1947. Pieros, Rick. Park City: Past & Present. Park City: self-published, 2011. Randall, Deborah Lyn. Park City, Utah: An Architectural History of Mining Town Housing, 1869 to 1907. Master of Arts thesis, University of Utah, 1985. Ringholz, Raye Carleson. Diggings and Doings in Park City: Revised and Enlarged. Salt Lake City: Western Epics, 1972. Ringholz, Raye Carleson and Bea Kummer. Walking Through Historic Park City. Self-published, 1984. Thompson, George A., and Fraser Buck. Treasure Mountain Home: Park City Revisited. Salt Lake City: Dream Garden Press, 1993. Researcher/Organization: John Ewanowski, CRSA Architecture Task 5-lntensive Level Surveys, Historic Sites Outside of Main Street Historic District Date: September 2015 191 4 ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION Building Style/Type: hall-parlor house No. Stories_:_1_ _ _ __ concrete Wall Material(s): drop-novelty wood siding --------------Alterations: _none _minor ..JLmajor (describe below) Additions: ..JLnone _minor _major (describe below) Foundation Material: Number of associated outbuildings _0__ and/or structures _0__. Briefly describe the principal building, additions or alterations and their dates, and associated outbuildings and structures. Use continuation sheets as necessary. 577 Deer Valley Drive was described by Roger Roper in a National Register nomination as follows: "This house is a one story frame hall and parlor house with a gable roof. As is typical of Park City hall and parlor houses, it has a symmetrical fayade with a door set slightly off-center between two windows, and a porch centered over the openings on the fayade. The house is two rooms deep with an original rear shed extension that was added after the original construction. It projects beyond the west wall, and a door that possibly provides access to a wood or coal shed was added to the south side of that projection. In-period rear extensions are part of Park City's architectural vocabulary. Although in many cases an extension represents a major alteration of the original house, it usually contributes to the significance of a house because it documents the most common and acceptable method of expansion of the small Park City house. There are two other entrances both into the rear shed extensions on the east and west sides. There is a window in each of the gable ends. All of the windows are the one over one double hung sash type. Except for the addition of the rear shed extension, which is an unobtrusive change, the house is essentially unaltered and maintains its original integrity." According to the Building Department, since the writing of this description, the house has been reconstructed entirely, with several major alterations. The largest alteration is the lack of accurate reconstruction of the front porch and it's covering structure. On the west side of the front fayade, the two windows flanking the middle window have been added as well. The side gable roofis covered by asphalt shingles. The foundation is concrete, and was put in as part of the reconstruction. The changes made to the structure and the lack of original materials being used in the reconstruction diminish the historic value of the home significantly. 5 HISTORY Architect/Builder: unknown Date of Construction: c. 1895 Historic Themes: Mark themes related to this property with "s" or "c" (S = significant, C = contributing). (see instructions for details) _Agriculture _Economics f::....Industry _Architecture _Education Government _Invention _Archeology _Engineering _Landscape _Religion _Art _Entertainment/ _Science Architecture _Commerce _Law Recreation _Social History _Communications _Ethnic Heritage _Literature _Transportation _Community Planning _Exploration/ _Maritime History f::....Other: Mining & Development Settlement _Military _Conservation _Performing Arts _Health/Medicine Write a chronological history of the property, focusing primarily on the original or principal owners & significant events. Explain andjustifY any significant themes marked above. Use continuation sheets as necessary. From the 1984 National Register nomination: "Built c. 1890, this house at 577 Deer Valley Road is architecturally significant as one of76 extant hall and parlor houses in Park City, 22 of which are included in this nomination. The hall and parlor house, the earliest house type to be built in Park City, and one of the three most common house types that were built during the early period of Park City's mining boom era, significantly contributes to the character of the residential area. "Built by at least 1907, as indicated by the Sanborn Insurance Maps which first covered this area that year, this house was probably constructed in the 1880s or 1890s, as were the majority of Park City's hall and parlor houses. The exact date of construction and the name of the original owner are unknown. By at least 1910 this property, referred to as the "8th house, north side of Deer Valley Road," indicate that it was owned by Rachel and George Urban, who also owned the 2 nd , 3rd , and 192 Park City Preservation Consulting, CRSAArchitecture 5th houses along that road as well as property in other parts of town. It is uncertain whether or not those four numbered houses were part of a group of five houses at 321,339,345,555, and 777 involving the Urbans in 1912 (see 555 Deer Valley Road). The 1910 census records, which listed the address for many households surveyed, do not list the address for this house, so it is difficult to determine who was living here at that time. "Rachel Urban was the principal madame of Park City's red light district, which was concentrated on Heber Avenue, the lower portion of Deer Valley Road. There is no substantial evidence, however, to support as assumption that this was one of her "business houses." The documented