Likelihood of Diagnosing Neuroblastoma in Isolated Horner Syndrome

Background: The need for an extensive evaluation for neuroblastoma in children with Horner syndrome is controversial. Methods: A retrospective study design was used. The cohort included 47 children with anisocoria who were diagnosed with Horner syndrome and 135 children with neuroblastoma evaluated at a pediatric medical center between 2007 and 2015. To detect neuroblastoma, patients with Horner syndrome underwent brain and cervical MRI, abdominal ultrasound, and/or measurement of urinary vanillylmandelic acid (VMA). The neuroblastoma group was evaluated for signs/symptoms of Horner syndrome at the time of diagnosis. Results: Seven patients with Horner syndrome were lost to follow-up, and the findings of the remaining 40 were categorized according to the age of the patient. Horner syndrome most frequently was idiopathic (58%), and in only 1 patient did the discovery of neuroblastoma precede the appearance of Horner syndrome. In the 21 patients aged 1-18 years, Horner syndrome was acquired in 15 patients and congenital in 6. The most common etiology was trauma (62%). Imaging was performed in 14 patients and VMA testing in 13. Neuroblastoma was diagnosed in 5 patients; in none was it related to Horner syndrome. In the 135 patients with neuroblastoma, most of the tumors were diagnosed at Stage 4 (60%) or Stage 3 (30%) with 53% originating in the abdomen. In one patient (0.74%) with signs/symptoms of Horner syndrome at diagnosis of neuroblastoma, the tumor had been identified prenatally and the diagnosis confirmed by imaging postnatally. Conclusions: The absence of occult neuroblastoma in children with Horner syndrome and of signs/symptoms of Horner syndrome in the children diagnosed with neuroblastoma suggests that Horner syndrome might not be as frequent a cause of neuroblastoma as previously thought. We recommend that full investigation for neuroblastoma be reserved for suspicious cases associated with additional systemic signs or symptoms.