Comparing optimal cut-points from the Youden index and Euclidean index

Update Item Information
School or College School of Medicine
Department Public Health Division
Project type Master of Statistics (MSTAT): Biostatistics Project
Author Barbeau, William
Title Comparing optimal cut-points from the Youden index and Euclidean index
Date 2021-04-23
Description Screening and diagnostic tests, based on continuous biomarker measurements, have be- come essential tools in medicine. Designing diagnostic tests based on continuous biomarkers is challenging because the biomarker's distribution in the population with the disease and population without the disease are rarely completely separated. Overlap in these two distributions means the test will always result in misclassification. The Youden index and Euclidean index (AKA the point closest to (0,1)) are two popular methods for choosing optimal cut-points to maximize sensitivity and specificity of diagnostic tests. Despite both of these methods being described and deployed in practice, there is little guidance on which method to use and at which situation. Through mathematical derivations, we show in the binormal case that the Euclidean index, relative to the Youden index, yields optimal thresholds with lower absolute deference's between sensitivity and specificity, especially when the difference in biomarker variances is large. If developers of diagnostic tests aim to maximize sensitivity and specificity for normally distributed data, then the Euclidean index is the preferred optimal cut-point method.
Type Text
Publisher University of Utah
Subject Statistics; biostatistics
Rights Management (c) William Barbeau
ARK ark:/87278/s6qg4swj
Setname ir_dph
ID 1703770
Reference URL https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s6qg4swj
Back to Search Results