red light district in Park City is not known to have extended this far east out oftown, and older residents of the area claim that these houses along Deer Valley Road were all occupied only by miners and laborers. The census records appear to support that claim. Like the other property holding of the Urbans in other parts of town, it is likely that this house, too, was used as investment property. Other owners of the property include Roy Pederson, Ethel M. Kimber and Alma H. Pederson." The site has subsequently been developed, with a modem condominium constructed in between the historic 577 and 555 Deer Valley Road. While the house and condominium are not physically connected, the larger surrounding structures diming the historic integrity of the site. Furthermore, reconstruction during this renovation in the first decade of the 2000s utilized non-original materials to a large degree, significantly diminishing the historic integrity ofthe house. Task 5-lntensive Level Surveys, Historic Sites Outside of Main Street Historic District 193 577 Deer Valley Drive, Park City, Summit County, Utah Historic Site Form-continuation sheet 577 Deer Valley Drive. Southeast oblique. November 2013. 577 Deer Valley Drive. South elevation. November 2013. 194 Park City Preservation Consulting, CRSAArchitecture HISTORIC SITE FORM - HISTORIC SITES INVENTORY PARK CITY MUNICIPAL CORPORATION (10-08) 1 IDENTIFICATION Name of Property: Address: 577 Deer Valley Drive AKA: City, County: Park City, Summit County, Utah Tax Number: Current Owner Name: Parent Parcel(s): Current Owner Address: Legal Description (include acreage): 2 STATUS/USE Property Category ~ building(s), main building(s), attached building(s), detached building(s), public o building(s), accessory structure(s) o o o o Evaluation * Landmark Site ~ Significant Site o Not Historic o Reconstruction Date: 200? Permit #: ~ Full 0 Partial *National Register of Historic Places: ~ ineligible listed (date: ) o Use Original Use: Residential Current Use: Residential o eligible 3 DOCUMENTATION Photos: Dates tax photo: ~ prints: historic: c. o o Drawings and Plans measured floor plans site sketch map Historic American Bldg. Survey original plans: other: o o o o o Research Sources (check all sources consulted, whether useful or not) abstract of title ~ city/county histories tax card 0 personal interviews original building permit 0 Utah Hist. Research Center sewer permit 0 USHS Preservation Files ~ Sanborn Maps 0 USHS Architects File o obituary index 0 LDS Family History Library city directories/gazetteers 0 Park City Hist. Soc/Museum census records 0 university library(ies): biographical encyclopedias 0 other: newspapers o o o o o o o o Bibliographical References (books, articles, interviews, etc.) Attach copies of all research notes and materials. Blaes, Dina & Beatrice Lufkin. "Final Report." Park City Historic Building Inventory. Salt Lake City: 2007. Carter, Thomas and Goss, Peter. Utah's Historic Architecture, 1847-1940: a Guide. Salt Lake City, Utah: University of Utah Graduate School of Architecture and Utah State Historical Society, 1991 . McAlester, Virginia and Lee. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1998. Roberts, Allen. "Final Report." Park City Reconnaissance Level Survey. Salt Lake City: 1995. Roper, Roger & Deborah Randall. "Residences of Mining Boom Era, Park City - Thematic Nomination." National Register of Historic Places Inventory, Nomination Form. 1984. 4 ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION & INTEGRITY Building Type and/or Style: Hall-Parlor No. Stories: 1 Additions: ~ none 0 minor 0 major (describe below) Alterations: 0 none 0 minor ~ major (describe below) Number of associated outbuildings and/or structures: 0 accessory building(s), # _ _ ; 0 structure(s), # _ _ . General Condition of Exterior Materials: Researcher/Organization: Preservation Solutions/Park City Municipal Corporation Date: 12-2008 , Park City, Utah Page 2 of 3 0' Good (Well maintained with no serious problems apparent.) o Fair (Some problems are apparent. Describe the problems.): o Poor (Major problems are apparent and constitute an imminent threat. Describe the problems.): o Uninhabitable/Ruin Materials (The physical elements that were combined or deposited during a particular period of time in a particular pattern or configuration . Describe the materials.): Foundation: Concrete. Walls: Wood siding. Roof: Gable roof form is under construction, final sheathing not yet applied. Windows/Doors: single and grouped double-hung sash type. Essential Historical Form: 0' Retains Location: 0 Original Location 0 Does Not Retain, due to: 0' Moved (date _200? __ ) Original Location: Within current site. Design (The combination of physical elements that create the form, plan, space, structure, and style. Describe additions and/or alterations from the original design, including dates--known or estimated--when alterations were made): According to the Building Department, this one-story hall-parlor house was completely reconstructed using very little of the original material. The description provided in the National Register nomination has not been accurately reconstructed due to the failure to reconstruct the front porch and by the use of window openings that were not part of the original design. (see Structure/Site Form, 1983). Setting (The physical environment--natural or manmade--of a historic site. Describe the setting and how it has changed over time.): The setting has changed due to the house being reconstructed as part of a larger development, but the close proximity of surrounding structures is not uncommon in Park City's historic neighborhoods. Workmanship (The physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or people during a given period in history. Describe the distinctive