62439

4159 S. 700 West Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah Carlisle, Sarah A., House II~ InI~IIIIillli~1 '1~11~11I1 1 1 1 3 9222 00536 0396 lllSTORIC SITE FORM ( 10-91) UTAH OFFICE OF PRESERVATION I IDENTIFICATION Name of Property: Carlisle, Sarah A., House Address: 4159 S. 700 West Twnshp: 2 5 City, County: Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 84123 UTM: Current Owner Name: Celestino and Maria Salazar Current Owner Address: 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Utah 84123 Range: 1 W Section: 12 423026 2 4503761 USGS Map Name & Date: Salt Lake City South, Utah Quad, 1998 Tax Number- 21-02-228-008 Legal Description (include acreage): BEG S 364.48 FT FR NE COR SEC 2, T 2S, R 1W, SLM; S 77.03 FT; W 217 FT M OR L, N 5"50' W 77 FT M OR L, E 225 FT TO BEG. 0.38 AC M OR L. 2 STATUSIUSE Property Cate~ory -Xbuilding(s) _structure _site _object Evaluation -Xeligibleicontributing _ineligible/non-contributing _out-of-period Use Original Use: Single Dwelling Current Use: Single Dwelling 3 DOCUMENTATION Photos: Dates _slides: brints: 2016 -Xhistoric: circa 1900, circa 1938 Drawin~s and Plans -Xmeasured floor plans tax card 1938 -Xsite sketch map aerial photograph _Historic American Bldg. Survey _original plans available at: _other- Research Sources (check all sources consulted, whether useful or not) -Xcity!county histories -Xabstract oftitle ~ersonal interviews -Xtax card & photo _building permit -XUSHS Library _sewer permit -XUSHS Preservation Files _Sanborn Maps _USHS Architects File -XLDS Family History Library -Xobituary index -Xcity directories/gazetteers -Xlocallibrary: Murray City Library _university library(ies): -Xcensus records -Xbiographical encyclopedias -Xnewspapers Bibliographical References (books, articles, interviews, etc.) Attach copies ofall research notes, title searches, obituaries, and so forth. [4159 S. 700 West.] File available at the Murray Museum. Broschinsky, Korral. "Historic Resources of Murray City, Utah, 1850-1950." National Register of Historic Places, Multiple Property Documentation Form, 2012. Available at the Utah State Historic Preservation Office. Johnson, Wesley G. and David Schirer Between the Cottonwoods: Murray City In Transition. Salt Lake City: Timpanogos Research Associates, 1992. Daughters of Utah Pioneers, History Department. "Joseph Carlisle." TMs, 2002. Evans, Vemal Ray. "Zina Taylor Carlisle Evans: An Amazing Interview." TMs, 1975. Murray City Corporation. The History of Murray City, Utah. Murray Bicentennial Book Commission. Salt Lake City, Utah: StanwayJVVheelwright Printing Company, 1976. Murray Eagle, various issues. Nielsen, Maurine Carlisle. "History of Joseph Carlisle." TMs, 1972. Polk Directories, Salt Lake City, 1910-1979. Published by R.L. Polk & Co. Available at the Utah State Historical Society. (Salt Lake County Tax Assessors Cards and Photographs). Available at the Salt Lake County Archives. (Salt Lake County Title Abstracts). Available at the Salt Lake County Recorder's Office. Salt Lake Tribune. Various issues. United States Federal Census, Murray Precinct, Salt Lake County, Utah, 1880, 1900, 1910, 1920, 1930 and 1940. Researcher/Organization: Preservation Documentation Resource/prepared for Murray City Date: 2016 4 ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION Building Styleffype: 4159 5 . 700 West, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah ~ge 2 No. Stories::.....---....;..;..;:.....-1% Victorian / Other Foundation Material: Stone Wall Material(s) : Brick, Stucco -------------------------------~--------------------Additions: ___none _major (describe below) Alterations: _none _major (describe below) ~minor ~minor Number ofassociated outbuildings ___ and/or structures _ _. Briefly describe the principal building, additions or alterations and their dates, and associated outbuildings and structures. Use continuation sheets as necessary. The Sarah A. Carlisle House, built in phases between 1882 and 1895, is a 1%-story Victorian brick cottage at 1 4159 S. 700 West in Murray. The house has three distinct sections: the 1%-story main section to the north, the brick parlor wing at the southwest corner, and a frame lean-to addition at the southeast corner The house has the architectural characteristics of the Victorian-era, such as arched window heads, but most of the architectural details have been removed or obscured by a circa 1975 remodeling. The house is built on a stone foundation, which is covered with stucco, as are the brick walls. The roof is covered in asphalt shingles (circa 1975). The house sits in the center of a rectangular parcel of 0.38 acres in the northwest corner of Murray. The Carlisle House is at the dead end of 700 West. There are numerous residences along 700 West, but the surrounding neighborhood is commercial and light industrial. Although the property has some integrity issues, such as the stucco and replacement windows, the Carlisle House is the oldest building in this part of Murray City and as a representative of the former agricultural land use has overwhelming historic value. The Sarah A. Carlisle House is a contributing historic resource in Murray City. The oldest section is the 1%-story main wing, which has a rectangular footprint of 16 by 27 feet with the narrow end facing 700 West. This wing has a truncated hipped roof. There is a wide plain corniced under the eaves. The fa~de (west elevation) features one narrow window and one door on the main level. There are no openings on the upper level of the fa~de . All the one-over-one double-hung windows are circa 1975 aluminum replacements, although the wood casings are intact. The door is a circa 1990 vinyl replacement. The north elevation has three double-hung windows on the main floor and two shorter windows on the upper floor The east (rear) elevation has one opening on each floor The south elevation is completed obscured by the lean-to addition. The one-story parlor wing is attached to the southwest corner of the main house. The footprint is square, measuring 16.5 feet on each side. The roof is pyramidal. There is a door and one window on the north elevation, one window on the south, and the west elevation is obscured by an enclosed porch. A circa 1900 photograph shows a door on the west elevation, which was blocked with bricked in a circa 1938 photographs from the same angle. The circa 1900 photograph also show a glimpse of the lean-to addition covered in square shingles. The tax records show the porch on the south elevation. Both photographs indicated the fa~de porch had lathe-turned Victorian-style posts and spindle decoration. Around 1975, the house was remodeled . The modifications include the stucco, aluminum replacement doublehung windows, enclosure of the south porch, the lathe-turn posts replaced by square posts, and the removal of three brick chimneys when the roof was re-shingled . Despite the number of changes, the house still feels Victorian and details such as the wood porch deck and steps are intact. The interior was not available for inspection . Family records state that there was no door from the main house into the parlor According to tax records, there is 1,402 square feet of space on the main floor and 432 square feet of finished attic space. There are three bedrooms and one bathroom. The attic was damaged by fire around 1970, which may have prompted the complete remodel. There is no basement. The Carlisle House is in the center of a 0.38-acre parcel, just a fraction of the original farm . There are mature trees along 700 West. The house is setback with a large lawn in the front yard. There is a gravel driveway along the south property line and a concrete parking pad near the house. A wood fence is along the south property line with a chain link fencing on the north and east property lines. A portion of a corrugated metal outbuilding juts over the north property from the adjacent property, but the majority of the outbuilding is on the other parcel and is not included as an associated building. The house is at the south end of 700 West, which has access from 3900 South. The former farm lane has a number of historic and non-historic residences ranging from the 1950s to the 1980s. Only those below 4100 South are within Murray City limits. 