Publication Type |
Journal Article |
School or College |
College of Science |
Department |
Physics |
Creator |
Wu, Yong-Shi |
Title |
Wu replies |
Date |
2010 |
Description |
The preceding Comment [1] on my Letter [2] and Haldane?s Letter [3] cites three old papers by Anghel [4], which contained an unfounded claim that the thermodynamics derived in Ref. [2] for a generalized ideal gas, based on the generalized Pauli principle proposed in Ref. [3], is physically inconsistent. Reference [4], as well as [5], invoked the division of a species into subspecies in an attempt to claim that the mutual statistics parameters cannot be constant as proposed in [2,3]. In this reply I explain why the argument and the claim in Refs. [4,5] were at least seriously flawed and, therefore, failed to be a credible challenge to Refs. [2,3]. At the end of this Reply I explain why the Comment [1] still contains a serious misconception of subspecies division. |
Type |
Text |
Publisher |
American Physical Society |
Volume |
104 |
Issue |
19 |
First Page |
198902 |
Last Page |
198901 |
Subject |
Quantum states; Quasiparticle excitation; Species; Subspecies; Species subdivision |
Subject LCSH |
Thermodynamics; Quasiparticles (Physics) |
Language |
eng |
Bibliographic Citation |
Wu, Y.-S. (2010). Wu replies. Physical Review Letters, 104(19), 198902-1. |
Rights Management |
© American Physical Society http://dx.doi.org/[Insert DOI here] |
Format Medium |
application/pdf |
Format Extent |
46,311 bytes |
Identifier |
ir-main,14193 |
ARK |
ark:/87278/s69c7fgd |
Setname |
ir_uspace |
ID |
702245 |
Reference URL |
https://collections.lib.utah.edu/ark:/87278/s69c7fgd |