elements.): The physical evidence from the period does not exist, but the elements typically found on Park City's mining era homes are evident--plan finishes, side gable roof form, restrained ornamentation, and wood siding (though siding was typically painted). Feeling (Describe the property's historic character.): The physical elements of the site, in combination, do not effectively convey a sense of life in a western mining town of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Association (Describe the link between the important historic era or person and the property.): The Hall-Parlor house form is the earliest type to be built in Park City and one of the three most common house types built in Park City during the mining era; however, the extent of the fact that this is an inaccurate reconstruction significantly diminishes its association with the past. This site was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1984 as part of the Park City Mining Boom Era Residences Thematic District. It was originally built within the historic period, defined as 1872 t01929 in the district nomination. However, because the building has been reconstructed, it would no longer be considered eligible for the National Register as part of an updated or amended nomination. As a result, it does not meet the criteria set forth in LMC Chapter 15-11 for designation as a Landmark Site. It, however, retains important local historic significance and meets the criteria set forth in LMC Chapter 15-11 for designation as a Significant Site. 5 SIGNIFICANCE Architect: 0' Not Known Builder: 0 Not Known 0 Known: (source:) 0 Known: (source: ) Date of Construction: c. 1895 , Park City, Utah Page 3 of 3 The site must represent an important part of the history or architecture of the community. A site need only be significant under one of the three areas listed below: 1. Historic Era: Settlement & Mining Boom Era (1868-1893) Mature Mining Era (1894-1930) o Mining Decline & Emergence of Recreation Industry (1931-1962) o o Park City was the center of one of the top three metal mining districts in the state during Utah's mining boom period of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, and it is one of only two major metal mining communities that have survived to the present. Park City's houses are the largest and bestpreserved group of residential buildings in a metal mining town in Utah. As such, they provide the most complete documentation of the residential character of mining towns of that period, including their settlement patterns, building materials, construction techniques, and socio-economic make-up. The residences also represent the state's largest collection of nineteenth and early twentieth century frame houses. They contribute to our understanding of a significant aspect of Park City's economic growth and 1 architectural development as a mining community. 2. Persons (Describe how the site is associated with the lives of persons who were of historic importance to the community or those who were significant in the history of the state, region, or nation): 3. Architecture (Describe how the site exemplifies noteworthy methods of construction, materials or craftsmanship used during the historic period or is the work of a master craftsman or notable architect): 6 PHOTOS Digital color photographs are on file with the Planning Department, Park City Municipal Corp. Photo No.1: Southwest oblique. Camera facing northeast, 2006. Photo No.2: South elevation. Camera facing north, 1995. Photo No.3: Southeast oblique. Camera facing northwest, 1983. I From "Residences of Mining Boom Era, Park City - Thematic Nomination" written by Roger Roper, 1984. Utah State Historical Society Property Type: Site No. _ _ _ _ _ __ Historic Preservation Research Office Structure/Site Information Form 1 Street Address: 0 Name of Structure: z ~ House at 577 Deer Valley Road <C () u:: ~ z w Q UTM: 577 Deer Valley Road Park City, Summit County, Utah Present Owner: E. J. G. Inc. Owner Address: #5 Walker Court, Park City, Utah Year Built (Tax Record): Legal Description 12 458590 4499320 T. S. R. 84060 Effective Age: Kind of Building: Tax ,: PC 531 4 room house North side Heber Avenue #204 Deer Valley (House No. 577 8th house side of Deer Valley forrrerly house No. 204 North si de Deer Valley). Also, beginning at point on Northerly right-of-way line Deer Valley entrance road and also 544.55 feet and East 376.24 feet from East ~ corner Section 16 T2S R4E; thence North 7 degrees 46 minutes East 109.43 feet " South 79 degrees 37 minutes East 157.61 feet; South l_See contjnyatj on sheet) 2 Original Owner: Construction Date: c. 1890 Original Use: Residence Integrity: Preliminary Evaluation: Final Register Status: o Site o Unaltered Q-Signlficant 0 National Landmark 0 District o--Minor Alterations o Contributory 0 National Register 0 Multi·Resource o State Register o Thematic o Good o Ruins o Deteriorated o ~ I- Z w :::E ::I () o Q PreS(YIt Use: Building Condition: ~ellent 3z Demolition Date: o Major Alterations Photography: Date of Slides: 1983 o Not Contributory Slide No.: Historic Period Date of Photographs: 1983 Photo No.: Views: 0 Front 0 Side 0 Rear 0 Other Views: 0 Front 0 Side 0 Rear 0 Other Research Sources: o Not of the IIJ.-.AOstract of Title iJJ..-8anborn Maps (]...JIIewspapers llJ-Ptat Records I Map O-:fax Card & Photo o City Directories o Biographical Encyclopedias o Building Permit t::!