1 The Salt Lake County tax assessor's records give an estimated construction date of 1897 but family records suggest that an least one section of the house was built in 1882. The street currently known as 700 West was originally a dirt lane for the Carlisle enclave. The street became Sixth (or S1h West) in 1917 when the Salt Lake Valley was resurveyed and the Salt Lake City street names were extended. During the survey, 1S1h Street became 3900 South. In 1972, the west side streets were renumbered and Sixth West became 700 West. The area was annexed into Murray City in 1981 . 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah S HISTORY Architect/Builder Date ofConstruction: Unknown / Unknown Historic Themes: Mark themes related to this property with (see instructions for details) C Agriculture _Economics _Education _Architecture _Archeology _Engineering _Art _Entertainment/ _Commerce Recreation _Ethnic Heritage _Communications _Community Planning k.Exploration/ & Development Settlement _Conservation _Health/Medicine "s" or "C" (S = significant, _Industry _Invention _Landscape Architecture _Law _Literature _Maritime History _Military _ Performing Arts 1882-1897 C = contributing). Government _Religion _Science _Social History _Transportation _Other Write a chronological history ofthe property, focusing primarily on the original or principal owners & significant events. Explain and justify any significant themes marked above. Use continuation sheets as necessary. The Sarah A. Carlisle House, constructed between 1882 and 1897 contributes to the history of Murray in the areas of Exploration/Settlement and Agriculture. In the area of Exploration/Settlement, the house is one of two historic homes remaining from an enclave of the Carlisle family, who homesteaded the area around 4100 South and the Jordan River The Carlisle enclave was associated with the west Mill Creek community in the nineteenth century when the family first settled the area. Today the former homesteads are divided between Murray City to the south, Millcreek Township to the north, and Taylorsville City west of the Jordan River The Sarah A. Carlisle House is located within the boundaries of Murray City. The property also contributes to the history of Murray in the area of Agriculture. The Carlisle House was associated with a working farm into the twentieth century when the boundaries of Murray were extended north and west. The property represents the area before it became a commercial and light industrial corridor between the railroad tracks and the Jordan River The Carlisle family made a number of important contributions to both the Murray and Millcreek communities and the house is a contributing resource. Although the design of the house is unusual, it has had too many non-historic modifications to be architecturally significance in its current condition. History and Contributions of the Sarah A. Carlisle Family Sarah A. Carlisle was the second wife of Joseph Carlisle. Joseph Carlisle was born in Nottingham, England in 1826. On May 18, May, 1853, Joseph married his first wife, Isabelle Sharp, in St. Louis, Missouri. They met while both of their families were traveling to Utah. Joseph was traveling with his two brothers, John and Richard. Their wagon train arrived in Salt Lake City in September 1853. The Carlisle brothers immediately set off to find arable land. They settled in an area between today's 4100 and 4400 South, and between 200 West and the west side of the Jordan River (probably to the Brighton ditch). Their first home was a one-room cabin with a willow roof. Joseph later built an adobe house at the top of the hil1.2 In 1874, all three brothers obtained homestead patents for their farmsteads. In April 1880, Joseph Carlisle acquired a patent for the land where Sarah A. Carlisle's home would be built (circa 1882). Joseph and Isabelle had thirteen children, seven of whom lived to maturity. Several married and also built homes on Carlisle Lane. The land near the Jordan River was easily irrigated, but was also near a trail and campsite for the nomadic Indians. Joseph Carlisle learned some of their language and was a mediator between the settlers and Indians in the area. Isabelle frequently fed the Indians who stopped by her place. Joseph Carlisle was one of the first settlers to raise alfalfa in the Salt Lake Valley. His crops were saved one year in the 1870s when swarms of grasshoppers moved from the east, but were drowned in the river before they could reach his crops. Joseph and his brothers also raised hay, had a dairy farm, and planted mulberry trees to raise silk worms. There were so many Carlisle children in the area that the district school built at the corner of 3900 South and West Temple was 3 named the Carlisle School. Isabelle's house was similar to the extant house at 4060 S. 700 West (built circa 1877), which was Joseph's brother John's house. Isabelle's house was demolished sometime before 1972. 3 There were two schools ofthe same name: a small building (circa 1870) and a four-room brick building that served the community from 1905 to 1923 (demolished). 