-ebiturary Index o Utah State Historical Society o Personal Interviews o LOS Church Archives o Sewer Permit O-e-ounty & City Histories o LDS Genealogical Society o U of U Library o BYU Library o USU Library o SLC Library .g(Other Census Records Bibliographical References (books, articles, records, interviews, old photographs and maps, etc.): Cowin, Nonna.. Telephone interview, March 6, 1984, Salt Lake City, Utah. Dermis, Gladys. Telephone interview, January 25, 1984, Park City, utah. KtmlIEr, Bea. Interview, February 10, 1984, Park City, Utah. 1900 Census Records. Stmrd..t County, Parle City Precinct. Researcher: "Qno-o.... "Rnno.... Date: tJ./P.b. Street Address: 4 577 Deer Valley Road Site No: Architect/ Builder: Building Materials: Wood Building Type/Style: Hall &: Parlor House Description of physical appearance & significant architect,ural ~eatures: (Include additions, alterations, ancillary structures, and landscaping If applicable) This house is a one story frame hall and parlor house with a gable roof. As is typical of Park City hall and parlor houses, it has a rectangular form oriented broadside to the street, a generally symmetrical facade with a door set slightly off-center between two windows, and a porch centered over the openings on the facade. The house is two rooms deep with an original rear shed extension which makes the house look like a saltbox type. There is a second smaller shed extension that was added after the original construction. It projects beyond the west wall, and a door that possibly provides access to a wood or coal shed was added to the south side of that projection. In-period rear extensions are part of Park City's architectural vocabulary. Although in many cases an extension represents a major alteration of the original house, it ususa11y contributes to the significance of a house because it documents the most common and acceptable method of expansion of the small Park city house. There are two other entrances, both into the rear shed extensions on the east and west sides. These is a window in each of the gable ends. All of the windows are the one over one double hung sash type. Except for the ;' -' l;addition of the rear shed extension, which is an unobtrusive change, the house is essentially unaltered and maintains its original integrity. 5 > a: o t; ~ Statement of Historical Significance: Construction Date: Built c. 1890, this house at 577 Deer Valley Road is architecturally . Significant as one of 76 extant hall and parlor houses in Park City, 22 of which are included in this nomination. The hall and parlor house, the earliest house type to be built in Park City, and one of the three most common house types that were built during the early period of Park City's mining boom era, significantly contributes to the character of the residential area. Bun t by at least 1907, as indicated by the Sanborn Insurance Maps which fi rst covered this area that year, this house was probably constructed in the leaOs or 1890s, as were the majority of Park City's hall and parlor houses. The exact date of construction and the name of the original owner are unknown. By at least 1910 this property, referred to as the "8th house, north side of Deer Valley Road," indicate that it was owned by Rachel and George Urban, who also owned the 2nd, 3rd, and 5th houses along that road as well as property in other parts of town. It is uncertain whether or not those four numbered houses were part of the group of five houses at 321, 339, 345, 555, and 777 Deer Valley Road, which were referred to in another property transaction involving the Urbans in 1912 (see 555 Deer Valley Road). The 1910 census records, which listed the addresses for many of the households surveyed, do not list the address for this house, so it is difficult to detemine who was living here at that time. Rachel Urban was the principal madame of Park City's red light district, which was concentrated on Heber Avenue, the lower portion of Deer Valley Road. There is no substantial evidence, however, to support an assumption that this was one of her IIbusiness houses. II The documented red light dhtrict in Park City is not known to have extended this far east out of town, and older (See continuation sheet) c. 1890 577 Deer Valley Road Hi story conti nued: residents of the area claim that these houses along Deer Valley Road were all occupied only by miners and laborers. l The census records appear to support that claim. like the other property holdings of the Urbans in other parts of town, it is likely that this house, too, was used as investment property. Other owners of the property include Roy Pederson, Ethel M. Kimber and Alma H. Pederson. 1Interviews with 8ea KU11I1Ier (February 10, 1984), and Gladys Dennis (January 25, 1984), Park City, Utah, and Norma Cowin (March 6, 1984) Salt lake City, Utah. legal Description continued: 7 degrees 13 minutes 8 seconds West 92.91 feet to point on 7351.7 feet radius curve running along Northerly ri ght-of-way 1i ne Deer Valley entrance road, radi us point of radius curve bears South 3 degrees 46 minutes 44 seconds West 7351.7 feet; thence No"rtherly along arc road curve 151.47 feet to point of tangency; thence North 85 degrees 2 mi nutes 26 seconds West 7.14 feet a long road Northerly right-of... way line to beginning. 16.019 square feet. U II C G Ii' 0 H H E N C, 0 DIN G To be Cbrrpleted -for All Sites Sent to the National Pegister , or as a Follow-up to the Blod<:: Survey . UPDATED 10/1 7/84 J ST. cr, CO. P. :=I 4. I ~ 01... S. SITE 6. I W ZONE M. 7. 1/4 1/4 9 . ©,(j), 9 , 1/4 l iE 1».0,LJ,S IS , IA,T 0 Jl..': ,) • I • . .5 J 17 , "])1SIb.J·2 1 IV J\ , L~sY ; J I YEAR DAY SIG. ~I.D. DAY YEAn EV. I ' t=t W 1=:=1 PLAN TP.IH " - - 1- ,- . - ,-""""" r?a I . OWN. \ f~120. ' 119. [cD DATE- ' 1 ! 1 DESTRUCTION HE I GlT ALT. Ii ' CULTURE I i lL 1 I , t \ ; I ; J I BUILDERS 1 ' , , I m MMENTS IL'ITETIING NR 21.tY~ I L---1 ORIGINAL USE TYPE qJlj; ~ --, ;)j trM;;.~~~ . _dl ~ ~ _1-'36 . '0 ' 0 ~~~~ 'TImME I 'I'D Dr"? CONDo RCDF ,/ I U ClC2 13.1[f o 1---"--+---l~·<"-'r ;;·~1 - I =[n I .f<u....B ·D ' I ' , : I 11. 1£] 12. ~ [~ g[ .X I , DlYrE El\BT /WEST t--'-'--+--r 1 I - , • I NORTlIING ,7,. ·5 CJ 8. [Ul ;s,s l '- . 3 ::J 37.~ . " ; =~ -l-J---L- . . I , I 15'f.~8 1 1 :? IMl Fn~ 16. rEI. 17.1<12,41~'ig] 18. ttM-· - " "~ILAST I Ef>.STI NG NORTH/SOLmI 22' 1~ j 23. JRq 24. M 25. Fift1 26.l f(l :r I 27. lffi m i\). TY. , 4 t.'-;'L~~:~ . ,/ ..... "'.r-:: ("') ,;... • I :" , (;/ ,;;;J ~~I :V,..J CXJ:iJ f:.~Tm JCrION 1-,L M). f.) IvtAP REmHE[\KTI STREET NAME PfDPERTY NAivU-C: 14 . RANGE TOWNSHIP IJ) , E: , G- ;~ , ,\/ .tt,b 1- IE ,V , /f-'A IA .D i STREE1' NO . 10. SEC . IPJ-i I I'- i \<:., ,~ 1). fClndaiL Encoders N ~ cure ABCD E FGHIJKL MN OPgRSTUVWXYZ ,==;=1 38 . .-l~"..l- _II .. ! _ , _L-1-_-L-_'_ ! ~, J . i _ i _ _ ._ j , ~ l ~~_I I I ... . _' ...~ j 1 , I ' ---~~ ' _ _ . --L-.l.....--L-_ '--- N3SCCIA'mD INDl VI DUALS I, D..J ?9" r-; I S.OnG. AS soc. 0 RGAN. I.LJ"~':::] 1 2 31 5 G 7 8 D 0 :---l.. __ <--l_.1 1 I L--!..-.J._ • • ..L.:..__ . "j -'_-L.--L-. Utah State Historical Society Property Type: Site No. _____ Historic Preservation Research Office Structure/Site Information Form 1 Street Address: i= 577 Deer Valley Road Park City, Summit County, Utah Name of Structure: House at 577 Deer Valley Road u: Present Owner: E. J. G. Inc. Q Owner Address: #5 Walker Court, Park City, Utah z 0 < (J i= z w Year Built ITax Recordl: Legal Description UTM: 12 458590 4499320 T. S. R. 84060 Effective Age: Kind of Building: Tax #: PC 531 4 room house North side Heber Avenue #204 Deer Valley (House No. 577 8th house side of Deer Valley fornerly house. No. 204 North side Deer Valley). Also, beginning at point on Northerly ri ght-of-way line Deer Valley entrance road and also 544.55 feet and East 376.24 feet from East ~ corner Section 16 T2S R4E; thence North 7 degrees 46 min. utes East 109.43 feet; South 7~ degrees 37 minutes East 157.61 feet; South . . . LSee contlnuatJOn Sheet) 2 Original Owner: Construction Date: c. Original Use: Residence Building Condition: z o ~ z Preliminary Evaluation: !a-Significant c:: Not of the [} Site [J o Good C Ruins v-Minor Alterations CJ Contributory G Major Alterations [) Not Contributory Photography: Unaltered Preseflt Use: l3-txCelient o Deteriorated 3 Integrity: Date 01 Slides: Views: [j Front C Side Research Sources: 1983 =Rear [] Other Demolition Date: 1890 Slide No.: Historic Period Final Register Status: 0 National Landmark c:: District C National Register C Multi-Resource 0 State Register Date 01 Photographs: Views: :::; Front 0 Side 0 Rear 1983 Other lC-Sanborn Maps QL...bIewspapers o U of U Library w W-f'Iat Records/Map ::::I . Q.-:fax Card & Photo o City Directories o Biographical 'Encyclopedias o Utah State Historical Society o Personal Interviews o USU Library oQ o Building Permit t::l-6blturary Index (J o Sewer Permit ~ounty & City Histories o LOS Church Archives o LOS Genealogical Society Photo No.: = IJl...Atlstract 01 Title :IE = Thematic o BYU Library o SLC Library Il""Other Census Records Bibliographical References (books, articles, records, interviews, old photographs and maps, etc.): Cowin, Norma. Telephone interview, March 6, 1984, Salt Lake City, Utah. Dermis, Gladys. Telephone interview, January 25. 1984. Park City. Utah. K1.lIlm2r, Bea. Interview, February 10. 1984, Park City, Utah. 1900 Census Records. Sunmit County, P.uk City Precinct. Researcher: Roger Roper Date: 4/84 Street Address: 4w ex: 577 Deer Valley Road Architectl Builder: Building Materials: . Wood -!:: Building Type/Style: Hall & Par lor House ct Description of physical appearance & significant archit~ct.ural features: ~ I- Site No: (,,) w :z: (,,) ex: ._ (Include additions, alterations, ancillary structures, and landscaping If applicable) This house is a one story frame hall and parlor house with a gable roof. As is typical of Park City hall and parlor houses, it has a rectangul ar fonn oriented broadside to the street, a generally symmetrical facade with a door set slightly off-center between two windows, and a porch centered over the openings on the facade. The house is two rooms deep with an original rear shed extension which makes the house look like a saltbox type. There is a second smaller shed extension that was added after the original construction. It projects beyond the west wall, and a door that possibly provides access to a wood or coal shed was added to the south side of that projection. In-period rear extensions are part of Park City's architectural vocabulary. Although in many cases an extension represents a major alteration of the original house, it ususa11y contributes to the significance of a house because it documents . the most common and acceptable method of expansion of the small Park city house. There are two other entrances, both into the rear shed extensions on the east and west sides. These is a window in each of the gable ends. All of the windows are the one over one double hung sash type. Except for the : ' addition of the rear shed extension, which is an unobtrusive change, the house is essentially unaltered and maintains its original integrity. 5 >ex: o I~ :z: Statement of Historical Significance: Construction Date: Built c. 1890, this house at 577 Deer Valley Road is architecturally significant as one of 76 extant hall and parlor houses in Park City, 22 of which are included in this nomination. The hall and parlor house, the earliest house type to be built in Park City, and one of the three most common house types that were built during the early period of Park City's mining boom era, significantly contributes to the character of the residential area. Built by at least 1907, as indicated by the Sanborn Insurance Maps which first covered this area that year, this house was probably constructed in the 1880s or 1890s, as were the majority of Park City's hall and parlor houses. The exact date of construction and the name of the original owner are unknown. By at least 1910 this property, referred to as the "8th house, north side of