2 S HISTORY 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah age 4 -continuedIn 1880, Joseph Carlisle was called to serve a mission for the LDS Church in England. Isabelle who had been saving her egg and butter money asked him to bring back a set of china, a gold watch, and a black silk dress. Instead, Joseph chose to use the money to pay the passage of a young English convert Sarah Ann Lord, thirtyfour years his junior Joseph and Sarah Ann were married in Salt Lake City on August 10, 1882. The betrayal hurt Isabelle and the relationship between the two wives was never cordial. Joseph built the brick house for Sarah Ann down the hill from Isabelle's house, likely the same year that they were married. After a stint in the state penitentiary for polygamy in 1890, Joseph chose to live with his younger wife, Sarah Ann, in the river bottoms. Isabelle Sharp Carlisle died on March 29, 1904. Sarah Ann Lord Carlisle was born on April 12, 1860 in Breighmet, Lancashire, England. Her father was an alcoholic and Sarah Ann was forced to work in a woolen mill at the ago of -eight. A few years after Sarah Ann immigrated to Utah, her mother and three siblings also immigrated to Utah. In 1897, Joseph Carlisle deeded the house and 10 acres of farm land to Sarah Ann, who was listed as Sarah A. Carlisle on all the land records. Joseph and Sarah Ann had five children born between 1883 and 1893: Mary Elizabeth, Joseph Brown, Adelaide Lord, Enoch Truman, and Zina Taylor All are listed with Joseph and Sarah Ann on the 1900 census. On the 1910 census, Joseph B. is married to his wife of a year, Mary Tululah Turbin. Enoch and Zina were still at home. All three men are working the farm . Joseph Carlisle died on March 17, 1912, and was buried the Millcreek Cemetery, now Elysian Burial Gardens. The 1920 census lists Sarah Brown with just one son at home, Joseph B. Joseph and Mary divorced after their daughter Frances was born. On June 23, 1920, Joseph B. Carlisle married Annie Kirsten Andersen. This marriage also ended in divorce. The 1930 census enumeration lists Sarah Ann and her son Joseph B. as farmers living at 4159 S. 700 West. The 1940 census also lists a second household, Fred and Annie Kimball, and their infant son, living in the rear Sarah Ann Lord Carlisle died on the Fourth of July in 1941 Her obituary described her as a dedicated church worker her whole life. She was buried in the Elysian Burial Gardens. During the first half of the twentieth century, the Carlisle land was sometimes described as in Murray. Obituaries and social events for the Carlisles and their neighbors were reported in the Murray Eagle newspaper The farm was divided after Sarah A. Carlisle's death, but Joseph B. retained this house property and a number of outbuildings, including a hay barn, stable, chicken coop, and granary. Joseph B. Carlise married for a third time on June 20, 1941, just two weeks before his mother's death. Joseph's third wife, Edna Lavera Palmer Wardle was a widow with two sons, Wayne and Harold, and a daughter, Nola. Edna Carlisle died on January 1, 1951 After a lifetime of farming the land where he was born, Joseph Brown Carlisle died on June 4, 1958. The property was deeded to Joseph's three step-children . Nola G. Wardle and her husband, Maxwell J. Kirk, may have built the house next door at 4135 S. 700 West, but directories also list them living at 4159 S. 700 West after her stepfather's death. Her brother, Harold J. Wardle, lived in the old brick home until he moved to Provo, Utah, around 1975. Both houses were eventually deeded to Leo G. and Madelyn Knowles in 1975, who lived at 4135 S. 700 West. Leo Knowles died in 2013 and Madelyn Knowles sold the property at 4159 S. to the current owners, Celestino and Maria Salazar 6 PHOTOS 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah Common Label Information: I 2. 3. 4. 5. Name: Address: 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah, 84107 Photographer: Korral Broschinsky Date: March 31 , 2016 Digital color photographs on file at Utah SHPO. page 5 6 PHOTOGRAPHS 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah Photograph 1 West and north elevations of house. Camera facing southeast. Photograph 2 Southwest corner of house. Camera facing northwest. page 5 6 PHOTOGRAPHS 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah Photograph 3 South elevation of house . Camera facing northeast. Photograph 4 West elevations of house with view of front yard . Camera facing east. page 6 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 7 SITE PLANS o 50 I 100 150 Feet Legend -+ Latitude : 40 .681148° Carlisle, Sarah A., House 4159 S. 700 West Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 200 I I s Longitude: -111 .91088 .-_ ~ Carlisle House current parcel .-_ ~ Murray municipal boundary page 7 Intensive Level Survey MAP1 NE 1/4 SEC 2, T2S , R1W 4159 S. 700 West, Murray, Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 7 SITE PLANS Title : o 25 I 50 75 I Feet 100 I -+ Latitude: 40.681148° Carlisle, Sarah A., House 4159 S. 700 West Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah s Legend Longitude: -111.91088 .-_ ~ Carlisle House current parcel page 8 Intensive Level Survey MAP 2 NE 1/4 SEC 2, T2S , R1W 8 HISTORIC PHOTOGRAPHS 4159 S. 700 West, Murray .. Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 4159 S. 700 West circa 1900 photograph of Joseph and Sarah A. Carlisle in front of house Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah ~/- 4159 S. 700 West Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah page 9 courtesy Carlisle family 0 circa 1938 photograph of north and west elevations courtesy Salt Lake County Archives DUPPREVlEW PAGE HistorY ~ Joseph carHISJORY • HtSTORY I do not remember much about my paternal grandfather, Joseph Carlisle; he died two months before I was ten;-years old. He was nsarly 86. Though he lived nsarby, I did not see him often; he was elderly and ill. My father did not tell us much of his parents, though.,he loved and respeoted them greatly. He often said that his father .. ~. a very intelligentr,man; I only know that my grandfathef's sons and daughterSwere very intelligent and interesting people - my own father and the aun~and uncles. Joseph Carlisle was born in Sherwood-on-the-hill, Nottinghamshire, England, July 21, 1826. His anoestors go baok many gensrations in this area, and nearby Linc61nshire. It is the land of Robin Hood; of the big city of Lincoln with its great oathedral and medieval wall, still in"t!ct; it is an area famous for Nottingham lace and Sheffield steel. My husband and I found ita most tascinating part of Engltnd when we vis! ted there in 1960. But the lovely Sherwood I'orest of Robin Hood days is gons, destroyed by the undermining of the coal industry. However, other beautiful forests remain, as well as lovely towns and villlges, charming old ohurches and pioturesque oastles. Much of this must have been familiar to my grandfather beoause he was twenty..tour years old when the family lett England in 1851. His father was Richard Carlisle, born April 30, 1798, Riseholm, St Mary's Parish, Lincolnshire, two and ons halt miles north by east from the city of Lincoln; his mother was Jenny Field, christensd November 20, 1795, at Willingham, Lincolnshire. Tbey were married June ;~ 22, 1822, in St. Helen's Church. They became the parents at 12. ohildren, Two of these were twin boys; and thell' was a set of triplets, two" boys and a girl; all five of these, and another little girl, Martha, died very young. However, triplets being UIIUSUal, they received many beautiful presents; the Queen of England sent them qui te an amount of monsy. I have learned sinoe that this grant, given in the royal name to the mother of triplets),l!s called King's Bounty. My grandfather Joseph w,,"s the third child, and seoond son; Thomls and Mary were older. The three youngest were John, Alioe, and Riohard. It was the six in the middle who died as children. The other six grew to maturity and married. This good family heard the gospel Taylor in 1849. They readily aocepted the father Richard, and his oldest son on August 11; my grandfather Joseph on a little later. preaohed by a Joseph Edward the tnlth and were baptized. Thomas on July 30; the mother September 16; the other tour A branch of the ohurch was organized, and my great-grandfather Richard was appointed presiding elder. He and his wife kept an open toouse for the elders who came that WaY. Before hearing the gospel)my grandfather Joseph had become, or was soon to beoome, the father of an illegitimate child. He tried very hard to marry the young woman and make things right, rut because he &nd his family were now Mormona she would have no part of it, and lett the vicinity, taking the ohild with her, a little girlJI believe. Later Joseph was to marry a very fins, ~lou./and forgiving woman - my grandmother Carlisle. When he told'Aaoout this earlier, unhappy experience) I do not know, rut somewhere nsar 1880, atter they had been in Utah for many years, Irandfather was called to go on a mission back to England. My grandmother urged him to try to find his daughter !Ild, i f possible, bring her back to Utah with him, where grandmother would accept her as if she were her own child. Pleased with his wife's attitude, Grandfather tried hard to looate this young woman, rut without success. The Richard Carlisle family, except for the oldest son, 'Ihomas , Field, sailed from Liverpool January 6, 1851 on the good ship Ellen, wi th J. W. CWllllings as leader, and 466 souls aboard. Thomas came later. The trip was long and eventful, rut the details are found in my great grandfather Richard's history, so I will not repeat them here. After about eight weeks the ship anchored in the Mississippi River off New Or1eans. They rode the steamer Alexander Scott to St. Louis, paying $2.50 apiece for adul ts-! and hUf fare for children; all luggage inoluded. They left New Orleans March 19, 1951, and landed in St. Louis Maroh 26. OAUC. , . '-', 1, throu c~ 1he :~. ',-,'icnal 30ciety - :j 'AH PIONEERS may no: be ' <i ' ·!," '~d for monetary gain. 2 It WaS a good trip. handled cutlery. But in St. Louis tragedy struck. My grandfather's mother, Jenny (Jane) died of cholera, after helping friends who were ill. Now her husband Richard must go on alone without the mother of his family. They had made such plans for when they would arrive in Salt Lake with the rest of the Saints. This home was located in the Mill Creek Ward, Salt Lake County the oldest country w?lXd in the valley, and .covering terri tory which is nnW'.Jllany stakes. original Ward house on 39th South, just above 5th East still stands, enlarged and modernized of coupse. My grandfather's farm, or the home :~ itself) was nearly two miles west of the church at the end of a lane, south or TW-rty-ninth South (once Fifteenth), and west of Seventh West (once called Sixth). The family had a long way to go to church over dusty roads in the summer, and deeply rutted muddy ones in the winter. They stayed in St. Louis a year and worked. Then leaving Mary, who had married there, they came on to Utah with the Henry Bryant..Manning-Jolly Seventh Company, arriving in Salt Lake City September 15. 1852. Richard was then 53 years old, my grandfather Joseph,26; John 18; Alice }15; and RichFd Jr • . 11. Mary, age 2!J. came to Utah soon )after. I do not know just when Thomas came. The family settled in Mill Cpeek, Salt Lake County, on the banks of the Jordon River; it was called Cottonwood then. The father remarried, and later moved to Alpine, Utah County, where he was a loved and respected citizen and faithful church member. His oldest son Thomas, and I think both daughters, Mary /¥ld Alice ) lived in Alpine. My grandfather Joseph, and his brothers ) John and Richard Jr. stayed in ~.i ll Creek. All brothers and sisters were married and' endowed in the Salt Lake Temple. The father Richard was married there for time to his second wife. They had the work done for their earlier spouses and were sealed to them. All of Richard's children were sealed to him and Jenny (Jane). He had no children by his second wife. When my grandfather Joseph arrived in Utah with the family he was already married. He must have met Isabella Sharp when they were in St. Louis, and they were probably married there in May 1852. She had been born December 22, 1831 , at Misson, Notltiinghamshire, England. She ~as nearly 21 years old; her husband~26. Their first home was a one-room cabin thatched with river willows. Their first son Joseph Richard was born December 19, 1854. Often after leaving her baby asleep on the bed Isabella would return to find a snake hanging from the willow ceiling above her baby's face - only a harmless water snake from the river bottoms below, or the irrigation ditch nearby, but not a welcome viSitor) I am sure; it alsQ;.:bothered my grandmother, always spoken of as a truly dignified English lady, to have to eat from tin plates, and use common black~ They were indeed very poor, at first. The The Joseph Carlisle home and some of the farm was located on sandy banks above the bottom lands where the Jordon River tlows northwest to the Gpeat Salt Lake. Joseph's land covered a sizeable acreage in all directions from that point. He was one of the very few first settlers in that area. rut the farm prospered. a l.arger adobe house was built; and more children came. Thirteen children were born to Joseph /!,nd my grandmother: Joseph Richard, 1854, who died at 81, had five children; Isabella Jana, 1857, died at 71, 10 children; Thomas Mathew, her twin, died when he was 12; James Sharp, 1859, died at 79 ', 3 daughters; Ezra Taylor, 1861, died as an infant; Elizabeth Ann, 1862, not quite 19, and a beautiful girl, engaged to be married', died suddenly of diphtheria afid was later sealed to her fiancee; William Frederick, my father) w&& born November 14, 1864, was Rot much past 57 years when he died, January 5, 1922, 5 children; Harvey Cartwright, two years younger than my father, and his closest friend, died 13 years after my father, age nearly 69, 6 children, 2 adopted; Herbert Towle, 1868 , died at two months; Orman was stillborn, 1871; Carrie Brown died in 1872 (we have no birthda~i but she would have been less than a year old at most.); Ether Franklin, 1873, died at 32 leaving three small children; 2 other children born to his wife by a later marriage, are sealed to him; Rosamond Pearl, born 1875, died in 1921; she was not quite 46 and left five children. She and my father were very close though separated by eleven years in age. During the se years of the birthSof these children the farming went on; the home was now the original one-story adobe ... at the baok .~c.Qn­ sisting of several rooms, with a new two-story part added in front; the parlor downstairs of course, tnd a long cold hall, and bedrooms upstairs. 