Deer Vall ey Road, indicate that it was owned by Rachel and George Urban, who al so owned the 2nd, 3rd, and 5th houses along that road as well as property in other parts of town. It is uncertain whether or not those four numbered houses were part of the group of five houses at 321, 339, 345, 555, and 777 Deer Valley Road, which were referred to in another property transaction involving the Urbans in 1912 (see 555 Deer Valley Road). The 1910 census records, which listed the addresses for many of the households surveyed, do not list the address for this house, so it is difficult to detemine who was living here at that time. II Rachel Urban was the principal madame of Park City's red light district, which was concentrated on Heber Avenue, the lower portion of Deer Valley Road. There is no substantial evidence, however, to support an assumption that this was one of her "business houses." The documented red light district in Park City is not known to have extended this far east out of town, and older (See continuation sheet) c. 1890 577 Deer Valley Road History continued: residents of the area claim that these houses along Deer Valley Road were all occupied only by miners and laborers. 1 The census records appear to support that claim. Like the other property holdings of the Urbans in other parts of town, it is likely that this house,too, was used as investment property. Other owners of the property include Roy Pederson, Ethel M. Kimber and Alma H. Pederson. 1 Interviews with Sea Kummer (February 10, 1984), and Gladys Dennis (January 25, 1984), Park City, Utah, and Norma Cowin (March 6, 1984) Salt Lake City, Utah. Legal Description continued: 7 degrees 13 minutes 8 seconds West 92.91 fe~t to point on 7351.7 feet radius. curve running al ongNortherly ri ght-of-way 11 ne Deer Va lley entrance road, rad1 us point of radius curve bears South 3 degrees 46 minutes ~4 seconds West 7351.7 feet; thence Northerly along arc road curve 151.47 feet to p01nt of tangency; thence North 85 degrees 2 mi nutes 26 seconds West 7.14 feet a long road Northerly right-of.-way line to beginning. 16.019 square feet. This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. 6657 Ranch T by the Geological Survey 1000 Aerial : ' : , SM'LS \: I \i Dashed IJnd lines indicate acprcxim::t€ !'xations J-~'" lOOO.meter Universal Transverse Mercator grid licks, zone 12, shown in blue To place on the predicted North American Datum 1983 move the projection lines 9 meters north and 64 meter~ east as shown by dashed corner ticks 16l.2" oel7..Ji 293MILS- on Uta~ c(':yc:!"'~:e system, .::;=<,.::; :.r-..c :955 Ml.:;\i£TIC "JORTH C-EC: ..... AT , C,~\ :..- C~·,,·Ec OF S ..... E[T Th FOR SALE BY U. S. A FOLDER UTA H, Sum mit County, Park City, Durkin, Joseph, House (Mining Boo m Era Houses T R), 22 Prospect Ave. (07/11/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Farthelos, Peter, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1150 Park Ave. (07112/84) UTA H, Sum mit County, Park City, Frkovich, Mike, House (Mining Boo m Era Houses T R), 162 Daly Ave. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Gray, Levins, D., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 355 Ontario Ave. (07112/84) UTAH,Summit County, Park City, Hansen, Frank, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1025 Park Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, Harris, Joseph D., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 959 Park Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, Harris, William H., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 39 King Rd. (07112/84) . UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Haumann, Harry W., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 939 Emp:ire Ave. (01/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Hinsdill. Henry M., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 662 Norfolk St. (07112/84) UT A H, Sum mit County, Park City, Holman, Samuel, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 307 Norfolk St. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, House at 1101 Norfolk Avenue (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1101 Norfolk Ave. (01/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, House at 343 Park Avenue (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 343 Park Ave. (07/12/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, House at 555 Deer Valley Road (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 555 Deer Valley Rd. (07/12/84) UT A H, Sum mit County, Park City, House at 577 Deer Valley Road (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 577 Deer Valley Rd. (07112/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, House at 62 Daly Avenue (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 62 Daly Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, .House at 622 Rossie Hill Drive (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 622 Rossie Hill Dr. (01/12/84) UTA H, Sum mit County, Park City, IO OF Relief Home (Mining Boo m Era Houses T R), 232 Woodside Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Jenkins, Joseph J., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 57 Prospect Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Johnson, Carl G., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 147 Grant Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Jones, Elizabeth M., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 412 Marsac Ave. (01/12/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, Kimball, Burt, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 817 Park Ave~ (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Kimball, Ernest Lynn, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 911 Em p:ire Ave. (07/12/84) . UTAH, Summit County, Park City, LindorIT, A1tred, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 40 Sampson Ave. (07112/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Meadowcroft, Charles, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 951 Woodside Ave. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Morgan, Jesse, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 1027 Woodside Ave. (01/12/84) UTAH, Sum mit County, Park City, Murdock, Jack M., House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 652 Rossie Hill Dr. (07/12/84) UTAH, Summit County, Park City, Murray, George, House (Mining Boom Era Houses TR), 44 Chambers Ave. (07/12/84) scon M MATHESON GOVERNOR Division of State History February 9, 1984 (UTAH STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T. SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIOGAANDE SALT LAKE CITY. UTAH 84101 TELEPHONE [phone] LJ. G. Inc. H5 Walker Court Park City, UT 84060 Dear Sir or Madam: We are pleased to report that your property at 577 Deer Valley Road, has been approved by the State Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee at its February 1, 1984 meeting for nomination to the National Register of Historic Pl aces. We have received comment from you regarding the eligibility of your proper~y and will thE~efore submit the nomination to Washington as soon as possible. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the Preservation Office, Utah State Historical Society, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake r.ity, Utah 84101, 533-6017. Sincerely, A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer AKP:br S~a : e ,- >s~ c ...; 8-.:·a'c De ;,c G C'ay:on Milton C A::l'a-ns C~a :r man • Theron H . LuKe • • Wa y~:= '< H ,ntoh • Helen Z. PaparllKolas • Ted J . Warner • Elizabeth Montague • ThomasG. Alexander DavidS . Monson • Elizabeth G riff ith • William D. ONens This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. ? I ...j' II II II __~!IBaL~----=-­ - - - -- ... - G _ ~fIiJ_~~ta!Zk.,-.s'f. z-tta-lO, lJ.rh. ~(ft, ~(.(i4f#, otffii/l ___ _ nz-V----4T--l i _ 1lilfiIt--.----_(._-U--_-WVliL_(J~_ .~. -6.j-b~J{,3_oJya, ___ ___. _.__ _. ---'L" -------- -'-'---:---4---~ ~1M. ~ _ ----+~~ <f~ . ~ ___ . $ ~~elL-~~l~~ ------~--~-----------------~------t- -------- -- - - -- - - - - - - - -- - - -- _. - - - ...,,-c.-------It-- - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - -- - - - - . -- - II .., - .. . I , , II !i . ii t !; li It I II '. -----~---------- --- -:-:--- ii ------+-- - -- - -- - - -- - -I ! . - - - -- - - - - !i -- --- ._- - ... - ---- - ---_.- - ---- - - --_.- -- - --_. - ---- -- ----~----------------------- - , . " . 11 . __ .- __ _--- - _. .. - - - - - - - - -_._--- - ---_ .. _ ._------- - This text message is used to keep the image from rotating in ocr process. Be sure to crop the top .25" off after the ocr process. ?-77 ~ 1/tt&1/A frod J GPA1J..1J (jAlt1J1l!\ - MIl old Uf'r7dJ~ (' {i;tit!J1111 6 J" or , I -R~I fJAimM IJAI -M() ~M 111 flpt. Y I f(1/~ /) I 5// -? r scon P.A . MATHESON GOVERNOR Division of State History December 8, 1983 (UTAH STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T. SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANOE SAlT lAKE CITY. UTAH 84101-1182 TELEPHONE 801fS33.S755 E.J .G. Inc. 15 Walker Court Park City, UT 84060 Dear Sir or Madam: This letter is to inform you of the status of the nomination of your property at 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City, Utah to the National Register of Historic Places. Your property, as part of the Residences of Mining Boan Era Park City Thematic Nomination, was scheduled to be presented to the State Review Committee on December 7, 1983, but due to inclement weather the meeting was postponed. It has been rescheduled for February 1, 1984 at 2:00 p.m. Weather permitting, that meeting will be held in the city offices at the Marsac School in Park City. If weather conditions make it impossible for the Review Committee to travel to Park City, the meeting will be held at the Utah State Historical Society, Denver &Rio Grande Depot, Salt Lake City. Your attendance is welcome, hut not required. As mentioned in a previous lette~ to you, owners of private properties nominated to the National Register must be given an opportunity to object to the listing of their properties in the National Register. If you object to this nomination, you must submit a notarized statement to that effect, one that certifies that you are the sole owner of the property. The objection letter must be sent by February 1, 1984 to Dr. Melvin T. Smith, Director and State Historic Preservation Officer, Utah State Historical Society, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake City, UT 84101. Sincerely, A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preserv~tion Officer AKP: Ijw State History Board: Milton C. Abrams. Chairman • Theron H. Luke J. EldOn Dorman • Wayne K. Hinton • He'en Z. Papani ~o ias • • Anand A. Yang • Elizabeth Montague • Thomas G. Alexander Da'/i5 S. Monson • Elizabeth Griffith • Williarn D. Owens .: ~. August 7, 1984 -. ... '.' ... --;:s: '. : . ~~ ..:.: ~ Division of State History E. J. G. Inc. #5 Walker Court Park City, lIT 84060 (UTAH ST .. ":: - ·S-O:l:C;:'_ 5OCfETV., 5-;' -:: ::J" Ur.. ~ :~o:'=T'A~:","":'.; COM~';J·JITY AND =(,C·.S~."C D:',!