3 I remember only a few sharp details of this house - a fan-light of colored glass in the front door that let in lovely lights; a large picture of the prophet Joseph riding his horse in the Nauvoo Legion this in the parlor; in the dining room a really large picture of a dark forest and a little girl in a red cape, and deer in the trees, (I am sure it was not meant to be Red Riding Hood); also, in the dining room a very charming old-fashioned baby's high chair. But my Uncle Harve and his wife lived there when I saw these things; when he moved to Holiday, a hired man who had worked for my uncle a long time, marriedJand lived in the house; he is dead no~ and the home has been torn down. A home, somewhat similar, be longing to my grandfather's brother John, still stands nearby. But this is 1972; our story returns to the 1800's. Besides being a good farmer, and I know my grandfather was, because his sons were well trained; he, with his sons, owned a stable of fine horses. Some of these were race horses - entered at the State Fair Grounds track, and at old Wandermere resort (now Nibley Park). And the family was active in church. My grandmother is remembered for the beautiful flowers she took to decorate the meeting house, especially on Sunday. Then somewhere near 1880, my grandfather was called on his mission to England. The oldest son, Joseph, was near 26 and near marriage; the oldest daughter was married, and may have already gone with other saints to colonize St. Johns, Arizona; James was 21; Elizabeth, called Eliza, near 19, and engaged, probably died while her father was on his mission; my father, Fred, was near 16; Harvey 14; Franklyn, 7; and the baby, Pearl, 5. (There had been three deaths between Harvey and Frankl and others earlier.) I suppose the family was comfortable, and the mission was no great hardship, but there were no luxuries. My grandmother had saved what the family called"butter and egg" money for many years. She gave it to Grandfather to bring back three things for her from England - a black silk dress, (how many pioneer ladies owned or wanted one?) a gold watch and chain, and a set of English china. My grandfather filled an honorable mission and was released; but instead og bringing Grandmother her desires )he used the money to pay the passage to America of a young English convert) who had been bapti~ed October 25, 1875. Her name was Sarah Ann Lord. She was born April 12, 1860, " at Brightrnet Hill, Lancashire, England. She was 29 years younger than my grandmother, 34 years younger than my grandfather, and he married her August 10, 1882 in the Salt Lake Temple. Quite understandably this une xpected event was re sented, especially by the older children. Two of them were married now. They knew this marriage must hurt their mother very much; but then, as later, my father became a peace maker. In fact it was my father who stayed longest at the horne farm to help his mother ~ and youngest sister; all the others married first. But he loved and respected his father, too, and always spoke well of him to his children. My grandfather was finally taken to the penitentiary during the polygamist raids in Utah. After his release,and after the manifesto in 1890 , he was forced tm choose which wife he would live with. He chose the younger woman, who lived in a new two-story red brick house in the bottom lands below the river hill where my gr~ndmother's house stood. My grandfather h§d five children by his second wife~. Mary Elizabeth,\ 1883; Joseph Brown, 1885; Adelaide, 1887; Enoch Truman, 1890; Zina Taylor, 1893. This last child was born when my grandfather was 67 years old. I do not know how things were between the two wives, nor between my grandmother and my grandfather, but relations could not have been entirely strained. The second mafriage was in 1882. In 1887 my grandparents went to the Salt Lake Temple and had their first four children sealed to them. These had been born before the parents were sealed in 1861 . All the other children were born under the covenant. Grandfather's second marriage was not altogether happy. His second wife WaS very different from the first. She had a sharp tongue, and a shrill voice. As children ,we did not go down the hill to play. And when Grandfather became older and ill, -w:e sensed that Sarah Ann was not a very patient nurse; but I am sure her life was not all sunshine either; she was so much younger than her husband. Grandfather's first wife died in 1904. She had lived 22 years after his second marriage. S~ven of her children survived, though 4 Frank would die a year after his mother. Grandfather died March 17, 1912, eight years after my Grandmother. He is buried in the Mill Creek cemetery near 9 East and 45 South - now called Elysian Gardens. His second wife died July 4, 1941. She was 81 years old. The three graves are on part of the lot my father owned;~he and my mother,and my oldest brother are buried there also. A pointed whitestone shaft with a red sandstone base marks my grandmother's grave. Low flat granite stonescemetery regulations- mark all the rest. I remember very little about my grandfather as I said at first. But when I was a very small girl he would sometimes walk from his home below the hill to our house- north on 6 West- a distance of half a mile or mor~,and sit under the shade of the trees. He only came in summer. He would never come into the house, nor stay long. He walked with a cane, and had a long white beard. And I remember his death. I was not quite ten. I remember I was taken to see his body the night after he died. He was lying in a large cold, unused room on the ground floor. I do not think he had been put in-;;the casket yet. It is all very vague; except for one thing, I was very surprised and curious about the pieces of money on my grandfather's eyes. I remember nothing else; not even how I felt. The story of the funeral had better been told by my mother. I guess she and father had decided that my brother William, who was seven and two thirds, and I-:':not quite ten- need not miss school to go to the funeral. So we were duly sent that morning as usual. But I proce\ded, after walking the mile and a quarter to school, to tell my teacher of my grandfather's death. What I said)I don't remember, but I must have asked to be excused, and proceded to get my brother excused also. We walked all the WaY back home. My mother was very surprised, to say the least. She was also very annoyed. The horse was groomed and shiny, and hitched to the equally shiny surrey. Mother and Father were neatly dressed in proper mourning apparel, and my brother Rollo- five, going on six, and my baby sister, not quite two, were clean and shining, too. And it was late, and my parents were out of the house and ready to step into the surrey. My brother William and I were not clean and shiny, and we were not dressed for a funeral. But of cQurse, we couldn~t be left home ~lone, nor sent back to school. I waS scolded; ~ were undressed, scrubbed, brushed and re-dressed more suitably and hustled into the shiny black phaeton_type rig. I can't quite remember, but I think my parents did not get to Grandfather's homl!L~ before the funeral , or at least, they were late ~nd kept everyone waiting; but we all arrived at.the Wa;d House on time. I remember nothing else of that day. But I do know that the Carlisle family was greatly respected; the five tall, goOd-loaking sons, and the two stately daughters that I knew all marrieli,\lkn and women- all in the Salt Lake Temple; all were active church members; so were most of their 39 children. I do not know how many grandchildren there were from the second marriage, but three of the five children married in the temple. Grandfather's property was extensive enough that it was divided into farms for all his eleven living children and the widow of Franklin; and most of us grandchildren grew up on those farms. There were also the farms of Grandfather's two brothers; this was adjoining land; five of their children had homes nearby, and we had perhaps another twentyfive or thirty second cousins to play with, to visit, to go to school and to church with. I work in the Temple wi til one of those second cousins- Erma Carlisle Ronenkamp. Many of the familiea living farther east attended our school, but it was, I think, very appropriately named the CarliSle School, Granite District, in Salt Lake County, Utah. Written November. 1972/by Maurine Carlisle Nielsen. 1. Joseph Carlisle. 2. Born: July 21, 1826, Sherwood-on-the-hill, Nottinghamshire, England. 3. Death: March 26, 1912, Mill Creek Ward, 39 South 7 West, Sal t Lake County, Utah. 4. Arrival: September 15, 1852. 5. Henry Bryant - Manning Jolly Seventh Company. 6. Married: Isabella Sharp, May 1852; sealed 1861 , Salt Lake City . Sarah Ann Lord, August 10, 1882 , Salt Lake City. 7. Written by: Maurine Louisa Carlisle Nielsen, October 1972. 8 9. Submitted by: Maurine Louisa Carlisle Nielsen, October 25, 1972. Weber County, Camp Y. HJST~Y~ HJST~£A~:V;~\\~~j:c~, John and JaJIles O. Hamilton o~med the first thresher in the ward. grain where the Hotel Utah now stands. They \~r~shed And wl:en the Relief' Society wa.s called to store wheat the sisters would go out and glean and these boys would thresh their grain and not take any toll. Jack Hill opened the first pleasure resort known as Hillis helt their picnics. P~k. Here the ward In the winter he put up ice from the pond. and h&d a number of men telivering ice to Salt Lake City. Jo~~ George B. Bailey WaB the Bee man. ward flowe~ C. Carlisle was the milk man. with milk and honey. Rag bees and ~uilting bees were held in practically every home. come and sew in the day time. The ladies would Then in the eventng the men would come o.nd trip the light fantastic to the tune of Jimmy t'la.lkerls fiddle. happy family; love and harmony prevailed. affected. So, the If They were just like one big, one~as in trouble, the whole ward was They enjoyed the faith of each other and was 8.ble to gi va help where help was needed. Foul' large wards have been divided from Millcreek, Wilford, Miller J Windsor J and · Valley Center ~la.rds ,and in 1946 we now have e, population of one thousand., four hu.ndred in the ward. • ~17 March Joseph Carlisle, born 21 July 1826, 1912. , Sheerwood-on-the-Rill, Notte, England, iied Among the first settlers in the western part of Mill Creek were Joseph Carlisle and his wife, Isabella Sharp Ca.rlisle, ~migrants of 1853. City, Joseph Carlisle walked south into Mill Creek, seeking turned west and came to the Jord.an River (located at West). 8. Upon arrival in Salt Lake R plac~ to settle. He place about 44th South and 7th Here they macie their hOlile permp..nently. An Indian trml ran alongside the house, and for a nu.mber of years, tribes of Indians passed. by their door during the summer months J springs a short distance farther along the hill. on their way to camp at the .~ > ,>, J~loEPS, .: ' " .. " " l." .. ,: ''If rnOlletary garn : -8~ The Indians admired Joseph Carlisle because he was fearless, and for this reason '. he could counsel with them; and he was Rent for if any trouble broke out with the Indians in the neighborhood. " , The Indians, also, call~d on him for assistance, especially in helping them bury their dead, which help he gave - generally burying them on the hills no~far from the bank of the r1ver. :Between the c.rows and the Indians, quite a heavy toll was made on the corn crop. The Indians would help themselves to the green corn, taking sackfulls at a time. The squaws aleo helped themselves to the waterJ:lelons, 2.ncl would wrap so many in their shawls tha t they would rollout and burst at frequent intervals all the w~y be~k to their One squa'" came to the home one day an", begged them to hide her as she had done camp. something for which her tribesmen were going to take her life. They burro,,,ed a hole down through the top of the straw stack and hid the squaw in the holp.. The Indians searched the premises for days but were unable to find the squaw; ann Joseph Carlisle found a ride for her with some man who was traveling into the southern part of the state, and so, she made her escape. In 1960, Joseph Carlisle bought a new "Schettler" wagon which he lend to the church to send back to Omaha to bring back emigrants. Joseph Carlisle's youngest bro- ther, Richard M. Carlisle, a young ms.n in his early twenties, made a number of trips back to Omaha, to help in this respect. (Joseph Carlisle was among the first to plant alfalfa (lucern) seed whEln it was introduced into S~lt Lake City.) In the ea,rly seventies, when the grasshoppers were iestroying the crops, Joseph Carlisle rea~ed u bounteous harvest, as the hordes of grasshoppers that tra.veled from the east bench, in swarms I came past the door and finally hopped into the river, at the bend, and were destroyed. Joseph Carlisle and Isabella S. Carlisle were the parents of thirteen children, all born at this place. He o\vned land from 2.nd West to the river, a.nd to ~~urray South; . and also bought a piece of the church farm "Then i t was offered for sale. (He was one of the first Board o f G·overnors a f 1,1ill ' Creek, serVing wi th John Snedaker and Ed\'lard M. Guest.) .'.,' : . . ....... .. . . . .~ . : . . ',- .', ' .: ' '. : on the Utah Sponsor Beehive Chapter, 2002 Location: 3850 South Jordan River Parkway - directions to get there : The monument is in Holm Park, which is a trailhead in the Jordan River Parkway system in SLC, UT. At the intersection of 3900 South (alk/a Meadow Brook Expressway) and 700 West, tum north and go one block to 3800 South (Carlisle Park Lane). Tum left (west), drive past apartments and open fields until you reach a stop sign at Carlisle Place which is 1000 West. Stay on Carlisle Park Lane as it heads toward a wooded area and curves left (south) between the apartments and woods. The street dead ends at a picnic pavilion and playground area called Holm Park. On a pathway west of the playground is a large sign about the park. North of that sign along the trail is a brick wall monument with the Carlisle Family SUP plaque. The plaque itself faces west toward the trail. In the 1850' sand 1860' s, three brothers, Joseph, John, and Richard Carlisle, settled in this location between 700 West and Jordan River Their endeavors included farming, dairying, and planting mulberry trees to raise silk worms. They developed a gravel pit on the west side of the river They were family men of strong character, active in public schools and the community. The "Carlisle School" was built near here. It was a five-room brick building which served students in the area from 1905 until 1923. Many of their children, grandchildren and great grandchildren settled and remained in this area. Carlisle Lane was a popular access to the Jordan River for irrigating, fishing, bird hunting, swimming, and berry picking. From this Carlisle family, like many other families from the "3900 block," came great men who fought for their country and honorable citizens who cared greatly about their community. Utah - Salt Lake Page - 161 I • ~-------~.