=LOPVf: . ; I,~ElV: /14 T SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RfOGRANOE SALT LAKE CITY. UTAH 84101-1182 TELEPHONE [phone] Dear Sirs: It is my distinct pleasure to inform you that on July 12, 1984, your property at 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City, nominated by the Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee and the Utah State Historic Preservation Officer as part of the Park City Thematic Resources Nomination, was officially listed in the National Register of Historic Places by the National Park Service and ~~. Carol Shull, Acting Keeper of the National Register. The National Register of Historic Places is the official list of historic properties recognized by the Federal Government as worthy of preservation for their signi~icance in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering and culture. Located in the National Park Service, Department of the Interior, the program is part of a national policy to coordinate and support public and private efforts to identify, evaluate) and protect our cultural and natural res6urces, and is maintained by the Secretary of the Interior under . provisions of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966. Listing in the National Register provides the following benefits to historic properties: -Col~ideration in the planning for federally assisted projects. Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 provides that the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation be given an opporttmity to connnent on projects affecting such properties. \ -Eligibility for Federal tax benefits for rehabilitations of certain historic commercial, industrial and residential rental buildings. -Consideration of historic values in the decision to issue a surface coal mining permit where coal is located, in accord w"i th the SurfaceI'-lining and Control Act of 1977. -Qualification for Federal grants f or historic preservation when funds are available. S!a:e H ~- .:" / a'J3'd . Vlai~" ~ ,.. ~·:on Milton C An"ams C~a " md" • Dean l '.1av • • Tnomas G. Alexander • Phillip A. Bulle" • J Eloen Dormar. • E1izabelllGntfilh • William 0 Owens • Helen Z. Papanli<OOS • Anand A. Yang Da'" c S Monson . E. J. G. Inc. August 3, 1984 Page 2 Listing does not mean that the Federal Government wants to acquire the property, place restrictive covenants on the land, or dictate the color or materials used on individual buildings . State a,ld loca.l ordinances or laws establishing restrictive zoning, special d<:s i gn revimv corrrrnittees ,orreview of exterior alterations, are not a part of the National Register program and should be clearly separated from the fu.'1ction of the National Register ,as a tool i n the Federal planning process. SincerelYJ A. Kent Powell Deputy State Histor ic Pres ervation. Offic~r AKP: jjlV scon M. MATHESON GOVERNOR Division of State History February 9, 1984 (UTAH STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T. SMITH. DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANDE SALT LAKE CITY. UTAH 84101 TELEPHONE [phone] Ennis Gibbs 5 Walker Court Park City, UT 84060 Dear Mr. Gibbs: are pleased to report that your property at 555 Deer Valley Road, has been approved by the State Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee at its February 1, 1984 meeting for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. ~/e We have received comment from you regarding the eligibility of your property and will therefore submit the nomination to Washington as soon as possihle. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the Preservation Office, Utah State Historical Society, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake City, Utah 84101, 533-6017. Sincerely, A,ft,atU A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer AKP:br ut, (/ rt7 r .7 .riJo -- --Vi / \ ( f Id(l<ri 7 cJ."- 11. //) '- ' -/ c,' V'f State History Board : Delio G. Dayton Mlto~ C. Abrams. Chairman • Wayne K. Hinton (~/lvh ~ • )fe/1v/-v/ - .r j d i,../'- I 0 I /"1') v / . ~ v-J I /\ C ~ J ),-(,/ tJ. -::::;::::;-- • Theron H. Luke • Ted J. Warner • Elizabeth Montague • Thomas G. Alexandtr? •. Helen Z. Papanikolas • David S. Monson • Elizabeth Griffith • William D. Owens ~ J ,11 /J4' A 3/J4}gy ~ Ms Qci.viLQ -t t-W hUlJ uX.u taL Lsfa1 J ~t (QjJ~ -w~ ~ ~ OOf'{l;Y'(V.Avb ca1~ ~, Cfjr{) rruu-Jv (JiMioc1 ~.) J.).s I1J);b f'LD1OA~d~ 6bUl. 'J)T scon M. MATHESON GOVERNOR Division of State History February 9, 1984 (UTAH STATE HISTORICAL SOCIETY) STATE OF UTAH DEPARTMENT OF COMM UNITY AND ECONOM IC DEVELOPMENT MELVIN T. SMITH , DIRECTOR 300 RIO GRANDE SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH 84101 TELEPHONE [phone] LJ. G. Inc. #5 Walker Court Park City, UT 84060 Dear Sir or Madam: We are pleased to report that your property at 577 Deer Valley Road, has been approved by the State Historic and Cultural Sites Review Committee at its February 1, 1984 meeting for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places. We have recei ved comment from you regarding the el i gibil i ty of your property and will therefore submit the nomination to Washington as soon as possiD1e. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the Preservation Office, Utah State Historical Society, 300 Rio Grande, Salt Lake City, Utah 84101, 533-6017. Sincerely, A· NjJ~dI A. Kent Powell Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer AKP:br State History Board : Milton C. Abram s, Chairman • Theron H. Luke • Delio G. Dayton • Wayne K. Hinton • Helen Z. Papanikolas • Ted J . Warner • Elizabeth Montague • Thomas G. Alexander David S. Monson • Elizabeth Griffith • William D. Owens 577 E. Deer Valley Drive. Overview of residence; view to the east-northeast 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City Roll: 6 Frame: 2 Approx. Date: 1940s National Register Listed Park City Tax Photo Tax No.: PC 531 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City Photo by Debbie Temme, October 1983 Negative: Utah State Historical Society View from Southeast corner 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City EKTACHROME 577 Deer Valley Road, Park City Kodachrome SLIDE ( ) t.." ' Kodak 9 Archival Gold® The 300 'lear Disc 52x / 700 MB / 80 MIN Contents: 61 =z 6 DC: ere VA '- L£.Y b£ . Disc No: Date: Title: :0 -= -': DELKlrt ¥ 1.; ~ DEVICES www.delkin.com