----.----- 4159 S. 700 West Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah Carlisle, Sarah A., House -.- DBSC. #,£,.t,.. O wner '. Addre •• -:=:-r-r-- -"..---..,----:----=:----:;;:- ---:;:;-..,-....,..-;-:,.,..- : - - - - - Location Kind of Building Stories Ru-~ Street Cia .. Type Dimensions C 1-2- 3~ No.'ft co.t L-/~' 3£ Sq . Ft . F t. $£;£ ~ x $ A ctual Factor Totals $ Condition No . of Rooms I I I \ \ I \ T ota l Additions and DeduC!iOnSi_ _t/ -_ _ _ _-'-_-':\ _ _.:.:...._ _ _ _U_______ Net Additions or Dedu ction. Age'_ _ _ __ Yrs. by I I \ R EPRODUCTION VALUE_ $. _ _ _ _ __ Depr. Owner Records Cars 1-2-3 ~-5-6 Reproduction Val. M lnu. Depr._ Remodeledl _ _ _ _ Est. Co.t,_ __ _ _ Garage-S-8-C '* E.t. Tenant N eighbors Out Bldg.. Depr. 2% 3%_ __ Wallsi_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ $. _ _ _ _ __ $, _ _ _ _ _ __ $, _ _ _ _ __ ----------------11$'- -------- - - - - - ----11 $'_ _ _ __ Roof_ _ _ _ _ _ Slze__ X-.-Age_ __ Floor Co. Remark.,_ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ ___ Deor. Value Garaa __ Tota lt $,_ __ _ __ Ob.al e.cenc·<-_ _ _ _--IIl$~ T ota l Buildlna Valu. Appraisedl_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 19_-'-_~ __"i,- _...._ S~riat- No. 1$=- : 0 0/' 71 7 /5"/9 - //.5"S- . Clau Stories 4Cu. Ft. Dimensions I x x /~ / x x J~ I drl" - / ails _ _ _ Clgs• "..'""~5:)hc.:; !. .l "r',f' --_+----U -----t----~I La:gL ·-----+--~_:_;/'-il Md. _ _ - _ _ La: l e Med. -- rs'l" @ /cir @ Porchea - Front Rear I' -=- \ Porch Metal Awnings . .,I'-----+--___ --il Mti . ..... )-/, /-;; Dormers-8mall~ Addition. . nCone. - - - - - No'ne - - + - - - - 1 1 Cl",m m Bay. - Small • 3p? /) I / of Building. ~ Insulation-Floors _ _ _ Roof Type Totals Fir. _ _ Wall. _ _ICI. _ _ DelCrlpti~ ExLWallS Factor J ~I J x x Gar.-Carport __ x _ F oundatIon ' -Stone Sq. Ft. - \ tJ 0 / 100 ~ J.! / () tI- " _. @ ~I _ @ - - - - + - - - - - - i l Basement Ent,.. _ _ _ _ _-+__+ I __ Plantar. - Plumbing ! @ ---t------il F~I J.. FIOO~ - - - - - + - - - - - U Bsmt. A!'t. _ _ _ Rooma Fin. Attic Rooms Fin I \- 'A 'f.. 'h 73 % Cellar-Bunt. - Mti. ---.J W- Unf:n. - - - + - - - - - 1 1 -LJUnfin . - -- - --+-------il Cla.s _ _ \ _ Tub ' Trays _ Eaain __-_ _ Sink ~\ Toilet ------i ...'. St. _ _ _ _ O.T . __ Wtr. Sft,.. _ _ SlIr I a rbage Disp. - -- - + - - - - 1 1 -----+I --'Ir--------1~----1I H ea t -Stove ~ H.A . __ Ste4m;~ttk'" _ _ Blr. _ Dishwasher Built-In-Appliances Oil _ _ Gaa _ _ Coal Air Cond . ./11 P ipel. • _ _ R adianl_-+-_ _ _ _--il - _ _ _-+_ _ __ ~I F inlsh- Fi,. l(' Hd. d. - -+ \ -------i F1oor- F'ir _ /_ _ Hd. d . _ _ _ _\i- 0lher _ _ _---1I-_ _ _-l1 I Cabinets Mant Tile - Wall. Storm Sash- 9 - --- - -\\-- - - - - + - - -- --11 Wa nIIeot Wood D. - -=---':-100,." S. --=- ; Metal, ' ..:::.... S. --- - + - - - -- --il I \ Total Additions Year Built roo Curren~ Value / Inf. by J?vMer - Tenantl Neighbor - Record Remodel Year Est.-Cost Est. Commiss\on Adj. Bldg. Value % If Depr. Col. 1( 2) 8 4 6 6 :J """ Current Value Mlnua Depr. Garage - Class _ _ _ Depr. 2% 3% Carport - % $ /)~/) Faetor - - - - - I I Car. ---FlooJ ( - - Wa lls _ __ Roof _ _ _ Doors p- Size - _ _ _ x Other ... - - .\ ge x - - % 11--- -- - - - Cost _. ~T~o~ta~l~ ~~u~il~d~in~g~V~a~lu~e_ _~S_ _ _ _ ___ Appraised _ _Ll--'-_----'J'-'S==----___ 19 sf; By I LIt:> ~ - Harold J. Wa~dle % Uaxwell W. Kirk 15A-1155 17 West 5th Ave., Clty 84107 Co:n 363.95 ft S fr (Serial No.-Owner-AtiI.-Desc. of Property} FRON· 0 z; A~~ f!ll'O d . .., Clty 7 :.1r_L 1 1159 Jo . 7th ~eJt -J LIJ ns COl' ~e c 2 , T2S , RliV: (.) 0: SL ~er. W 22 5.13 it tQ eeR Qt laRe; S 5°50' E 11 2. 21 it; S 81°30' E 114.7 tt; N 3 it; E 69 it; S 57 it; W 10 tt; S 20 ft, E 30 ttl U 205 it to beg. 0.56 Ac. i J. ~ /5/iJ - //S5 15·4C)? ci z: ...J iU (.) a:: ~ FRONTAGE OR AREA DEPTH FACTOR / . /..p". & S 5°]J I 91' ~ ~; w .. , ' it to 3ig Cot ton 001 c!.. to Ii' line 3d f t . r 1 to b .. - . l./ '3 .. ~ 1~ J . ?7 ly Ill '" .. t:~ i! oJ ; :1 ~. ~ '- . 1 -, FRONTAG cj Z D c --'.! CO'D .3 6 • J3 H S f ::~ c 01' : .... 0 2 , ': 23, H 1 t SL ":0 , " 2<: ).13 it to cen of L:l.1 I Harold J. lardle 15-491 4159 So. 7th lest Ctt)' 7 5 it S fr NE cor Seo 2, T 2S, Com 363.9 W 225 l3 it to cenotLane ~ ~:50~L~~~~3.97 it'to Big cotto~.OOdd C k- S~'ly alg ad creek to E 1 ne s ree 2;" t ... ~525 8 ft II or 1 to beg. 1.&8 Ae Sec • I OR AREA I i /.~R I Q. I - - - Harold J. WuJle 4159 So. 7th West - .-._- _. City 84107 15A-1I55 0 1----- - Co~ 363.95 ft S fr HE cor Sec 2, T 2S, R lW, SL Mer, W 225.13 ft to cen ofLane S 5°50' E 199 .97 ft to Big Cottonwood Creek; SS'ly alg sd creek to Eline s1 Sec 2; N 525.8 ft m or 1 to beg. 1.69 Ac z: -J FRONTAGE OR AREA DEPTH FACTOR R LIJ (.) a:: cr a.. /. ~R ,4~ (:-;) ( .,. , - I" l----l- !:I I--, I l ; 1 I ._ _ ' I _ ---t : , ; " : _ I , ' I--- . - TC-74 Rev. ~7 STATE OF' UTA H _ - 261\1 STATa TAX COMM ISSI ON Age , II: --_ . I - - - ___ Size I 'Ar... ' ,I I I . - ..... i .L_ I Fae., tor -,.1 ., ' D1 x 1 I _...L I 1 -- f x o l ' ~ I ---~ lI : --;- I;;> x J -t I_ - ~ I ' -- I I ,;; TOTA~ Rem"rlca: _ ! J +-+--+ ---1 ---1- _. ~_ J RESIDENTIAL OUT BUILDINGS !'S. ' I -:~---I--.---J I 1----- Ii- I-r--+--L I- Li r ' Ii ; ---I I __ _--+- ~ I -I . _~_1I ' I ' ; I i I - 1 " i _i--+_-+--1 i = i - - ~ ! JI ---- -II I +1 : : I ' ~ ' -+-'; --r- T -; ---; - I! if-I I' I X X '" . .., 1 J .. z-., _ L TVDer,r-= " -= Ue +-- J I I Coot J 1- =r=r= _ ') J JllEj~ j =J:r 15 - - /-...- 1J.rse irr~~ j AX COM,Ml~SION Ownu·. Nome ~.a.;:..._A.____ ~ _ . __._-._..___.______ .0.,;.,', ""d""/~;-.7:•. M . ~~r-~£-;4--l!M Loeatioll _~ .....~ ..... ' ..~............._. _ ...~............_..._~., :Z_.-.-:...- ..-(2-~. ~Q. Kind of Bulldlng ... __._......_ ..._ ....... _ ......._...__.._._ Street No.2.L_ .. " ! . Schedule Stodeo CI ......_.:.:__ ..:._ Baoe Pactor.~.... _':,...:'-'_...!.__..__'._ •~ J , -. .'CAt; - .L.:..!...__ Dlmeulo No. of Room... .--1------.---.- - _.:'!.________ D ..crlption pound.llon-Stone......! _._ ~. Conc .__ .. _._ Roof-Type________ Mat._._._._ .. Lo Dormers-SmaIL.:.-- Med._ _ _ Bay.-SmalL._. _ _ Med. _ _ __ / /).1/ 'I x_...t-...":-~,_-;, _ _-V'--+:-..L~ Porchel-Pront. Rear _ _ ._--x.~.@... Baaemcn'--_ _-".._ _ _ P100'.._ _ _+-_ 1 Attlc-Room .._ _ _ Pln. _ _ _ Unfln. CIRII-___._ Tub _ _. T.a ._.._.._. Plumblng- B••ln..___ Sink--. Tol t.._ _. { Urlnals_ _ _ _ pountai7 - : - - - .. _- I " _ _1_ _• Heat-Stove.___ H. A. ___. SlU) m f- S.___ !__\-_ PIDlab- {Hd. Wd.__ PloorsPIr.. _.___ Cabinets..Tile- d. Wd_._ _ 1'1••_ ._._.. Mantel; ... --\-- n --~-- _. _ _. ._._. {~:.:~! -:::::::=-=-_= _..::::-_-::=:=:==~-::.= .._ . ~~~ng~:=~~_~=~~t~_~_ :::::~=~: ===._. - ..··-············-·-·-·······.. ······..···-1....··-··..····-..............-.-..-.. .-....-...---.. =::::::~::::~:::::=::::~::::::::~~::I:::=::~::=::~~::~:::~::::~:=::~::. :~==:==- . . ___ I Deductlon•...____.._........_ .. .__ ..__ '7';" Q.f . __.._ "'Ie::. Total Addition. rd .__....._ _=L. .._. __.. _ Net Addition 0. Deductions _____.___._..__ ._.__._.____..,.__ ..___ .. .____....: ::....-::!...L l Est. Owner Age _ _ _ Yrs. by Tenant Neighbors Record. Reproduction Val. Minus _yj---____.__. Remodelecl..-_ _ _ E.t. Coot Garage-S 8-C Cara.___ ._.__ ~ Remodeling Inc. OblOle.cenco ~~.._ .._._....__.._. ___._. .~._._.._. Roof.._. _ _ _ SlZe;.,.....x_ _~: ~ ploor. __._..__.____ Co.L-2 "_"_'" }C( . , f' .._......_.__ .___________./'" ..-....L;.....::... __. ......--jj~--.-.-.--. -.----"T/ Depredatd "Value ...___..._ _.. __..___ .. TOTAL BUILDING VALUE... Remarltt Original Record ..... ___._..._. _ _ _ _.___._ ...._._.._._. __ _ Carel No .. _ _ _...___ Year·_ _ _ _ _._ By_ _ __ I :2 LJL:... /1 / $.-r-'-?.-1.LJ.,. / -_..__.._-_._------__ .0. ___ _ _ .• _ _ •_ _ _ _ _ .... __ ._._ ..•. _._ ..••_. ___ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ ••__•__ •__ - .... ...~....."'L .~.~.._..::l!... .1.-.. r--' - .. ........ - ..- ......- ...r-..- . - - . - - - - - - --- . , _ _ _ __ -==._....l...;;:1-'<::::..:._: .._._._..__ ..-.. ......................... ................. _ •••• _ .••••.•• _ •••••••. _ •••••.• .•••••••. _ •• _~ •. _ ::: ••.• ~••••••• 4~__ •• _-_......_-_..._._ _---- ..._..•. ...,..!.. ........__........_...::.... -- -_:. . .=_: -----_.._.- /~ -- ..-.-.----..--...-..- -:L--.- ..-..-................-... ---------..------..-.-.--.---....-.- . =:::=:=::::~~~~:=··--;-··-=-·:~~2-.:~:::=~::~::~:~==-.l!:..z.~_~.~"---- ---~-=:~ ~P7 -_ _--. .. _._.__._._._---_._-_._---_._--_._-_. ;' _.- ..__ .._..- .._-_._._---_._._ .. _--_._..._--_._.._-_._-.._..- ......-_..-_. _._-.....- ... ,/ _.._..__._._._..___._______.___.__........_.___1__-"-.__'.:.:_.....:;_-"::.....!-_~"-_-:... ___I -'I --- _ _ _- : - _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ • • _ ___ • • .;,t...••• _ ~ . _:. _ _ _ • __ • _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ .!._L_ _ - __ ..... _ I For.. T.e. 74 -." Y n ,l . ____ ' _________ -.:£. .._.. ?-- ;-v RECORD OF ASSESSMENT OF IMPROVEMENTS ____________________ COUNTY SERIAL NO. _ _ _ _ __ OWNER'S NAME _______________________________________ OWNER'S ADDRESS _____________________________________ L~TmN ___________________________________________ FORM TC·748 STATE OF UTAH STATE TAX COMMISSION GOTTSCHALL PTG . 8 - 3a Sarah A. Carlisle 4159 So. 6th lest Cit)' Co. at SE cor of Sec S.L. Jer. " 10 rds I I 751 0 I 20.2 rds to up river to Sec Iloe ! N 34 rds ot lot 7, 13-678 35, T 1S, R 11, 12.8 rds • 8 rds Jordan River Sly E to bag. 4 lot 1 Sec 2. T 2S, R 11 S. L. Mer. Being in lots 12, 13. 14 ! 15, BIt 1, 10 Ac. Plat B, B.'. Sur. 16.97 Ac. Page Untitled Document 1 or 1 Assessor --> Parcel Search --> Valuation Summary --> Printable Version Parcel 21-02-228-008-0000 Owner Address Total Acreage Above Ground sqft. Property Type Tax District KNOWLES, MADELYN; TR (MKFT) 4159 S 700 W 0.38 1402 111 - SNGL FAM RES 21A Value History Record Land Value Building Value Market Value Tax Rate 2013 S 72,200 S 45,000 $ 117,200 not set 2012 S 69,900 S 49,400 .0126960 .0117950 2011 1 S 89,900 S 55,200 $ 119,300 $ 125,100 2010 1 $ 70,600 $ 55,900 $126,500 S 74,500 s 52,600 $127,100 .0108690 S 76,800 S 75,800 $152,600 .0093800 2009 2008 1 .0122490 .. s M u rr.] 40.681 122260,-111 .910814520 Land Record Record ID Lot Use Lot Type Land Class Income Flag Seasonal use Influence Type RESIDENTIAL PRIMARY-LOT Influence Effect Assmt. Class Lot Depth Acres Zone Sewer Number Lots RES-PRIMARY 0.38 3000 PUBLIC Lot Shape Lot Location Neighborhood Nbhd Type Nbhd Effect Topography REGULAR INTERIOR 385 STATIC TYPICAL LEVEL Traffic Traffic Influence Street type Street Finish Curb Gutter Sidewalk LIGHT TYPICAL DEAD-END PAVED N N Residence Record Building Style Assessment Classification Extrior Wall Type Roofing Central AC Heating Owner Occupied Number of Stories Total Rooms Bedrooms CB P SO AS N 0 Y 2.0 7 3 Full Baths Extrior Condition F 3/4 Baths Overall Grade F Half Baths F Overall Condition Number of Kitchens A Visual Appeal Finished Fire places Maintenance A Year Built 1900 Conformity E 1985 Livability Effective Year Built A F Primary Kitchen Quality Interior Grade 0 Intrior Condition A Primary Bath Quality 0 Extrior Grade A Percent Complete 100 Above Grade Area + Basement Area: 1402 Main Floor Area Upper Floor Area Finished Attic Area Above Ground Area Basement Area Finished Basement Area Finished Basement Grade Carport Surface Area Attached Garage S. Area Builtin Garage S. Area Basement Garage S. Area 970 432 1402 Click here for Parcel Characteristics Search Again? This page shows the assessor's CAMA data , as It was on May 18 20 13 http://assessor.s1co.org/cfmIlQueryNaluationInfoPrint.cfm?parceljd=21022280080000&...1129/2014 TITLE SEARCH FORM ADDRESS: 4159 S. 700 West TAX NUMBER: CITY" Murray, Salt Lake County, Utah 84123 LEGAL DESCRIPTION AND ACREAGE: CURRENT OWNER: Madelyn Knowles BEG S 364.48 FT FR NE COR SEC 2, T 2S, R 1W, SLM; S 77.03 FT; W 217 FT M OR L, N 51\50' W 77 FT M OR L, E 225 FT TO BEG . 0.38 AC M OR L. HISTORIC NAME: Carlisle, Sarah A., House DATE BUILT· 21-02-228-008 0.38 acres 1897 Oate of Instrument Date of Record GRANTOR (seller) GRANTEE (buyer) Type of Transaction 04-30-1880 12-31-1952 United States of America Joseph Carlisle PATENT May 13,1895 patent to James Carlisle 08-31-1897 09-14-1897 Joseph Carlisle Sarah A. Carlisle WD 10.80 acres 01-28-1905 03-08-1905 Joseph Carlisle Sarah A. Carlisle WD 05-09-1938 06-16-1938 Co-Operative Security Corporation Sarah Ann Carlisle; Joseph B. Carlisle RELMTGE release mortgage in Bk 205 p.589 07-04-1941 1941-1944 estate of Sarah Ann Lord Carlisle Joseph B. Carlisle; Edna L. Carlisle; etc ADMIN & EXE DEEDS death certificate properties divided 03-02-1951 03-05-1951 Joseph B. Carlisle , widower Maxwell W . & Nola Kirk WD 06-07-1958 12-16-1960 Joseph Brown Carlisle deceased DEATH CERT 10-25-1960 12-16-1960 Utah State Tax Commission estate of Joseph B. Carlisle 05-25-1966 06-08-1966 Salt Lake County by Auditor Harold J. Wardle TAX DEED joint tenant with step-father Joseph B. Carlisle 05-21-1970 08-06-1971 estate of Harold J. Wardle, incompetent A. A. Pallet Company ORDER & GUARDIAN DEED Harold J. Wardle c/o Maxwell W . Kirk 12-05-1975 12-12-1975 estate of Harold J. Wardle Leo D. Knowles & Bill D. Puckett ORDER & Maxwell W . Kirk & GUARDIAN DEED N. G. Kirk Knowles? 05-03-1979 05-20-1981 05-07-1979 05-28-1981 Murray City To Whom It May Concern ANNEX PLAT 10-22-1998 10-22-1998 Leo G. Knowles, joint Leo G. Knowles Trust SWD Allan Boldt, 1987 05-23-2013 05-30-2013 Madelyn Knowles, Leo & Madelyn Knowles Family Trust Madelyn Knowles WD Russell L. & Barbara L. Wigren, 1985-1987 10-11-2013 05-23-2013 Madelyn Knowles Celestino & Maria Salazar WD RESEARCHER: PDR DATE: 2016 Dollar Amount COMMENTS PAGE 1 of 1 253.26 PI 227013 KAY LOT 2 AMD SUB 7 12 6 13 - ~~~ - - --- - -- - - 7 PI 228001 PI .'1 q, ~ 227014 . 28 ---"'58"'.'J:f:'~1 I \ 01 221007 <{ ~ ~ ---------------------- -- 220002 .91 ~\ 1-_=.;;........'--_--"'29 =~9~_-_-_-_~ .21 229.63 PI 226007 144 .90 I- 1- - --- - - -- --- --- - ---- - - - - 227005, 239.50 I~ PI 24.3 \~ <{ 22800J 13 227003 I ",I f'-:' .91 .66 -J ~\ r ------------~ .'" I I ___ 228008 ~~------.-- ~2~~~ , - - - - - - - - - 274 .04 .38 " ', - ST , I .-1 . - ---- - -- - - - -- -- - - - ---\-- i - -- - 227010 + ---!-- - -- - - - -- 0 4170 S I I I 308.06 I I 101022 I I I I 2.77 I I ..,1", NI..-: 2211010 .c\c") r;\ll! I 22fJ1)(}7 59.10 o I I I I I \ I 101022 1.48 , .to I I I I I I 10t012 306.00